TL;DR
This pilot study investigated whether a shared decision-making (SDM) intervention, including physician training and a novel visual aid, could improve decision quality for older men with lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS/BPH). While recruiting participants proved feasible, the intervention did not significantly improve decision quality compared to usual care, suggesting that more complex interventions may be needed to overcome barriers faced by this population.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Older men frequently experience lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) due to benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH). Deciding on the best treatment involves complex trade-offs, and ideally, this process should involve shared decision-making (SDM) between the patient and physician. However, older adults, particularly those with lower health literacy, face significant barriers to effective SDM. These barriers include limited physician training in SDM, assumptions about patient capacity, and the inherent complexities of multimorbidity and polypharmacy in older individuals. Existing decision aids are often not tailored to this demographic, being too complex or inaccessible. This study aimed to address this gap by piloting an intervention designed to facilitate SDM for older men with LUTS/BPH, focusing on improving decision quality.
Methods
This was a two-arm, randomized controlled trial. The intervention group received care from physicians trained in SDM and who used a novel visual analogue uroflowmetry score (VAUS) tool during consultations. The VAUS is a pictogram-based Likert scale designed to help patients assess their urine stream, aiming to be elder-friendly and accessible to those with lower literacy. The control group received usual care from physicians not trained in SDM and without the VAUS tool. Decision quality was assessed using the patient-reported Shared Decision-Making Questionnaire (SDMQ-9) and the physician-reported SDMQ-Doc.
Datasets
The study did not introduce new datasets or benchmarks. It utilized existing questionnaires (SDMQ-9 and SDMQ-Doc) for outcome measurement.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Feasibility Confirmed: The study successfully demonstrated that it is feasible to recruit older men with LUTS/BPH and their physicians for a pilot randomized trial, even with a multi-ethnic Asian population.
- VAUS Potential: The VAUS tool, designed for elder-friendliness and lower literacy, shows promise as a communication aid, though its impact on decision quality in this pilot was not statistically significant.
- SDM Barriers Persist: Despite the intervention, decision quality did not improve, suggesting that physician training and a single visual aid may not be sufficient to overcome the multifaceted barriers to SDM in this population.
- Physician Engagement: The high participation rate of physicians indicates their recognition of the importance of SDM in clinical practice.
- Differing Perspectives: While not statistically significant, patients in the intervention group reported slightly higher decision quality scores than in the control group, hinting at a potential, albeit small, benefit.
Key Results
- Recruitment: 413 men were screened, 153 were eligible, and 60 men (30 per arm) were randomized. The recruitment rate was slower than anticipated, with a significant proportion of eligible men declining participation due to perceived lack of benefit or time constraints.
- Participant Demographics: The study population consisted of older men (mean age 70±9 years), predominantly Chinese (87%), with a substantial proportion having no formal education (40%) and lower socioeconomic status (32%).
- Decision Quality (Patient-Reported): The intervention group had a higher mean SDMQ-9 score (70.8) compared to the control group (59.5), but this difference was not statistically significant after adjustment for multiple testing (adjusted p=0.352).
- Decision Quality (Physician-Reported): The mean SDMQ-Doc score was also higher in the intervention group (78.1) than the control group (73.2), but this difference was not statistically significant (adjusted p>0.999).
- No Drop-outs: All randomized participants completed the study, and there were no missing data, indicating good adherence to the study protocol.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Generalizability: The findings may not be generalizable due to the convenience sampling of participants.
- Response Bias: Participants might have provided socially desirable answers in questionnaires.
- Cross-Contamination: There's a possibility of trained physicians influencing untrained colleagues.
- Sample Size: The pilot study was underpowered to detect a statistically significant difference in effectiveness.
- Protocol Development: Participants were not involved in the development of the study protocol.
Future work should focus on addressing the multifactorial barriers to recruitment and exploring more comprehensive interventions for SDM. The authors suggest involving community members in future trial design and evaluating the impact of SDM interventions from the perspective of the physician-patient dyad, potentially incorporating interdisciplinary approaches.
Summary updated