Making Sense of the Robotized Pandemic Response: A Comparison of Global and Canadian Robot Deployments and Success Factors

Tim D. Barfoot, Jessica Burgner-Kahrs, Eric D. Diller, Animesh Garg, Andrew A. Goldenberg, Jonathan Kelly, Xinyu Liu, Hani E. Naguib, Goldie Nejat, Angela P. Schoellig, Florian Shkurti, Hallie Siegel, Yu Sun, Steven L. WaslanderarXiv 2020 · arXiv

Introduction

The COVID-19 pandemic acted as an unprecedented global "stress test" for robotics technology. While media reports frequently highlighted "hero robots" performing tasks like hospital disinfection and grocery delivery, the reality on the ground revealed a significant gap between experimental demonstrations and reliable, large-scale deployments. This research, produced by the University of Toronto Robotics Institute, evaluates over 60 robot platforms to identify why certain regions pivoted faster than others and how Canada can optimize its robotics strategy.

Methodology and Frameworks

To distinguish between hype and utility, researchers employed a multi-disciplinary qualitative approach. This included extensive stakeholder interviews across healthcare, transportation, and manufacturing sectors, alongside a review of over 60 global platforms.

Central to the analysis was the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) scale (1–9), with a focus on systems at TRL 7 or higher—those ready for immediate pilot or scaling. Furthermore, the team developed a pathway model based on the intersection of Desirability, Feasibility, and Viability. This framework categorized deployments into four pathways:

  1. Deploy: Immediate use of existing technology.
  2. Transfer: Short-term adaptation of existing systems.
  3. Roboticize: Short-term automation of manual tasks.
  4. Develop: Mid-to-long term R&D for novel challenges.

The Global Landscape: Success Factors and the "Murphy Rule"

A primary finding of the study aligns with the "Murphy Rule" of disaster robotics: the systems most successfully deployed during a crisis are those already in common use before the event. Emergency responders and frontline workers rarely have the capacity to learn unfamiliar technology during a high-stakes crisis.

Furthermore, the study highlights teleoperation as a critical "autonomy bridge." While full autonomy in unstructured environments remains a long-term goal, supervised autonomy allows robots to be useful today by letting humans handle complex edge cases remotely. While disinfection robots captured public imagination, the most significant growth occurred "behind the scenes" in logistics and manufacturing, where companies like OTTO Motors and Avidbots met surging demand caused by labor shortages.

The Canadian Context: Strengths and Strategic Gaps

Canada presents a unique paradox. According to the Economist Intelligence Unit’s Automation Readiness Index, Canada ranks 5th globally, trailing only South Korea, Germany, Singapore, and Japan. This high ranking is driven by robust education and workplace policies.

However, when looking specifically at "Innovation Policies & Regulations," Canada drops to 23rd out of 25. This indicates a lack of strategic coordination between government, academia, and industry. Historically, Canada has functioned more as a "sales office" for international robotics firms rather than an industry-focused R&D hub. While space robotics (e.g., Canadarm) has seen significant long-term investment ($1.4B over 35 years), other strategic robotics funding has become fragmented since the wind-down of the PRECARN/IRIS networks in 2010.

Moving Forward: A Unified Robotics Roadmap

The paper concludes that technical feasibility (high TRL) does not guarantee market success. To transition from a cautious adopter to a global leader, Canada requires a Unified National Robotics Roadmap. Key recommendations include:

  • National Asset Inventory: Mapping existing robotics capabilities across the country.
  • Frontline Guidelines: Establishing clear protocols for piloting robots in public and healthcare settings.
  • Vocational Training: Focusing on training robot operators and technicians, not just high-level researchers.
  • Regulatory Harmonization: Aligning Canadian standards with international frameworks (like the EU) to support export-ready innovation.

By shifting from fragmented, early-stage experiments to a coordinated strategy focused on pre-existing, reliable platforms, Canada can better prepare for future crises while strengthening the high-tech sector, which currently represents approximately 5% of the national GDP.

Summary updated

Abstract

From disinfection and remote triage, to logistics and delivery, countries around the world are making use of robots to address the unique challenges presented by the COVID-19 pandemic. Robots are being used to manage the pandemic in Canada too, but relative to other regions, we have been more cautious in our adoption -- this despite the important role that robots of Canadian origin are now playing on the global stage. This white paper discusses why this is the case, and argues that strategic investment and support for the Canadian robotics industry are urgently needed to bring the benefits of robotics home, where we have more control in shaping the future of this game-changing technology. Such investments will not only serve to support Canada's current pandemic response and post pandemic recovery, but will also prepare this country to weather future crises. Without such support, Canada risks falling behind other developed nations that are investing heavily in hardware automation at this time.
BibTeX
@misc{barfoot2020making,
  author = {Tim D. Barfoot and Jessica Burgner-Kahrs and Eric D. Diller and Animesh Garg and Andrew A. Goldenberg and Jonathan Kelly and Xinyu Liu and Hani E. Naguib and Goldie Nejat and Angela P. Schoellig and Florian Shkurti and Hallie Siegel and Yu Sun and Steven L. Waslander},
  title = {{Making Sense of the Robotized Pandemic Response: A Comparison of Global and Canadian Robot Deployments and Success Factors}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2009.08577},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.08577},
}
Figure