MAGNETOROTATIONALLY DRIVEN SUPERNOVAE AS THE ORIGIN OF EARLY GALAXY r -PROCESS ELEMENTS?

C. Winteler, Roger Käppeli, Albino Perego, Almudena Arcones, Nicolas Vasset, Nobuya Nishimura, M. Liebendörfer, F.‐k. ThielemannThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates magnetorotationally driven supernovae (MR-SNe) as a potential source for the early universe's "r-process" elements. By simulating these extreme events with a 3D MHD code and performing detailed nucleosynthesis calculations, the authors demonstrate that MR-SNe can indeed produce the observed abundance patterns of heavy elements, offering a compelling explanation for their presence in the early Galaxy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The origin of heavy elements synthesized through the "r-process" (rapid neutron capture) remains a significant puzzle in astrophysics. While neutron star mergers are considered a primary source, their early appearance in the universe, particularly in metal-poor stars, poses a challenge. The authors explore an alternative: magnetorotationally driven supernovae (MR-SNe). These are core-collapse supernovae (CCSN) where rapid rotation and strong magnetic fields launch powerful jets, potentially creating the extreme conditions needed for r-process nucleosynthesis. Previous models of neutrino-driven supernovae and even some other explosion mechanisms have struggled to produce the right neutron-rich conditions and sufficient quantities of r-process elements. This paper aims to determine if MR-SNe, specifically those with high rotation and magnetic fields, can successfully explain the observed r-process abundances in the early Galaxy.

Methods

The study employs a multi-pronged approach:

  • 3D Magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) Simulation: The core of the work involves a 3D MHD simulation of a core-collapse supernova using the FISH code. This code solves the ideal MHD equations and incorporates a spectral leakage scheme for approximated neutrino transport. The simulation models the evolution of a massive star's core after collapse, focusing on the formation and propagation of bipolar jets driven by magnetic fields.
  • Tracer Particles: Lagrangian tracer particles are embedded within the simulation to record the thermodynamic history (density, temperature, electron fraction) of individual fluid elements. These particles are crucial for post-processing nucleosynthesis calculations.
  • Nucleosynthesis Calculations: The thermodynamic histories from the unbound tracer particles are fed into an extended nuclear reaction network. This network calculates the abundances of synthesized elements. Two sets of calculations are performed: one using the electron fraction ($Y_e$) directly from the simulation, and another that incorporates an estimate of neutrino absorption effects on $Y_e$ during post-processing. This allows the authors to assess the impact of neutrino interactions on the final elemental yields.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a pre-collapse model of a 15 $M_\odot$ star from Heger et al. (2005) as the initial condition for the MHD simulation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MR-SNe as a Viable r-process Site: The simulations strongly suggest that MR-SNe can create the necessary neutron-rich conditions for efficient r-process nucleosynthesis, particularly in the ejected material from the bipolar jets.
  • Role of Neutrino Absorption: While the primary MHD simulation doesn't explicitly include neutrino absorption in the hydrodynamics, post-processing calculations show that neutrino absorption can shift the electron fraction ($Y_e$) towards higher values, broadening the distribution. However, even without this refinement, the core r-process peaks are reproduced.
  • Jet-Driven Nucleosynthesis: The powerful bipolar jets launched in these MR-SNe are identified as the primary sites for the strong r-process production, carrying neutron-rich material outward.
  • Explaining Early Galaxy Abundances: The rarity of the required progenitor configurations (high rotation, strong magnetic fields) aligns with the observed scatter in r-process element abundances at low metallicities, suggesting that MR-SNe could be responsible for seeding the early universe with these heavy elements.

Key Results

  • The 3D MHD simulations successfully produce bipolar jets, confirming that these are not artifacts of axisymmetric models.
  • Nucleosynthesis calculations, both with and without estimated neutrino absorption effects, reproduce the second (A~130) and third (A~195) peaks of the solar r-process element distribution.
  • The peak electron fraction ($Y_e$) in the ejecta is found to be around 0.15-0.17, and this distribution is broadened towards higher $Y_e$ when neutrino absorption is considered.
  • The ejected mass ($M_{ej}$) is estimated at $6.72 \times 10^{-3} M_\odot$ and the explosion energy ($E_{exp}$) at $8.45 \times 10^{49}$ erg, indicating a significant production of r-process material per event.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Progenitor Rarity: The paper acknowledges that the specific progenitor conditions (high rotation, strong magnetic fields) required for MR-SNe are thought to be rare (perhaps 1% of massive stars). This rarity, however, is seen as a strength, potentially explaining the observed scatter in r-process abundances.
  • Neutrino Transport Approximation: The neutrino transport is approximated using a spectral leakage scheme. A more sophisticated, fully 3D radiative transfer treatment of neutrinos would be beneficial.
  • Nuclear Mass Models: The nucleosynthesis calculations were performed using a specific nuclear mass model (FRDM). Testing with different mass models is suggested to address discrepancies in abundances between the r-process peaks.
  • Extrapolation of Thermodynamics: Thermodynamic variables for tracer particles are extrapolated beyond the end of the MHD simulation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future studies should investigate the impact of progenitor parameters (mass, magnetic field, rotation rate), nuclear input, and a more consistent treatment of neutrino interactions on the robustness of their conclusions. They also highlight the ongoing effort to perform long-term global 3D simulations of CCSNe with more sophisticated neutrino radiative transfer.

Summary updated

Abstract

We examine magnetorotationally driven supernovae as sources of r-process elements in the early Galaxy. On the basis of thermodynamic histories of tracer particles from a three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamical corecollapse supernova model with approximated neutrino transport, we perform nucleosynthesis calculations with and without considering the effects of neutrino absorption reactions on the electron fraction (Y e ) during post-processing. We find that the peak distribution of Y e in the ejecta is shifted from 0.15 to 0.17 and broadened toward higher Y e due to neutrino absorption. Nevertheless, in both cases, the second and third peaks of the solar r-process element distribution can be reproduced well. The rare progenitor configuration that was used here, characterized by a high rotation rate and a large magnetic field necessary for the formation of bipolar jets, could naturally provide a site for the strong r-process in agreement with observations of the early Galactic chemical evolution.
BibTeX
@article{winteler2012magnetorotationally,
  author = {C. Winteler and Roger Käppeli and Albino Perego and Almudena Arcones and Nicolas Vasset and Nobuya Nishimura and M. Liebendörfer and F.‐K. Thielemann},
  title = {{MAGNETOROTATIONALLY DRIVEN SUPERNOVAE AS THE ORIGIN OF EARLY GALAXY <i>r</i> -PROCESS ELEMENTS?}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1088/2041-8205/750/1/l22},
}

Loading related content...

Figure