Magnetophoresis-Assisted Capillary Assembly: A Versatile Approach for Fabricating Tailored 3D Magnetic Supercrystals

Pierre Moritz, Antoine Gonon, Thomas Blon, Nicolas Ratel‐Ramond, Fabrice Mathieu, Pierre Farger, Juan M. Asensio, Simon Cayez, David Bourrier, Daisuke Saya, Liviu Nicu, Guillaume Viau, Thierry Leïchlé, Lise‐Marie LacroixACS 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel, cost-effective method called magnetophoresis-assisted capillary assembly to precisely arrange magnetic nanoparticles into complex 3D structures. This technique allows for the creation of high-performance, rare-earth-free permanent magnets and soft magnetic materials that can be integrated into micro-devices, paving the way for advanced portable electronics and sensors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The miniaturization of electronic devices, particularly for applications in telecommunications, automotive, and biomedical fields, demands the integration of small, powerful magnetic components. Traditional methods for fabricating these sub-millimeter magnetic materials often face challenges related to cost, complexity, material limitations, and achieving precise control over shape and properties. Specifically, creating tailored 3D magnetic structures with high performance has been a significant hurdle. This paper addresses this challenge by presenting a versatile and efficient method to assemble magnetic nanoparticles into desired supercrystal architectures.

Methods

The core of this work is the magnetophoresis-assisted capillary assembly technique. This process leverages two key principles:

  1. Magnetophoresis: Magnetic nanoparticles, suspended in a liquid, are guided and aligned by an external magnetic field. Specifically, the method utilizes patterned ferromagnetic structures (like nickel blocks) that act as flux concentrators, creating strong local magnetic field gradients. These gradients attract the magnetic nanoparticles to specific locations.
  2. Capillary Forces: As the solvent evaporates from the nanoparticle suspension, capillary forces help to compact and solidify the assembled structures into stable supercrystals.

The authors also employed:

  • Finite Element Simulations (Comsol Multiphysics): Used to map and predict the magnetic field gradients generated by the patterned flux concentrators, crucial for understanding and optimizing the assembly process.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and X-ray Diffraction (XRD): For structural characterization of the fabricated supercrystals, including nanorod alignment and crystallographic orientation.
  • Vibrating Sample Magnetometry (VSM): To measure the magnetic properties (magnetization, coercivity, energy product) of the resulting magnets.
  • Hall-effect Micro-probe: To measure the magnetic stray field generated by the fabricated magnets.
  • MEMS Gravimetric Sensor: Used as a proof-of-concept to demonstrate the functionality of the fabricated magnets in actuating a micro-device.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of Magnetophoresis and Capillary Action: The combination of directed magnetic forces and solvent evaporation provides a powerful and precise way to assemble nanoparticles into complex 3D structures.
  • Flux Concentrators are Key: Using patterned ferromagnetic materials (Ni blocks or Fe bars) is critical for generating the localized, strong magnetic field gradients needed to attract and assemble nanoparticles effectively.
  • Versatility in Nanoparticle Choice: The method works with both anisotropic (Co nanorods) and isotropic (Fe₂.₂C nanospheres) magnetic nanoparticles, enabling the fabrication of different types of magnets (permanent and soft).
  • Rare-Earth Free Magnets: The ability to create high-performance permanent magnets from cobalt nanorods offers a promising alternative to rare-earth-based magnets, which have supply chain and environmental concerns.
  • Scalability and Integration: The process is relatively simple, cost-efficient, and time-efficient, making it suitable for fabricating integrated magnetic components for micro-devices and potentially for large-scale production.

Key Results

  • High-Performance Permanent Magnets: Fabricated Co-NR based sub-millimeter magnets exhibited magnetic properties comparable to NdFeB-based composites, with a coercive field of 590 mT and an energy product of 30 ± 3 kJ.m⁻³.
  • Millimeter-Scale Self-Standing Magnets: The process was extended to create millimeter-sized, self-standing magnets with similar magnetic performance, achieving an energy product of 37 ± 3 kJ.m⁻³.
  • Effective MEMS Actuation: The fabricated Co-NR magnets successfully actuated a MEMS gravimetric sensor over distances up to 600 µm, demonstrating their potential for integrated magnetic actuation.
  • Soft Magnetic Supercrystals: Fe₂.₂C nanoparticle supercrystals were fabricated with soft magnetic properties, showing a coercive field of 25 mT and a saturation magnetization of 400 ± 20 kA.m⁻¹.
  • Precise Nanoparticle Alignment: SEM and XRD characterization confirmed good alignment of Co nanorods along the applied magnetic field direction, with an angular dispersion of 16°.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Inter-particle Interactions: While the method is effective, the paper notes that inter-particle interactions (e.g., agglomeration of Co NRs) can influence the assembly process and may require further control.
  • Surface Oxidation: The authors suggest that performing the assembly under an inert atmosphere could prevent nanoparticle surface oxidation and potentially increase the magnetic volume fraction of the assemblies.
  • Extension to Other Magnetic NPs: The authors propose that this fabrication process is not limited to Co and Fe-based nanoparticles and can be extended to other magnetic nanoparticle systems, opening avenues for diverse magnetic material development.
  • Further Optimization: While the current process is efficient, further optimization of parameters like suspension concentration, solvent choice, and magnetic field application could lead to even better control over supercrystal properties and density.

Summary updated

Abstract

The fabrication and integration of sub-millimeter magnetic materials into predefined circuits is of major importance for the realization of portable devices designed for telecommunications, automotive, biomedical, and space applications but remains highly challenging. We report here a versatile approach for the fabrication and direct integration of nanostructured magnetic materials of controlled shaped at specific locations onto silicon substrates. The magnetophoresis-assisted capillary assembly of magnetic nanoparticles, either spherical or anisotropic, leads to the fabrication of high-performance Co-based permanent magnets and Fe-based supercrystals. Integrated sub-millimeter magnets as well as millimeter self-standing magnets exhibiting magnetic properties competing with NdFeB-based composites were obtained through this cost- and time-efficient process. The proof-of-concept of electromagnetic actuation of a micro-electromechanical system cantilever by means of these supercrystals highlights their potentiality as efficient integrated magnetic materials within nomadic devices.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{moritz2021magnetophoresis,
  author = {Pierre Moritz and Antoine Gonon and Thomas Blon and Nicolas Ratel‐Ramond and Fabrice Mathieu and Pierre Farger and Juan M. Asensio and Simon Cayez and David Bourrier and Daisuke Saya and Liviu Nicu and Guillaume Viau and Thierry Leïchlé and Lise‐Marie Lacroix},
  title = {{Magnetophoresis-Assisted Capillary Assembly: A Versatile Approach for Fabricating Tailored 3D Magnetic Supercrystals}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/acsnano.0c10215},
}
Figure