Magnetoelectric Sensor Operating in d15 Thickness-Shear Mode for High-Frequency Current Detection

Fuchao Li, Jingen Wu, Sujie Liu, Jieqiang Gao, Bomin Lin, Jintao Mo, Jiacheng Qiao, Yiwei Xu, Yongjun Du, Xin He, Yifei Zhou, Lan Zeng, Zhongqiang Hu, Ming Liu2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel magnetoelectric (ME) current sensor designed for high-frequency applications, such as those found in smart grids. By utilizing a d15 thickness-shear mode, the sensor achieves a resonant frequency around 1 MHz and demonstrates superior performance compared to traditional tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) sensors in detecting fast transient currents.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate and rapid detection of high-frequency currents is crucial for the reliable operation of modern power grids and electronic equipment. These currents, often generated by switching operations, lightning strikes, or partial discharges, can pose significant threats to sensitive components. Existing sensors, like shunt resistors, optical sensors, Hall effect sensors, current transformers, and Rogowski coils, have limitations in terms of bandwidth, accuracy, cost, or contact requirements. While magnetoresistive sensors, particularly TMR sensors, offer good performance, their accuracy degrades significantly at high frequencies (MHz range), and they are expensive to manufacture. This creates a need for a cost-effective, high-frequency current sensor with a quick response.

Methods

The researchers developed a magnetoelectric (ME) current sensor by combining a PZT piezoelectric ceramic layer with a Metglas amorphous alloy layer. This composite is designed to operate in the d15 thickness-shear mode. In this mode, the magnetostrictive layer (Metglas) is excited by a magnetic field (induced by the current) to vibrate longitudinally, which in turn causes the piezoelectric layer (PZT) to undergo shear strain. This shear strain generates an electrical signal proportional to the applied magnetic field, and thus, the current.

Key aspects of their method include:

  • Material Selection: PZT for piezoelectricity and Metglas for magnetostriction.
  • Structure: A layered composite with PZT layers transversally poled and sandwiched between the magnetostrictive layer and a rigid layer.
  • Operating Mode: Specifically designed for the d15 thickness-shear mode, which is distinct from other common ME sensor modes.
  • Fabrication: The composite is integrated into a magnetism gathering ring to concentrate the magnetic field from the current-carrying wire.
  • Testing: Comparative experiments were conducted against a commercial TMR current sensor to evaluate performance in the MHz frequency range.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements and finite element analysis simulations rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • d15 Thickness-Shear Mode Advantage: The paper highlights the effectiveness of the d15 thickness-shear mode for high-frequency ME current sensing, offering a unique approach compared to more common ME sensor configurations.
  • Resonance-Enhanced Sensitivity: The sensor exhibits a prominent resonance peak around 1.036 MHz, leading to significantly enhanced sensitivity at this frequency. This resonance is tunable by adjusting the PZT thickness, offering flexibility in sensor design.
  • Superior High-Frequency Performance: The proposed ME sensor demonstrates a more stable and less distorted output waveform at frequencies up to 3 MHz compared to a commercial TMR sensor, which shows significant distortion at higher frequencies.
  • Cost-Effectiveness Potential: While not explicitly quantified, the materials and design suggest a potential for lower manufacturing costs compared to high-end TMR sensors.
  • Wide Dynamic Range: The ME sensor maintains good linearity and tracking performance over a wider current range than the tested TMR sensor, suggesting its suitability for diverse applications.

Key Results

  • Resonant Frequency: The ME sensor achieved a resonant frequency of approximately 1.029 MHz, with a prominent peak observed at 1.036 MHz in the impedance spectrum.
  • Sensitivity: The sensor demonstrated a resonance-enhanced sensitivity of 11.42 mV/A at 1.029 MHz.
  • Limit of Detection (LOD): The ME sensor achieved a current LOD of 3.82 μA at 1 MHz, comparable to the commercial TMR sensor.
  • Frequency Response: The sensor maintained stable output waveforms up to 3 MHz, whereas the TMR sensor showed significant distortion at 2.5 MHz and complete distortion at 3 MHz.
  • Linearity: The ME sensor exhibited better linearity and a larger testing range compared to the TMR sensor, especially at currents above 100 mA.
  • Error Analysis: The ME sensor's fluctuations (errors) were within a range of -3.18% to 3.47% when fitted to a Lorentz curve, comparable to the TMR sensor's errors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Shielding: The authors acknowledge that the signal noise of the ME sensor could be reduced by improved shielding, suggesting this as an area for future circuit design optimization.
  • Eddy Current and Faraday Effects: At MHz frequencies, eddy current loss and Faraday effects in the ferrite magnetism gathering ring can weaken the ME coupling effect near resonance, posing a challenge for high-frequency detection.
  • Further Optimization: While the sensor shows promise, further work could focus on optimizing the ME coupling effect and mitigating the negative impacts of eddy currents and Faraday effects at higher frequencies.
  • Broader Frequency Range: Extending the investigation to even higher MHz frequencies and exploring different ME composite configurations could unlock further potential.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{li2024magnetoelectric,
  author = {Fuchao Li and Jingen Wu and Sujie Liu and Jieqiang Gao and Bomin Lin and Jintao Mo and Jiacheng Qiao and Yiwei Xu and Yongjun Du and Xin He and Yifei Zhou and Lan Zeng and Zhongqiang Hu and Ming Liu},
  title = {{Magnetoelectric Sensor Operating in d15 Thickness-Shear Mode for High-Frequency Current Detection}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/s24082396},
}

Loading related content...

Figure