Magnetization Plateaus in One DimensionalS=1/2Heisenberg Model with Dimerization and Quadrumerization

Wei Chen, Kazuo Hida, Hiroki NakanoJournal of the Physical Society of Japan 1999 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The one dimensional $S=1/2$ Heisenberg model with dimerization ($1-j$) and quadrumerization ($\delta$) in the magnetic field is studied by means of the numerical exact diagonalization of finite size systems and the conformal field theory. It is found that the magnetization plateau at half of the saturation value exists for $\delta \neq 0$. For $\delta = 0$, this model is described by the conformal field theory with central charge $c=1$ at this value of magnetization. The critical exponent $\nu$ which characterizes the $\delta$-dependence of the width of the plateau is calculated using the level spectroscopy method. The $j$-dependence of the critical exponent $\nu$ is found to be non-monotonic and discontinuous at $j = 0$. The effective theory of the magnetization plateau is also presented for various limiting cases.

Introduction: The Search for Magnetization Plateaus

In the study of quantum magnetism, one-dimensional Heisenberg chains serve as a fundamental model for exotic physical phenomena. While a uniform chain typically behaves as a "gapless spin liquid," introducing spatial modulations like dimerization (alternating bond strengths) can induce an energy gap, effectively "freezing" the spins.

When a magnetic field $H$ is applied to these systems, the magnetization $m^z$ usually increases continuously. However, in non-homogeneous chains, the magnetization can become "stuck" at specific values, forming what is known as a magnetization plateau. This research investigates a model combining dimerization (controlled by $j$) and quadrumerization (controlled by $\delta$). The primary objective is to understand how these structural modulations interact to generate plateaus and to determine the critical exponents describing the plateau's growth.

Magnetization curve $m^z$ versus magnetic field $H$, illustrating the plateau at $m^z=0.25$ (half-saturation).

Methodology: Bridging Finite Systems and Infinite Limits

The researchers utilized a two-pronged approach to analyze the spin chains:

  1. Numerical Exact Diagonalization: Using the Lanczos method, they calculated the ground state and low-lying excited states for finite-sized systems (up to 28 sites). This provided direct access to magnetization curves and energy gaps.
  2. Conformal Field Theory (CFT) and Level Spectroscopy: To extrapolate results to the thermodynamic limit, the system at the critical point ($\delta = 0$) was treated as a Gaussian model with central charge $c=1$. Level spectroscopy was then employed to extract scaling dimensions and critical exponents from the energy levels of finite systems, bridging the gap between numerical data and universal physical laws.

Key Insights: Symmetry Breaking and Discontinuities

The study revealed several critical features of the quadrumerized Heisenberg model:

  • Robustness of the Plateau: A magnetization plateau at $m^z = 1/4$ (half of the saturation value for $S=1/2$) emerges immediately upon the introduction of any quadrumerization ($\delta \neq 0$).
  • The $j=0$ Discontinuity: A striking finding is the discontinuity of the critical exponent $\nu$ at $j=0$. This point represents the transition where alternating bonds switch from antiferromagnetic to ferromagnetic.
  • Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking: For $j > 0$, the exponent $\nu$ is found to be less than 1. This suggests the possibility of "spontaneous quadrumerization," where the lattice might distort to lower its energy, pinning the magnetization plateau in a manner analogous to the spin-Peierls transition.

Results: Scaling and Phase Diagrams

The numerical analysis confirmed a central charge $c \approx 1$ at the critical point, validating the CFT approach. The width of the plateau, defined by the difference between critical fields $H_{c2}$ and $H_{c1}$, scales as $H_{c2} - H_{c1} \sim \delta^\nu$.

Phase diagram in the $H-\delta$ plane for $j=0.5$, showing the emergence of the $m^z=1/4$ plateau as quadrumerization $\delta$ increases.

The exponent $\nu$ exhibits distinct behaviors depending on $j$:

  • For $j > 0$, $\nu$ remains relatively constant at approximately $0.8$.
  • As $j$ approaches $0$ from the negative side, $\nu$ increases sharply toward $2$.
  • At exactly $j=0$, $\nu = 1$.

Because $\nu$ is smaller for positive $j$ (antiferromagnetic alternating chains), the plateau is predicted to be more easily observable in such materials compared to ferromagnetic ones.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While the study is limited by the finite size of the simulated systems, the use of extrapolation techniques like level spectroscopy provides robust predictions for the thermodynamic limit. The authors suggest that the synthesis of real materials with quadrumerized structures is the next logical step. Observing a "field-induced spin-Peierls transition" in such materials would provide definitive experimental validation for the predicted spontaneous symmetry breaking.

Summary updated

Abstract

The one dimensional $S=1/2$ Heisenberg model with dimerization ($1-j$) and quadrumerization ($\delta$) in the magnetic field is studied by means of the numerical exact diagonalization of finite size systems and the conformal field theory. It is found that the magnetization plateau at half of the saturation value exists for $\delta \neq 0$. For $\delta = 0$, this model is described by the conformal field theory with central charge $c=1$ at this value of magnetization. The critical exponent $\nu$ which characterizes the $\delta$-dependence of the width of the plateau is calculated using the level spectroscopy method. The $j$-dependence of the critical exponent $\nu$ is found to be non-monotonic and discontinuous at $j = 0$. The effective theory of the magnetization plateau is also presented for various limiting cases.
BibTeX
@article{chen1999magnetization,
  author = {Wei Chen and Kazuo Hida and Hiroki Nakano},
  title = {{Magnetization Plateaus in One Dimensional<i><i>S</i></i>=<b>1/2</b>Heisenberg Model with Dimerization and Quadrumerization}},
  journal = {Journal of the Physical Society of Japan},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1143/jpsj.68.625},
}
Figure