Magnetic Stress Sensing System for Nondestructive Stress Testing of Structural Steel and Steel Truss Components Based on Existing Magnetism

Guangyuan Weng, Jintao Wang, Yang Liu, Xiyu Zhu, Jianbo Dai2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel magnetic stress sensing system that leverages the inherent magnetism of structural steel to perform nondestructive stress testing. By analyzing changes in magnetic flux, the system can accurately assess stress levels in steel structures, offering a promising alternative to traditional methods that require knowledge of loading history.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Structural steel components, particularly in bridges and buildings, are subjected to varying loads throughout their service life. Accurately monitoring their stress state is crucial for ensuring structural integrity and preventing failures. Traditional stress testing methods often rely on strain gauges, which require direct attachment and can be invasive. Furthermore, many methods necessitate knowledge of the component's loading history, which is not always available or easily determined in real-world scenarios. This paper addresses the challenge of developing a nondestructive, online stress detection method that circumvents the need for loading history information and can be applied to existing steel structures.

Methods

The core of this research is a magnetic stress sensing system that exploits the magnetomechanical effect in ferromagnetic materials. This effect describes how stress influences the magnetic properties of a material. The system comprises:

  • Magnetic Flux Induction Coil: A probe designed to measure magnetic flux.
  • Magnetic Flux Measurement Device: A fluxmeter to quantify the magnetic flux.
  • Loaded Device: A universal testing machine to apply controlled stress.
  • Data Acquisition Software: To record and process the measurements.

The methodology involved:

  1. Establishing a Magnetic Stress Flux Mathematical Model: Researchers conducted magnetic coupling tests on various grades of structural and bridge steel specimens. They analyzed the relationship between magnetic flux changes and stress, developing a fitting equation to describe this relationship.
  2. Developing a Practical Formula for Stress Detection: Based on experimental data, a formula was derived to directly calculate stress from magnetic flux measurements.
  3. Testing on a Steel Truss Model: A scaled-down model of a 24m steel truss structure was built and subjected to static loading. The magnetic stress sensing system was used to measure stress in various members.
  4. Comparison with Traditional Methods: The results from the magnetic stress sensing system were compared with those obtained from traditional strain gauges and finite element analysis (FEA) simulations.

A key innovation is the focus on "existing magnetism". Instead of applying an external magnetic field, the system leverages the residual magnetism already present in the steel. This simplifies the setup and makes it more practical for in-situ applications.

Datasets

The paper utilized a variety of structural steel specimens, including:

  • Structural Building Steels: Q235B, Q345B, Q390B, Q420B.
  • Structural Bridge Steels: Q235qD, Q345qD, Q375qD, Q420qD.

These specimens were prepared in various diameters (12, 16, 20, 25, 28, and 32 mm) and lengths to account for different geometric influences. A total of 120 specimens were used for initial magnetic property characterization and model development. For the steel truss model testing, seventy-two specimens of different structural bridge and building steels were selected.

The paper does not explicitly mention the creation of new benchmark datasets for public release, but the experimental data collected on the steel truss model serves as a basis for validating the proposed method.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Existing Magnetism is Key: The research demonstrates that the inherent magnetism of steel is sufficient for stress detection, eliminating the need for external magnetic field excitation. This significantly simplifies the system's design and application.
  • Stress Alters Magnetic Flux: Stress applied to structural steel causes measurable changes in its magnetic flux, providing a direct link between mechanical load and magnetic response.
  • Unified Model Potential: The study suggests that a unified constitutive magnetic stress flux model can be established for structural steel specimens within the linear elastic range, regardless of grade and diameter, simplifying stress prediction.
  • Nondestructive and Online Capability: The developed system offers a nondestructive and online method for stress monitoring, overcoming limitations of traditional techniques.
  • Good Agreement Across Methods: The magnetic stress sensing system's results showed strong agreement with traditional strain gauge measurements and finite element analysis, validating its accuracy.

Key Results

  • A magnetic stress sensing system was successfully developed and tested.
  • A practical formula for stress detection based on magnetic flux variation was obtained.
  • The magnetic stress flux model showed good agreement with experimental results from strain gauges, with a maximum error of approximately 5% in the steel truss model tests.
  • The study confirmed that the magnetic flux of structural bridge steel is generally higher than that of structural building steel of the same grade.
  • The magnetic flux variation of structural steel specimens in the linear elastic range is related to steel grade and diameter, increasing with stress.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Component Geometry: The developed probe is primarily suitable for components with a circular cross-section. Future work could focus on adapting the system for components with different shapes.
  • Data Transmission: For in-situ engineering applications, data transmission from the magnetic fluxmeter can be a technical challenge. The authors suggest exploring wireless data transmission technology as an important research direction.
  • Complex Stress States: While the study addressed tensile and compressive stresses, real-world structural members often experience more complex stress states. Further research is needed to extend the method to these scenarios.
  • Service Conditions: The research was conducted under controlled laboratory conditions. Applying the system to structures in service, with varying environmental factors (temperature, humidity), requires further investigation.
  • Constitutive Model Expansion: While a model for the first monotonic loading process was studied, expanding this to cover more complex loading and unloading cycles would be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{weng2020magnetic,
  author = {Guangyuan Weng and Jintao Wang and Yang Liu and Xiyu Zhu and Jianbo Dai},
  title = {{Magnetic Stress Sensing System for Nondestructive Stress Testing of Structural Steel and Steel Truss Components Based on Existing Magnetism}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20144043},
}
Figure