Magnetic resonance safety assessment of a new trend: magnetic eyelashes

Cihat Eldeniz, Trevor Andrews, Uday Krishnamurthy, Lamyaa Aljaafari, Glenn Foster, Tammie L.s. Benzinger, Hongyu An, Pamela K. WoodardJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Magnetic eyelashes, a popular cosmetic, pose a significant projectile risk in MRI environments due to their strong magnetic forces. This study quantifies this risk using industry-standard testing, revealing that these eyelashes experience large deflections, making them unsafe for MRI scans and necessitating their removal.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) relies on powerful magnetic fields. While medical devices undergo rigorous safety testing for MRI compatibility, personal cosmetic items often fly under the radar. Magnetic eyelashes, a recent trend, present a potential hazard because they are small, may not be disclosed by patients, and can be easily overlooked by technologists. The concern is that the strong magnetic fields within an MRI scanner could turn these eyelashes into dangerous projectiles, posing a risk to patients and equipment. This paper aims to quantify this projectile risk by measuring the forces exerted on magnetic eyelashes within an MRI environment.

Methods

The researchers employed a standard industry method, ASTM F2052-15, to assess the projectile risk of magnetic eyelashes. They tested six different brands of magnetic eyelashes on a 3-Tesla MRI scanner. The core of the testing involved measuring the magnetically induced deflection force. This was done by suspending each eyelash with a string and measuring the angle it deflected when brought into the MRI's magnetic field. The deflection angle was measured using a protractor. The testing was conducted at a specific location within the scanner where the magnetic field gradient was known. While heating and torque tests were not performed due to the assumption that the eyelashes wouldn't stay in place, the deflection force was quantified by measuring the angle of deflection.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ubiquitous Magnetic Force: Even at magnetic field strengths below 1 Tesla, the magnetic eyelashes experienced substantial forces, indicating they are made of strong permanent magnets, likely neodymium.
  • Near 90° Deflection: The deflection angles were consistently large, often exceeding 90 degrees, demonstrating a strong pull towards the scanner's walls. This suggests a significant projectile risk.
  • Brand-Agnostic Risk: The deflection angles were remarkably similar across different brands, implying that the projectile risk is a general characteristic of magnetic eyelashes, not specific to a few manufacturers.
  • String Weight as a "Worst-Case" Scenario: The weight of the strings used for testing exceeded the ASTM standard's recommendation. However, this actually strengthened the findings, as the large deflection angles occurred despite this added load, suggesting even greater deflection would occur with lighter strings.
  • Beyond Projectiles: The paper highlights that even if not a direct projectile hazard, ferromagnetic objects in the MRI can cause artifacts, lodge in equipment, and lead to significant downtime for troubleshooting.

Key Results

The study found that all tested magnetic eyelashes produced large deflection angles, indicating significant magnetic forces. While specific numerical deflection angles varied slightly between brands (e.g., from 85.5° to 87.0°), the overall trend was consistently large deflections. The measured deflection forces (Fm) ranged from 3.0 mN to 10.0 mN. These large deflections confirm that magnetic eyelashes are MR unsafe and should be removed before entering Zone III of an MRI scanner room.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that heating and torque testing were not performed because it was presumed the eyelashes would not remain in place. They also note that the material composition of the eyelashes was not publicly available, though they inferred they were likely neodymium magnets. Future work could involve investigating the projectile risk at different magnetic field strengths (e.g., 1.5T) and exploring the potential for artifacts caused by these materials. The paper strongly recommends that magnetic eyelashes, and even magnetic eyeliners containing iron oxide, be removed prior to MRI scans to ensure patient and equipment safety.

Summary updated

Abstract

One type of cosmetic that has gained recent popularity is the magnetic false eyelash. Some of these magnetic eyelashes are placed onto magnetic eyeliner applied to eye lids, while others come in pairs and clamp around the natural eyelashes. This presents potential safety hazards in the magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) environment. This is because patients may not deem it necessary to disclose this type of cosmetic, the standard MR screening forms often fail to capture these accessories, and the eyelashes may not be readily noticed by the technologists. MRI artifacts caused by magnetic eyelashes were reported previously.1 However, in this study, we used industry standard testing methods specifically to examine the projectile risk. We quantified the deflection force experienced by magnetic eyelashes from various manufacturers. All tested products produced large deflections, indicative of significant magnetic forces. The translational forces were so strong that other effects (such as rotational forces, heating, and artifacts) could only be tested in a manner that is inconsistent with how a patient would present in a usual clinical setting. All deflection tests were performed on a 3-Tesla MR scanner (MR component, Biograph mMR, Siemens Healthcare, Erlangen, Germany) following the guidelines listed in ASTM F2052-15.2 Because it was presumed that the magnetic eyelashes would not remain in place as the subject moved into the isocenter of the bore, no heating or torque testing was performed. Eyelashes from six brands were tested: Arishine®, Lash’d Up™, Pinpoxe®, Lamix, Ardell®, and Lamiya [cf. Fig. 1(a)]. Arishine® and Lamix came with an eyeliner applicator. The material composition of the magnetic eyelashes was not publically available. However, they were all made of permanent magnets, which were most probably neodymium magnets.3 Figure 1(b) exhibits the magnetically induced deflection force measurement configuration, while Figure 1(c) depicts the physical coordinate system of the scanner. Initially, we intended to do the test at the location within the scanner where the spatial gradient of the field strength is within 20 percent of its maximum value along z, as described in Ref. [2]. Although the document provided by the manufacturer of the scanner did not have isogradient lines in this region, the spatial gradient forms a plateau centered at about (x, y, z) = (0, 0, 830) mm with values ranging from 3 to 5 T/m. However, when a magnetic eyelash was brought close to this point, it was pulled toward the wall of the bore (i.e. away from the bore axis), leading to a deflection angle that was more than 90 degrees. Therefore, the measurement location was chosen as (x, y, z) = (0, 0, 1078) mm, where the value of the isogradient line was available and reported as 3 T/m. The magnetic field strength at this location was <1 T. Given that common commercial permanent magnets like neodymium magnets do not become saturated at such low magnetic field strengths,4 it is reasonable to assume that the deflection force was proportional to the product of the field strength and the spatial field gradient. In accordance with the ASTM standard,2 each piece of magnetic eyelash was deflection-tested three times. The weights of the strings were also recorded. The magnetically induced deflection force was calculated using the mean deflection angle. The eyelashes of some brands — Lash’d Up™ (large piece), Pinpoxe®, Ardell®, and Lamiya (both pieces) — showed bending, related to the magnet base consisting of multiple small magnets rather than a single continuous piece. Furthermore, the string length required to knot the string both at the protractor and the magnetic eyelash showed some variation. Consequently, for each eyelash, the location of the protractor was adjusted until the eyelash reached the location of measurement cited above, making the lengths of the strings irrelevant. Due to the tilting of some magnetic eyelashes and in order to prevent the lash-component of the eyelash from touching the ruler (which was fixed at z = 1078 mm), the eyelashes were kept within a few millimeters of the target location (x, y, z) = (0, 0, 1078) mm. It is worth noting that the spatial gradient values change on a more macro scale (fractions of meters), so a margin of a few millimeters exerts only a negligible effect. Figure 1(d) lists the measurement results. The measured deflection angles were similar across different brands. With the deflection angles being much larger than 45°, the results confirm that ferromagnetic eyelashes are MR unsafe and should be removed before entering Zone III, the space before entering the MRI scanner room.5 Furthermore, with the deflection angles being similar across different brands, the heavier magnetic eyelashes are expected to experience a larger projectile effect. Finally, given the effect of the spatial gradient field component of the attraction force, the projectile effect can be significant, even at 1.5 T. It is worth noting that the weights of the strings were more than 1% of those of the eyelashes, which were extremely light-weight by design. This exceeds the limit recommended by the ASTM standard and thus requires an explanation.2 The excess weight would be a concern if the deflection angles were small since the string weight would be suspected to shadow the true deflection forces. However, in our study, it strengthens the case against magnetic eyelashes because the deflection angles were close to 90° despite this additional load. If it were feasible to use extremely light strings, the deflection angles would be larger. Failing the deflection test does not make a piece of equipment MR unsafe in and of itself; nevertheless, near the MRI scanner, the eyelashes can rapidly become a moving projectile as close as millimeters from the orbit of the eye and hence become a safety concern. In addition, even if they do not become a direct hazard to the patient, small ferromagnetic objects that get pulled into the MR system can remain there, or lodge within a receiving coil or accessory, potentially resulting in artifacts that may masquerade as pathology. Moreover, they could be relocated to hard-to-check areas, and troubleshooting could involve substantial scanner downtime. The magnetic eyeliner associated with some of these eyelashes are allowed to contain synthetic iron oxide under the current regulations of the FDA, 21 CFR §73.2250. It has been reported that, even with tattooed eyeliners that typically contain iron oxide, adverse events are unlikely, transient, and mild.6 However, like the false eyelashes themselves, magnetic eyeliners should be removed prior to the scan in order to ensure safety. The authors thank Gwyneth A. McDonald for her advice in the selection of magnetic eyelash brands. The authors have no conflict of interest to disclose.
BibTeX
@article{eldeniz2020magnetic,
  author = {Cihat Eldeniz and Trevor Andrews and Uday Krishnamurthy and Lamyaa Aljaafari and Glenn Foster and Tammie L.S. Benzinger and Hongyu An and Pamela K. Woodard},
  title = {{Magnetic resonance safety assessment of a new trend: magnetic eyelashes}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1002/acm2.12952},
}
Figure