Magnetic properties of the spin-1 chain compound NiCl3C6H5CH2CH2NH3

Ferdinand Lipps, A.h. Arkenbout, Alexey O. Polyakov, Michael Günther, Timur Salikhov, E. Vavilova, H.‐h. Klauß, B. Büchner, T. M. Palstra, V. KataevLow 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers investigated the magnetic properties of a novel Ni-hybrid compound, NiCl3C6H5CH2CH2NH3, which exhibits a one-dimensional chain structure of Ni²⁺ spins (S=1). While initial findings suggested it could be a Haldane spin-1 chain with a quantum spin gap, experimental results revealed an unexpected antiferromagnetic ordering at low temperatures, hinting at a complex, possibly inhomogeneous, ground state.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper delves into the fascinating realm of low-dimensional quantum magnetism, specifically focusing on one-dimensional (1D) spin chains. The "Haldane conjecture" predicts that 1D Heisenberg spin chains with integer spin values (like S=1) should possess a unique, non-magnetic "spin-singlet" ground state, separated from excited states by a "quantum spin gap." This gap is a purely quantum mechanical phenomenon, not arising from crystal field anisotropy. Finding real materials that exhibit this predicted Haldane state is a significant challenge in condensed matter physics, as real-world materials often have complexities like interchain couplings or structural imperfections that can lead to different magnetic behaviors, such as conventional antiferromagnetism. This paper aims to explore whether the synthesized Ni-hybrid compound, NiCl3C6H5CH2CH2NH3, with its Ni²⁺ ions arranged in chains, could be a realization of the Haldane spin-1 chain and to understand its magnetic properties.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged experimental approach to probe the magnetic properties of the Ni-hybrid compound:

  • Static Magnetization Measurements: Using a VSM-SQUID magnetometer, they measured the material's response to applied magnetic fields across a range of temperatures. This technique provides bulk magnetic properties like susceptibility and magnetization.
  • Electron Spin Resonance (ESR) Spectroscopy: ESR is a powerful local probe that investigates the magnetic properties of individual spins. They used X-band ESR (9.6 GHz) and high-field/high-frequency ESR (HF-ESR) up to 360 GHz, employing single crystals and powder samples. This allowed them to study the spin dynamics and identify different magnetic phases.
  • Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) Spectroscopy: Specifically, 35Cl NMR was used to gain further insights into the local magnetic environment and spin dynamics. This technique is sensitive to the magnetic fields experienced by the nuclei, providing information about magnetic ordering and fluctuations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements performed on synthesized samples of NiCl3C6H5CH2CH2NH3.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Promising Candidate for Haldane System: The structural arrangement of Ni²⁺ ions in chains and the isotropic nature of the Ni²⁺ spins (S=1) initially suggested this compound could be a prime candidate for realizing the Haldane spin-1 chain.
  • Unexpected Antiferromagnetic Ordering: Despite the initial promise, the material orders antiferromagnetically (AFM) at a Néel temperature (TN) of approximately 10 K, contradicting the expected spin-singlet ground state of a pure Haldane system. This suggests that interchain couplings, though weak, are significant enough to induce long-range magnetic order.
  • Evidence for an Inhomogeneous Ground State: Intriguingly, the ESR and NMR data reveal signatures that point towards a complex, potentially inhomogeneous ground state. This state might involve a coexistence of mesoscopically separated regions exhibiting AFM order and regions that still possess characteristics of a Haldane spin-singlet state.
  • Role of Structural Disorder: The authors speculate that small structural disorder within the Ni-chains could lead to fragmented chains of varying lengths. These fragments might develop AFM-ordered clusters at their ends, which then interact and order, while other segments retain their Haldane-like properties.

Key Results

  • Intra-chain Exchange Constant (J): Analysis of static susceptibility data yielded an antiferromagnetic intra-chain exchange constant of J = 25.5 K.
  • Predicted Haldane Gap: Based on the calculated J, a Haldane gap of approximately 10.5 K was theoretically predicted for a pure S=1 Heisenberg chain.
  • Néel Temperature (TN): Experimental data clearly indicated an antiferromagnetic ordering transition at TN ≈ 10 K.
  • Spin-Flop Transition: Magnetization measurements revealed a spin-flop transition at approximately 3.5 T, characteristic of an antiferromagnetic system.
  • ESR Signatures: ESR measurements showed an isotropic resonance in the paramagnetic regime (T > 10 K), consistent with the absence of significant single-ion anisotropy, a prerequisite for Haldane systems. However, below TN, additional ESR modes emerged, consistent with AFM ordering.
  • NMR Evidence: 35Cl NMR spectroscopy showed a sharp spectral transformation around 9 K, correlating with the AFM transition. The relaxation rate measurements also suggested a complex behavior not fully explained by simple AFM ordering.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Inhomogeneous Ground State: The primary limitation is the deviation from the expected pure Haldane behavior, with the emergence of AFM order. The proposed inhomogeneous ground state is speculative and requires further investigation.
  • Nature of Interchain Couplings: While interchain couplings are implicated in the AFM ordering, their precise nature and strength are not fully characterized.
  • Role of Defects: The hypothesis of structural disorder leading to fragmented chains and inhomogeneous states needs direct experimental verification.

Future work could focus on:

  • Synthesizing and studying samples with controlled structural modifications to directly test the disorder hypothesis.
  • Performing more detailed theoretical modeling to better understand the interplay between intra- and interchain couplings and their impact on the ground state.
  • Exploring other spectroscopic techniques to further probe the coexistence of different magnetic phases.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report experimental results of the static magnetization, ESR and NMR spectroscopic measurements of the Ni-hybrid compound NiCl3C6H5CH2CH2NH3. In this material NiCl3 octahedra are structurally arranged in chains along the crystallographic a axis. According to the static susceptibility and ESR data Ni2+ spins S = 1 are isotropic and are coupled antiferromagnetically (AFM) along the chain with the exchange constant J = 25.5 K. These are important prerequisites for the realization of the so-called Haldane spin-1 chain with the spin-singlet ground state and a quantum spin gap. However, experimental results evidence AFM order at TN ≈ 10 K presumably due to small interchain couplings. Interestingly, frequency-, magnetic field-, and temperature-dependent ESR measurements, as well as the NMR data, reveal signatures which could presumably indicate an inhomogeneous ground state of co-existent mesoscopically spatially separated AFM ordered and spin-singlet state regions similar to the situation observed before in some spin-diluted Haldane magnets.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lipps2017magnetic,
  author = {Ferdinand Lipps and A.H. Arkenbout and Alexey O. Polyakov and Michael Günther and Timur Salikhov and E. Vavilova and H.‐H. Klauß and B. Büchner and T. M. Palstra and V. Kataev},
  title = {{Magnetic properties of the spin-1 chain compound NiCl3C6H5CH2CH2NH3}},
  booktitle = {Low},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1063/1.5010316},
}
Figure