Macroscopic bubble generation promoted by nanobubble seeds as a traceless anti-fluctuation strategy for water splitting

Sheng Yang, Jing Yuan, Pengpeng Xie, Bo Li, Mengxuan Li, Daojin Zhou, Liang Luo, Xiaoming SunNature Communications 2025 · DOI

Abstract: To adapt fluctuating renewable energy for water splitting is challenging, since the growth of electrochemically generated nanobubbles at early stage requires high supersaturation during the repeated start-stop cycles, which can accelerate the deactivation of electrodes and cause extra energy consumption. Herein, we propose a "bubble seeding" strategy by introducing nanobubbles (NBs, ~200 nm in diameter) into electrolyte to promote the generation of macroscopic bubbles. The precursive nanobubbles can act as the beforehand nuclei with a certain supersaturation, lower the supersaturation barrier for further growth, and result in reduced overpotential as high as 130 mV for oxygen evolution reaction. The enhancement depends on nanobubble coverage and size, with higher coverage and larger sizes favoring macrobubble growth. The nanobubbles with inert gas species (e.g. N<sub>2</sub> for oxygen evolution reaction) can also work as the seeds, while the interfering or consumable gas species (e.g. O<sub>2</sub> for hydrogen evolution reaction) would hinder the generation of macroscopic bubbles and enlarge the overpotential. The water splitting device working at presence of nanobubbles exhibits stable operation voltage during repeated start-stop cycles in contrast to traditional electrolyte without NBs, indicating great potential of such traceless nanobubble additive strategy for stabilizing gas evolution applications.

Introduction: The Nucleation Bottleneck

Green hydrogen production via water splitting is a cornerstone of the transition to renewable energy. However, the intermittent nature of wind and solar power forces electrolyzers into frequent start-stop cycles. This operational fluctuation reveals a significant physical bottleneck: bubble nucleation.

According to the Young-Laplace equation, the internal pressure of a bubble is inversely proportional to its radius. Consequently, microscopic "intrinsic" nuclei require extremely high gas supersaturation to overcome internal pressure and grow into macroscopic bubbles. This high energy requirement translates to a substantial "overpotential," which not only increases energy consumption but also creates a harsh environment that can physically strip catalysts from the electrode, leading to rapid device deactivation.

Mechanism: Bypassing the Nucleation Barrier

The proposed "bubble seeding" strategy involves injecting a population of nanobubbles (NBs, ~200 nm in diameter) directly into the electrolyte. These NBs act as pre-formed templates, effectively bypassing the high-energy "pin-rise" stage where tiny bubbles struggle to expand.

Theoretical comparison of supersaturation requirements for intrinsic nucleation versus adsorbed nanobubble seeds.

As shown in the mechanism above, the larger radius of the NBs compared to intrinsic nuclei results in lower internal pressure and a significantly reduced supersaturation requirement (Δζ) for growth. This shift lowers the overpotential (Δη) needed to initiate gas evolution. The promotion effect is a function of electrode coverage and NB size; larger seeds and higher surface coverage lead to lower overpotentials.

Experimental Validation

The researchers verified this strategy using a combination of high-resolution imaging and electrochemical techniques:

  • Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis (NTA): Confirmed the size and concentration of injected NBs.
  • Surface Plasmon Resonance imaging (SPRi): Visualized NB adsorption onto the electrode surface in real-time.
  • Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): Mapped the morphology and contact angles of adsorbed NBs.
  • AEM Electrolyzer Testing: Validated the strategy in a practical Anion Exchange Membrane (AEM) device using nickel-iron (NiFe-LDH) and nickel-molybdenum (NiMo) electrodes.

Key Results and Performance

The introduction of NBs yielded significant energy savings and improved device longevity. A primary result was the reduction of overpotential for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) by as much as 130 mV at a current density of 1 mA/cm².

Electrochemical polarization curves showing a 130 mV reduction in overpotential with nanobubble injection.

Beyond energy efficiency, the strategy offers several advantages:

  • Traceless Operation: Unlike chemical surfactants, NBs are composed of the reaction gases (or inert gases like N₂). They eventually grow into product bubbles and leave the system without contaminating the output or fouling the membrane.
  • Gas Species Specificity: The gas inside the NB must be compatible. Using Nitrogen or the product gas (e.g., O₂ for OER) works well. However, using an "interfering" gas (like O₂ during the hydrogen evolution reaction) can hinder the process by triggering side reactions that consume the seeds.
  • Enhanced Durability: In AEM electrolyzer tests, operating voltage remained stable over 120 cycles with Ar NBs, whereas standard electrolytes showed a steady voltage climb, indicating catalyst degradation. SEM imaging confirmed that electrodes used with NB-seeded electrolytes remained physically intact.
  • Efficiency: The energy cost to generate these nanobubbles is negligible, representing only about 0.047% of the total energy consumed by the electrolyzer.

Conclusion

The "bubble seeding" strategy provides a simple, effective, and traceless method to mitigate the energy losses and electrode degradation associated with fluctuating renewable energy inputs. By lowering the physical barriers to bubble growth, this approach enhances both the efficiency and the lifespan of water-splitting devices, offering a robust solution for stabilizing gas evolution applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

To adapt fluctuating renewable energy for water splitting is challenging, since the growth of electrochemically generated nanobubbles at early stage requires high supersaturation during the repeated start-stop cycles, which can accelerate the deactivation of electrodes and cause extra energy consumption. Herein, we propose a "bubble seeding" strategy by introducing nanobubbles (NBs, ~200 nm in diameter) into electrolyte to promote the generation of macroscopic bubbles. The precursive nanobubbles can act as the beforehand nuclei with a certain supersaturation, lower the supersaturation barrier for further growth, and result in reduced overpotential as high as 130 mV for oxygen evolution reaction. The enhancement depends on nanobubble coverage and size, with higher coverage and larger sizes favoring macrobubble growth. The nanobubbles with inert gas species (e.g. N<sub>2</sub> for oxygen evolution reaction) can also work as the seeds, while the interfering or consumable gas species (e.g. O<sub>2</sub> for hydrogen evolution reaction) would hinder the generation of macroscopic bubbles and enlarge the overpotential. The water splitting device working at presence of nanobubbles exhibits stable operation voltage during repeated start-stop cycles in contrast to traditional electrolyte without NBs, indicating great potential of such traceless nanobubble additive strategy for stabilizing gas evolution applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2025macroscopic,
  author = {Sheng Yang and Jing Yuan and Pengpeng Xie and Bo Li and Mengxuan Li and Daojin Zhou and Liang Luo and Xiaoming Sun},
  title = {{Macroscopic bubble generation promoted by nanobubble seeds as a traceless anti-fluctuation strategy for water splitting}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-025-61131-3},
}
Figure