Machine learning polysomnographically-derived electroencephalography biomarkers predictive of epworth sleepiness scale

Matheus Araújo, Samer Ghosn, Lu Wang, Nengah Hariadi, Samantha Wells, Carl Y. Saab, Reena MehraScientific 2023 · DOI

This paper, published in Scientific Reports, presents a machine learning approach to turn a common clinical tool—the overnight sleep study—into an objective diagnostic for daytime sleepiness.

TL;DR

Researchers developed a machine learning pipeline that identifies objective EEG biomarkers for excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) using data from standard overnight sleep studies. By analyzing brain rhythms during resting wakefulness, the model achieved over 80% accuracy in distinguishing between highly sleepy and alert individuals, outperforming traditional clinical predictors like age and BMI.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) is more than just feeling tired; it’s a public health crisis linked to $135 billion in lost productivity and significant safety risks (like drowsy driving). Currently, clinicians diagnose EDS using the Epworth Sleepiness Scale (ESS), a subjective questionnaire where patients rate their likelihood of dozing off in various scenarios.

The problem? Subjective reports are notoriously unreliable. Patients may underreport or overreport symptoms, making it difficult for doctors to accurately diagnose disorders like narcolepsy or track how well a treatment is working. There is a dire need for a "biological thermometer" for sleepiness—an objective, non-invasive biomarker.

Methods

The authors leveraged a computational pipeline to analyze previously collected electroencephalography (EEG) data from the Cleveland Clinic Sleep Registry.

The "Awake" Window: Instead of looking at the sleep itself, they focused on the "awake" epochs recorded during a polysomnogram (PSG)—specifically the three-minute window between "lights out" and the onset of the first stage of sleep (N1).

Feature Extraction: They extracted three main types of features from the EEG signals:

  1. Power Spectral Density (PSD): Measuring the "strength" of different brain wave frequencies (Delta, Theta, Alpha, Beta, Gamma).
  2. Phase-Amplitude Coupling (PAC): Looking at how the timing of slow waves interacts with the strength of fast waves.
  3. Coherence: Measuring how well different regions of the brain are "in sync" with each other.

The Algorithm: After statistical filtering to find the most relevant features, they trained a k-Nearest Neighbors (k-NN) classifier to perform a binary classification: High ESS (sleepy) vs. Low ESS (alert).

Datasets

The study used data from the Cleveland Clinic Sleep Registry, identifying a total of 72 patients:

  • High ESS Group (n=31): Severe sleepiness (ESS score ≥ 20).
  • Low ESS Group (n=41): No sleepiness (ESS score < 5).

By selecting patients at the extreme ends of the scale, the researchers aimed to find the clearest possible physiological signals associated with sleepiness.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Slow" vs. "Fast" Signature: The most striking finding was the shift in brain rhythms. Alert individuals (Low ESS) showed significantly higher power in alpha and beta bands (associated with active processing and alertness). In contrast, sleepy individuals (High ESS) showed "heavier" activity in delta and theta bands, which are typically dominant during sleep.
  • Occipital Beta as a Marker: Specifically, higher beta activity in the occipital region (the back of the brain, channel O2) was a strong indicator of alertness.
  • ML Trumps Demographics: One of the most important "aha" moments came from the confounding variable analysis. While factors like age, BMI, and gender are often linked to sleep issues, the ML model’s EEG-based predictions were the only statistically significant predictors of EDS when tested in a combined model. This suggests the EEG signal captures a unique physiological state of sleepiness that demographics cannot.

Key Results

The k-NN model demonstrated robust performance in identifying sleepy vs. alert patients:

  • Accuracy: 80.2%
  • Precision: 79.2%
  • Recall: 73.8%
  • Specificity: 85.3%
  • AUC-ROC: 79.5%

The researchers also used a generalized linear model to show that their ML output explained 41% of the variance in sleepiness, whereas confounding clinical variables (age, BMI, gender) only explained 8%.

Limitations and Future Work

While promising, the study has a few hurdles to clear before clinical adoption:

  • Sample Size: With only 72 patients, the model needs validation on a much larger, prospective cohort across different geographic locations.
  • Manual Pre-processing: The pipeline still relies on manual sleep staging to identify the "awake" period. A fully autonomous system would need to identify these windows without human intervention.
  • Feature Constraints: The study used predefined frequency bands (e.g., 1–4 Hz for Delta). The authors suggest that future work using Deep Learning on raw EEG signals might uncover even more subtle, non-linear biomarkers that traditional band-pass filtering misses.

Ultimately, this work paves the way for "point-of-care" sleepiness assessments that could eventually be integrated into electronic health records to help identify patients at risk for drowsy driving or other fatigue-related dangers.

Summary updated

Abstract

Excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) causes difficulty in concentrating and continuous fatigue during the day. In the clinical setting, the assessment and diagnosis of EDS rely mostly on subjective questionnaires and verbal reports, which compromises the reliability of clinical diagnosis and the ability to robustly discern candidacy for available therapies and track treatment response. In this study, we used a computational pipeline for the automated, rapid, high-throughput, and objective analysis of previously collected encephalography (EEG) data to identify surrogate biomarkers for EDS, thereby defining the quantitative EEG changes in individuals with high Epworth Sleepiness Scale (ESS) (n = 31), compared to a group of individuals with low ESS (n = 41) at the Cleveland Clinic. The epochs of EEG analyzed were extracted from a large overnight polysomnogram registry during the most proximate period of wakefulness. Signal processing of EEG showed significantly different EEG features in the low ESS group compared to high ESS, including enhanced power in the alpha and beta bands and attenuation in the delta and theta bands. Our machine learning (ML) algorithms trained on the binary classification of high vs. low ESS reached an accuracy of 80.2%, precision of 79.2%, recall of 73.8% and specificity of 85.3%. Moreover, we ruled out the effects of confounding clinical variables by evaluating the statistical contribution of these variables on our ML models. These results indicate that EEG data contain information in the form of rhythmic activity that could be leveraged for the quantitative assessment of EDS using ML.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{araujo2023machine,
  author = {Matheus Araújo and Samer Ghosn and Lu Wang and Nengah Hariadi and Samantha Wells and Carl Y. Saab and Reena Mehra},
  title = {{Machine learning polysomnographically-derived electroencephalography biomarkers predictive of epworth sleepiness scale}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-34716-5},
}
Figure