Machine Learning Methods for Improved Understanding of a Pumping Test in Heterogeneous Aquifers

Yong Fan, Litang Hu, Hongliang Wang, Xin LiuWater 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the application of machine learning (ML) techniques to analyze complex pumping test data from a heterogeneous aquifer in the Democratic Republic of Congo. By employing various ML methods, the study demonstrates their ability to reveal hidden hydraulic connections and improve the understanding of aquifer properties, offering a powerful alternative to traditional analytical solutions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Interpreting pumping test data is crucial for understanding aquifer properties and managing groundwater resources. However, traditional analytical solutions (like Theis or Hantush-Jacob) often fall short in complex hydrogeological settings characterized by heterogeneity and anisotropy. These solutions rely on strict assumptions that are frequently violated in real-world scenarios, leading to inaccurate estimations of aquifer parameters. This paper addresses this gap by investigating how machine learning methods can extract valuable information from pumping test data in such challenging environments, providing a more robust and insightful analysis.

Methods

The study employs a suite of machine learning and statistical methods to analyze the pumping test data:

  • Pearson Correlation Analysis: Used to quantify the linear relationship between the time-series groundwater level data of pumping wells and observation wells.
  • K-Means Clustering: Applied to group wells based on their correlation coefficients, drawdowns, and depths, aiming to identify wells with similar hydraulic properties and infer hydraulic connections.
  • Time-Series Analysis (ARIMA): Utilized to forecast groundwater level changes (drawdowns) within the pumping wells themselves, capturing their dynamic behavior.
  • Artificial Neural Networks (ANN), Support Vector Machine (SVR), and Random Forest (RF): These supervised learning models are employed to predict drawdowns in observation wells, using precipitation and pumping well drawdowns as independent variables.
  • Linear Regression: Coupled with analytical solutions (specifically, a linear graphic method based on the Theis model) to estimate hydraulic conductivity.

The novelty lies in the comprehensive application of these diverse ML techniques to a single, complex pumping test scenario, aiming to provide a multi-faceted understanding of the aquifer system.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from a large-scale pumping test conducted at a newly planned mining site in the Kolwezi Copper Deposit, Democratic Republic of Congo. This dataset includes:

  • Pumping Well Data: Drawdown measurements from three pumping wells (P01, P02, P03) over approximately 32 days.
  • Observation Well Data: Drawdown measurements from 28 observation wells (including the pumping wells) over the same period.
  • Precipitation Data: Daily precipitation records for the study area during the pumping test.
  • Geological and Well Information: Well locations, depths, and regional stratigraphy.

This dataset represents a real-world, complex hydrogeological scenario, serving as the primary benchmark for evaluating the ML methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ML for Visualizing Hydraulic Connections: Traditional contour maps of maximum drawdown are useful but can be insufficient. ML-driven correlation and clustering analyses provide a more dynamic and insightful "visual picture" of how wells are hydraulically connected over time, revealing patterns that might otherwise be missed.
  • Depth-Dependent Permeability: The clustering analysis, incorporating well depth, suggests a zone of good permeability between 250 m and 350 m, indicating that ML can help pinpoint specific depth intervals of interest for groundwater flow.
  • RF Outperforms ANN and SVR in Prediction: While all tested ML models (ANN, SVR, RF) could reasonably capture drawdown trends, the Random Forest (RF) model demonstrated superior accuracy and, importantly, lower sensitivity to parameter variations, making it a more robust choice for this application.
  • ARIMA for Pumping Well Dynamics: The ARIMA model proved effective in accurately predicting drawdowns within the pumping wells, even in a hypothetical scenario with a very long simulation period, highlighting its utility for capturing the temporal dynamics of active pumping.
  • Linear Regression as a Complementary Tool: Combining linear regression with analytical solutions offers a practical way to estimate hydraulic conductivity, bridging the gap between purely data-driven ML and traditional hydrogeological methods.

Key Results

  • Hydraulic Connections: K-means clustering identified four distinct groups of wells, with the highest correlation (PR > 0.75) found in wells located closer to the pumping wells, suggesting strong hydraulic connections in this zone. A depth range of 250-350 m was identified as having good permeability.
  • Pumping Well Drawdown Prediction: The ARIMA model predicted maximum drawdowns for wells P01, P02, and P03 after 3 years to be 64.53 m, 52.50 m, and 92.88 m, respectively.
  • Observation Well Drawdown Prediction: RF and SVR models showed better performance than ANN for predicting drawdowns in observation wells, with average RMSE values of 0.13 m.
  • Hydraulic Conductivity Estimation: The linear regression method, applied to specific wells, provided hydraulic conductivity estimates consistent with previous studies in the region (around 0.15 m/d to 7.00 m/d, depending on well and aquifer thickness assumptions).
  • Model Parameter Sensitivity: The RF model exhibited the least sensitivity to parameter values compared to ANN and SVR, indicating greater reliability and ease of use.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Radius of Influence (ROI): The study acknowledges that the radius of influence (ROI) in pumping tests was not discussed but will be a focus in future work, particularly when considering combined influences of groundwater level and quality.
  • ML Mechanics: The authors note that ML methods, while powerful for prediction and pattern recognition, lack the inherent physical mechanics of groundwater flow and cannot directly estimate hydraulic conductivity like analytical solutions.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests future work will involve exploring ROI and the combined effects of groundwater level and quality. The successful application of ML in this study opens avenues for its broader use in complex aquifer characterization.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pumping tests are very important means for investigating aquifer properties; however, interpreting the data using common analytical solutions become invalid in complex aquifer systems. The paper aims to explore the potential of machine learning methods in retrieving the pumping tests information in a field site in the Democratic Republic of Congo. A newly planned mining site with a pumping test of three pumping wells and 28 observation wells over one month was chosen to analyze the significance of machine learning methods in the pumping test analysis. Widely used machine learning methods, including correlation, cluster, time-series analysis, artificial neural network (ANN), support vector machine (SVR), random forest (RF) method, and linear regression, are all used in this study. Correlation and cluster analyses among wells provide visual pictures of possible hydraulic connections. The pathway with the best permeability ranges from the depth of 250 m to 350 m. Time-series analysis perfectly captured changes of drawdowns within the three pumping wells. The RF method is found to have the higher accuracy and the lower sensitivity to model parameters than ANN and SVR methods. The coupling of the linear regressive model and analytical solutions is applied to estimate hydraulic conductivities. The results found that ML methods can significantly and effectively improve our understanding of pumping tests by revealing inherent information hidden in those tests.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fan2020machine,
  author = {Yong Fan and Litang Hu and Hongliang Wang and Xin Liu},
  title = {{Machine Learning Methods for Improved Understanding of a Pumping Test in Heterogeneous Aquifers}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/w12051342},
}
Figure