Machine Learning for Predicting Ultralow Thermal Conductivity and High ZT in Complex Thermoelectric Materials

Yuzhou Hao, Yuting Zuo, Jiongzhi Zheng, Wenjie Hou, Hong Gu, Xiaoying Wang, Xuejie Li, Jun Sun, Xiangdong Ding, Zhibin GaoACS 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses machine learning to accurately predict the thermoelectric properties of Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub>, revealing an exceptionally low thermal conductivity and a high figure of merit (ZT) of up to 3.17. This work highlights the crucial role of phonon coherence and anharmonicity in achieving efficient thermoelectric performance, paving the way for designing new materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Thermoelectric materials are exciting for their ability to convert heat into electricity, offering a clean energy solution. However, maximizing their efficiency (quantified by the figure of merit, ZT) is a major challenge. High ZT requires simultaneously enhancing electrical conductivity and suppressing thermal conductivity. While many complex materials show promise for ultralow thermal conductivity, accurately predicting and understanding the underlying mechanisms, especially in highly anharmonic systems, remains difficult. Traditional computational methods can be prohibitively expensive, and experimental measurements can be complex to interpret. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a robust computational framework, powered by machine learning, to precisely predict the thermoelectric performance of complex materials like Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub> and elucidate the microscopic origins of its properties.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining advanced computational techniques:

  • Machine Learning Potential (MLP): They trained a Moment Tensor Potential (MTP) using DFT calculations. This MLP acts as a surrogate model, capable of accurately predicting atomic forces and energies for large systems, significantly speeding up simulations compared to direct DFT calculations.
  • Self-Consistent Phonon (SCPH) Calculations: To account for the complex anharmonic effects in Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub>, they used SCPH calculations. This method goes beyond simpler harmonic approximations to capture temperature-dependent phonon frequencies and linewidths, which are crucial for understanding thermal transport in such materials.
  • Unified Thermal Transport Theory: They integrated the MLP-derived force constants and SCPH results into a unified theory of thermal transport. This theory considers both "population" (phonon-like) and "coherence" (wave-like) contributions to lattice thermal conductivity, as well as various scattering mechanisms (acoustic deformation potential, ionized impurity, and polar optical phonon scattering) for electrical transport.
  • Moment Tensor Potential (MTP) for Higher-Order Force Constants: A key innovation was using MTP to efficiently obtain fourth-order force constants, which are essential for accurately modeling four-phonon scattering processes that significantly influence thermal conductivity in anharmonic materials.

Datasets

The paper utilized existing DFT calculations to train the Moment Tensor Potential (MTP). The training dataset was generated using Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics (AIMD) in the isobaric-isothermal (NPT) ensemble. The MTP was then tested on a validation dataset. The accuracy of the trained MTP was validated against DFT results for energy, forces, and phonon dispersion.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Coherence is King for Ultralow Thermal Conductivity: The study revealed that "coherence" contributions (wave-like phonon transport) play a dominant role in the ultralow lattice thermal conductivity of Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub>, especially at higher temperatures. This is a significant finding, as it suggests that understanding and manipulating these coherent effects is crucial for designing materials with excellent thermal insulation.
  • Anharmonicity is Not Just a Nuisance, It's a Feature: The research strongly emphasizes the profound impact of lattice anharmonicity in Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub>. The observed phonon hardening with increasing temperature and the significant role of four-phonon scattering highlight that these complex interactions are not just noise but fundamental to the material's ultralow thermal conductivity.
  • Glass-like Behavior from Limited Group Velocities: The ultralow thermal conductivity of Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub> is attributed to limited phonon group velocities, leading to a glass-like thermal transport behavior, despite its crystalline structure.
  • Dual-Degeneracy for Enhanced Electrical Properties: The material's impressive electrical properties are linked to a "dual-degeneracy phenomenon" within its valence band, which helps maintain good electrical conductivity even with suppressed thermal transport.

Key Results

  • Ultralow Thermal Conductivity: An exceptionally low lattice thermal conductivity (κ<sub>L</sub>) of 0.31 W m<sup>-1</sup> K<sup>-1</sup> was predicted at room temperature, consistent with experimental observations.
  • High Figure of Merit (ZT): A maximum ZT value of 3.17 was achieved for p-type Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub> at 600 K in the c-axis direction. For n-type Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub>, an optimal ZT of 2.26 was found at 500 K in the a/b-axis direction.
  • MLP Accuracy: The trained MTP demonstrated high accuracy, with RMSE values of 0.00029 eV/atom for energy and 0.023 eV/Å for atomic forces, and its phonon spectrum closely matched DFT results.
  • Anisotropy: Both thermal and electrical transport properties exhibit significant anisotropy in Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub>, with distinct behaviors for p-type and n-type doping.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Validation: While the predicted thermal conductivity aligns with experimental values, further experimental validation of the calculated ZT values and the detailed mechanisms is suggested.
  • Carrier Concentration Optimization: The study highlights the importance of optimizing carrier concentration for maximizing ZT, suggesting that further fine-tuning of doping levels could lead to even better performance.
  • Band Engineering: The paper points to the dual-degeneracy phenomenon as a key factor for enhancing thermoelectricity, implying that band engineering strategies could be explored to further improve ZT.
  • Broader Application of the Framework: The developed machine learning-assisted computational framework holds promise for accurately predicting thermoelectric properties in other complex materials, potentially accelerating the discovery of new thermoelectric materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

Efficient and precise calculations of thermal transport properties and figures of merit, alongside a deep comprehension of thermal transport mechanisms, are essential for the practical utilization of advanced thermoelectric materials. In this study, we explore the microscopic processes governing thermal transport in the distinguished crystalline material Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub> by integrating a unified thermal transport theory with machine learning-assisted self-consistent phonon calculations. Leveraging machine learning potentials, we expedite the analysis of phonon energy shifts, higher-order scattering mechanisms, and thermal conductivity arising from various contributing factors, such as population and coherence channels. Our finding unveils an exceptionally low thermal conductivity of 0.31 W m<sup>-1</sup> K<sup>-1</sup> at room temperature, a result that closely correlates with experimental observations. Notably, we observe that the off-diagonal terms of heat flux operators play a significant role in shaping the overall lattice thermal conductivity of Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub>, where the ultralow thermal conductivity resembles that of glass due to limited group velocities. Furthermore, we achieve a maximum <i>ZT</i> value of 3.17 in the <i>c</i>-axis orientation for <i>p</i>-type Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub> at 600 K and an optimal <i>ZT</i> value of 2.26 in the <i>a</i>-axis and <i>b</i>-axis direction for <i>n</i>-type Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub> at 500 K. The crystalline Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub> not only showcases remarkable thermal insulation but also demonstrates impressive electrical properties owing to the dual-degeneracy phenomenon within its valence band. These results not only elucidate the underlying reasons for the exceptional thermoelectric performance of Tl<sub>9</sub>SbTe<sub>6</sub> but also suggest potential avenues for further experimental exploration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hao2024machine,
  author = {Yuzhou Hao and Yuting Zuo and Jiongzhi Zheng and Wenjie Hou and Hong Gu and Xiaoying Wang and Xuejie Li and Jun Sun and Xiangdong Ding and Zhibin Gao},
  title = {{Machine Learning for Predicting Ultralow Thermal Conductivity and High <i>ZT</i> in Complex Thermoelectric Materials}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/acsami.4c09043},
}
Figure