LUMINOUS RED GALAXY POPULATION IN CLUSTERS AT 0.2⩽ z ⩽0.6

Shirley Ho, Yen‐Ting Lin, David N. Spergel, Christopher M. HirataThe Astrophysical Journal 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the distribution of Luminous Red Galaxies (LRGs) within X-ray selected galaxy clusters at intermediate redshifts. They find that the number of LRGs in a cluster follows a Poisson distribution and that the brightest LRGs are highly concentrated towards the cluster centers, suggesting a consistent picture of massive galaxy formation and evolution across cosmic epochs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how massive galaxies form and evolve within the cosmic web is a fundamental question in astrophysics. Clusters of galaxies are dense environments where galaxy evolution is expected to be significantly influenced by their surroundings. Luminous Red Galaxies (LRGs) are a specific type of massive, old galaxy that are thought to be "red and dead," meaning their star formation has largely ceased. Their presence and distribution within galaxy clusters can provide crucial clues about the processes that build these massive galaxies, such as mergers. However, precisely quantifying the relationship between dark matter halos (which host galaxy clusters) and the number and distribution of LRGs within them has been challenging. This paper aims to address this by providing observational constraints on the "halo occupation distribution" (HOD) of LRGs in clusters.

Methods

The authors employ a statistical approach to analyze the distribution of LRGs within galaxy clusters. Their core methodology involves:

  • LRG Selection: They define LRGs based on carefully chosen color criteria from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) data, designed to identify galaxies with old stellar populations and a prominent 4000Å break.
  • Cluster Membership: Cluster membership for LRGs is assessed using photometric redshifts, which provide an estimate of a galaxy's redshift based on its colors.
  • Halo Occupation Distribution (HOD): The central concept is the HOD, which describes how many galaxies of a certain type (in this case, LRGs) are expected to reside in a dark matter halo of a given mass. They model this relationship using functional forms like $\langle N(M) \rangle = k \times (M/10^{14} M_\odot)^\alpha$.
  • Statistical Analysis: They analyze the variance of the LRG counts within clusters to test if a Poisson distribution is a good assumption for the number of LRGs per halo. They also examine the radial distribution of LRGs within clusters by fitting a Navarro-Frenk-White (NFW) profile.
  • Systematic Error Mitigation: They account for potential sources of error, such as interlopers (galaxies that appear to be in a cluster but are not), LRG identification failures, and uncertainties in photometric redshifts.

Datasets

The primary datasets used in this study are:

  • ROSAT 400d Survey: This X-ray survey provides a catalog of galaxy clusters, from which the authors select clusters based on their X-ray properties (luminosity and redshift).
  • Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS): This large-scale optical survey provides the photometric and spectroscopic data used to identify and characterize the LRGs. The authors utilize data from SDSS DR5.
  • Chandra Archive (for Yx sample): A subset of clusters with better-measured masses derived from X-ray temperature and gas properties (Yx) was used to cross-check their mass estimations and to extend the mass range of their analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LRGs as Dark Matter Tracers: The study highlights that both galaxy clusters (traced by X-ray emission) and LRGs can serve as valuable probes of the underlying dark matter distribution. Understanding their co-evolution is key to understanding structure formation.
  • Poissonian Nature of LRG Occupation: A significant finding is that the number of LRGs within a dark matter halo, and even the number of satellite LRGs (those not at the very center), can be well-described by a Poisson distribution. This simplifies theoretical modeling.
  • Concentration of Brightest LRGs: The brightest LRGs (BLRGs) within clusters show a strong preference for the cluster center, with about 80% residing within the inner 20% of the cluster's virial radius. This is consistent with previous findings for bright galaxies.
  • NFW Profile Fit: The radial distribution of LRGs (including BLRGs) within clusters can be effectively modeled by an NFW profile, yielding a concentration parameter of 17.5. Excluding the BLRGs results in a lower concentration (6.0), indicating their central dominance.
  • Implications for Galaxy Evolution: The consistency of LRG distribution and HODs between their studied redshift range (0.2-0.6) and the local universe (z<0.2) suggests that the evolution of massive galaxies in clusters might be relatively passive over this epoch, with mergers playing a key role in their formation at earlier times.

Key Results

  • The halo occupation distribution of LRGs in clusters is modeled as $\langle N(M) \rangle = k \times (M/10^{14} M_\odot)^\alpha$, with best-fit parameters $\alpha = 0.620 \pm 0.105$ and $k = 1.425 \pm 0.285$ when assuming a Poisson distribution for $N(M)$.
  • The variance of the LRG counts divided by the mean count, $\text{Var}(N)/\langle N \rangle$, is found to be $1.428 \pm 0.351$, consistent with a Poisson distribution ($\gamma=1$).
  • The radial profile of LRGs within clusters, when fitted with an NFW profile, yields a concentration parameter of $17.5 \pm 7.3$ when including brightest LRGs, and $6.0 \pm 3.3$ when excluding them.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mass Estimation Uncertainties: While efforts were made to use more reliable mass estimates (Yx sample), uncertainties in cluster mass estimations remain a factor, particularly for lower-mass clusters at higher redshifts.
  • Photometric Redshift Errors: The study acknowledges that errors in photometric redshifts can lead to misclassification of cluster members and interlopers, though they attempt to account for these effects.
  • Mass Tracer Correlation: The paper notes that LRGs themselves, or the luminosities of central LRGs, do not appear to be straightforward, precise tracers of cluster mass, suggesting that further investigation is needed to quantify these relationships and potential systematic effects.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that studying LRGs at lower redshifts (z < 0.2) would be crucial for better constraining the evolution of massive galaxy populations. They also point to the need for further work to quantify the impact of photometry errors on correlations between LRG properties and cluster masses.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT We investigate statistical properties of luminous red galaxies (LRGs) in a sample of X-ray-selected galaxy clusters at intermediate redshift (0.2 ⩽ z ⩽ 0.6) of mass range from ∼1 × 10 14 M ☉ to ∼8 × 10 14 M ☉ . The LRGs are selected based on carefully designed color criteria, and the cluster membership is assessed via photometric redshifts. As clusters and LRGs are both viewed as promising tracer of the underlying dark matter distribution, understanding the distribution of LRGs within clusters is an important issue. Our main findings include (1) the halo occupation distribution (HOD) of LRGs inside our cluster sample is 〈 N ( M )〉 = k ( M /10 14 h −1 M ☉ ) a , where a = 0.495 ± 0.105 and k = 1.455 ± 0.285 assuming a Poisson distribution for N ( M ). If we assume the form of 〈 N ( M )〉 = 1 + k ( M /10 14 h −1 M ☉ ) a , where a = 0.580 ± 0.130 and k = 0.975 ± 0.240 assuming a Poisson distribution for N ( M ). (2) The HOD of LRGs [ N ( M )] and the satellite distribution of LRGs [ N ( M ) − 1] are both consistent with being Poisson. To be more quantitative, we find Var( N )/〈 N 〉 = 1.43 ± 0.35 and Var( N − 1)/〈 N − 1〉 = 1.82 ± 0.50. (3) The radial profile of LRGs within clusters when fitted with a Navarro–Frenk–White profile gives a concentration of 17.5 +7.1 −4.3 (6.0 +3.2 −1.9 ) including (excluding) brightest LRGs (BLRGs). In essence, the BLRGs are more concentrated toward the center of the clusters than the other LRGs in clusters. We also discuss the implications of these observations on the evolution of massive galaxies in clusters.
BibTeX
@article{ho2009luminous,
  author = {Shirley Ho and Yen‐Ting Lin and David N. Spergel and Christopher M. Hirata},
  title = {{LUMINOUS RED GALAXY POPULATION IN CLUSTERS AT 0.2⩽ z ⩽0.6}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1088/0004-637x/697/2/1358},
}
Figure