<title>New multichannel Ethernet protocol for passive optical star local area networks using coherent transmission</title>

Daniel Rodellar, C. Bungarzeanu, Héctor A. García, Caroline Brisson, Alain Kueng, Philippe A. RobertProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 1998 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel multichannel Ethernet protocol designed for passive optical star local area networks (LANs) that leverages Wavelength Division Multiplexing (WDM) and coherent transmission. The proposed protocol offers significantly improved throughput and reduced latency compared to traditional single-channel Fast Ethernet, especially under high traffic loads, by distributing data across multiple wavelengths.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As network demands grow, particularly with the rise of multimedia applications, existing Ethernet-based LANs face limitations in their total capacity. While fiber optics offer immense bandwidth, effectively utilizing it for high-speed LANs requires innovative protocols. The challenge is to create a network architecture that can handle a large number of stations and high data rates without compromising performance, especially in terms of latency and packet loss, which are critical for real-time applications. Traditional single-channel Ethernet, even at higher speeds like Fast Ethernet, struggles with congestion as the number of users and traffic volume increase, leading to reduced efficiency and increased delays.

Methods

The core of this paper is a new multichannel protocol built upon the familiar Carrier Sense Multiple Access with Collision Detection (CSMA/CD) principles of Ethernet. The key innovation lies in its integration with WDM, allowing multiple data channels to coexist on a single fiber. Each station is equipped with a tunable transmitter to select a specific wavelength (channel) for sending data and a coherent receiver capable of detecting all channels simultaneously. This is facilitated by a shared local oscillator and a passive star coupler, forming a star topology.

The protocol adapts Ethernet's MAC layer by introducing a "channel-jumping" mechanism: if a station experiences a certain number of collisions on its current channel, it can switch to another available wavelength to transmit its packets. The paper also explores different strategies for selecting this new channel, including random choice, longest idle time, and round-robin. Performance is evaluated through simulations using a protocol simulator that models self-similar Ethernet traffic patterns.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention specific named datasets. Instead, it states that "a tracing data file with real Ethernet packet arrivals has been used to generate fictitious traces by multiplexing this real traffic." This implies the use of real-world Ethernet traffic traces to create synthetic traffic patterns that exhibit self-similarity, a characteristic crucial for accurately evaluating network performance under realistic conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • WDM as a Scalability Solution: The paper demonstrates that WDM is not just about increasing raw bandwidth but can be effectively used to create multiple logical channels on a single fiber, dramatically improving LAN capacity and scalability.
  • Coherent Transmission Benefits: Coherent detection offers superior receiver sensitivity (up to 20 dB improvement), which is crucial for supporting a large number of stations without needing optical amplifiers. It also allows for tighter channel spacing, enabling simpler receiver designs.
  • Multichannel CSMA/CD Fairness: By distributing traffic and collisions across multiple channels, the multichannel protocol maintains better fairness and efficiency compared to single-channel Ethernet, even when the total offered traffic approaches the network's capacity.
  • Channel-Jumping for Resilience: The ability for stations to switch channels upon collision is a key mechanism for avoiding prolonged congestion on any single channel and improving overall network resilience.
  • Self-Similar Traffic Matters: The authors emphasize the importance of using traffic models that capture the self-similar nature of Ethernet traffic for accurate performance evaluation, as traditional models can underestimate delays and packet loss.

Key Results

The simulations show that the proposed multichannel protocol significantly outperforms Fast Ethernet (100 Mbit/s) when both are configured to have the same total capacity (e.g., 10 channels of 10 Mbit/s each).

  • Throughput: The multichannel protocol achieves a higher maximum throughput (84 Mbit/s) at a higher offered load (95 Mbit/s) compared to Fast Ethernet (67 Mbit/s at 70 Mbit/s offered load). Crucially, the multichannel protocol's throughput remains constant under congestion, while Fast Ethernet's decreases.
  • Average Delay: The average delay for the multichannel protocol is consistently lower than that of Fast Ethernet, with a difference of 0.4 ms at a full 100 Mbit/s offered traffic.
  • Packet Loss: The number of packets lost (requiring retransmission) is significantly lower for the multichannel protocol, being ten times lower than for Fast Ethernet under similar congestion levels.
  • Channel-Jumping Policy: While all three tested jumping policies (random choice, longest idle, round-robin) performed similarly, they all showed better results than a policy with no backoff waiting time after jumping.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Economical Practicability: The authors acknowledge that the "economical practicability is presently a weakness of our proposal." This likely refers to the cost of tunable transmitters and coherent receivers, suggesting that further advancements in these technologies are needed for widespread adoption.
  • Laser Tuning Time: While the simulations were performed with a zero laser tuning time (T=0), the paper notes that for slower tuning lasers, the number of consecutive collisions (C) before jumping can be adjusted to optimize performance. The impact of non-zero tuning times on delay was found to be minimal (less than an Ethernet bit time) for the tested parameters.
  • Congestion Control: The paper mentions suggestions for congestion control in high-capacity networks but does not detail them extensively.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring other channel-jumping strategies, such as choosing a random idle wavelength or reducing backoff waiting times after a channel change, to further optimize delay and throughput, particularly for real-time services. They also highlight the potential for future work in developing more cost-effective implementations of the required hardware.

Summary updated

Abstract

A new optical local area network that combines dense Wavelength Division Multiplexing (WDM) techniques and coherent transmission benefits is presented. A new multichannel protocol is specified based on Ethernet, using WDM to carry multiple channels on a single fiber. The protocol is simulated to evaluate the performance under congestion conditions and to compare it with other protocols having the same total capacity. Some suggestions are made for congestion control in high-capacity networks and different channel-jumping strategies are proposed. A network architecture is proposed with tunable transmitters and multichannel receivers, and with a common local oscillator.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rodellar1998lt,
  author = {Daniel Rodellar and C. Bungarzeanu and Héctor A. García and Caroline Brisson and Alain Kueng and Philippe A. Robert},
  title = {{\<title\>New multichannel Ethernet protocol for passive optical star local area networks using coherent transmission\</title\>}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {1998},
  doi = {10.1117/12.321902},
}
Figure