Low-voltage high-performance flexible digital and analog circuits based on ultrahigh-purity semiconducting carbon nanotubes

Ting Lei, Leilai Shao, Yu‐Qing Zheng, Gregory Pitner, Guanhua Fang, Chenxin Zhu, Sicheng Li, Ray Beausoleil, H.-s. Philip Wong, Tsung‐Ching Huang, Kwang‐Ting Cheng, Zhenan BaoNature Communications 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new method to achieve ultra-high purity (99.997%) semiconducting carbon nanotubes (CNTs), enabling the fabrication of highly uniform and high-performance flexible digital and analog circuits. This breakthrough overcomes previous limitations in CNT purity and device yield, paving the way for advanced flexible electronics in applications like wearables and sensors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Flexible electronics hold immense promise for applications ranging from wearable devices to advanced sensors. Carbon nanotube (CNT) thin-film transistors (TFTs) are particularly attractive due to their high carrier mobility and mechanical flexibility. However, realizing complex, large-scale flexible circuits with CNTs has been hampered by several key challenges:

  • Low Semiconducting Tube Purity: Existing methods often yield CNTs with a significant percentage of metallic tubes, which can lead to short circuits and poor device performance.
  • Low Device Yield and Uniformity: Variations in CNT purity and deposition lead to inconsistent transistor characteristics, making it difficult to achieve reliable circuits.
  • Difficulty in Fabricating Complementary Circuits: Creating both p-type and n-type CNT TFTs with comparable performance and stability is challenging, hindering the development of efficient complementary metal-oxide semiconductor (CMOS)-like circuits.
  • Limited Circuit Complexity and Performance: Previous CNT-based flexible circuits were typically small-scale and operated at low frequencies, limiting their practical applications.

This paper aims to address these limitations by developing a method for producing ultra-high purity semiconducting CNTs and demonstrating their use in high-performance, low-voltage flexible digital and analog circuits.

Methods

The core of this work lies in two main areas: CNT purification and circuit fabrication/design.

  • Ultra-High Purity CNT Sorting: The researchers employed a modified polymer-sorting technique using a removable and recyclable imine polymer (PFPD). The key innovation involves an additional purification step: storing the initial sorted solution at 4°C to induce aggregation of metallic CNTs, followed by mild sonication and centrifugation. This process, repeated, achieved an unprecedented semiconducting CNT purity of 99.997% with a respectable yield of 19.9%.
  • Device Fabrication and Optimization:
    • Bottom-Contact Architecture: To improve uniformity and yield, a bottom-contact device structure was chosen, where source/drain electrodes are patterned before CNT deposition. This avoids photolithography on the CNT layer, which can cause significant CNT loss.
  • Surface Modification: A novel self-assembled monolayer (SAM) with a hydrophobic base and hydrophilic tail was used to improve CNT adhesion and reduce electrical hysteresis.
  • Encapsulation: A multi-layer encapsulation strategy involving a barrier layer (SiNx) and an Al2O3 layer was implemented to significantly enhance bias stability and protect against moisture and oxygen doping.
  • Pseudo-CMOS Design: To overcome the challenges of fabricating stable n-type CNT TFTs, the researchers adopted a pseudo-CMOS design style. This approach uses only one type of semiconductor (p-type CNTs in this case) to achieve performance comparable to complementary circuits, simplifying fabrication and improving yield.
  • Device Modeling: An accurate CNT TFT device model was developed and used for circuit simulation and optimization.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the fabrication and characterization of novel circuits using their developed CNTs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Purity-Performance Link is Crucial: The paper strongly demonstrates that achieving ultra-high purity in semiconducting CNTs is not just an incremental improvement but a fundamental enabler for high-performance, reliable flexible electronics. The 99.997% purity directly translates to significantly higher transistor yields and more consistent circuit behavior.
  • Pseudo-CMOS is a Game-Changer for Flexible CNT Circuits: The adoption of pseudo-CMOS design elegantly sidesteps the persistent difficulties in fabricating high-performance n-type CNT TFTs. This allows for the creation of complex digital and analog circuits using readily available p-type CNTs, offering a practical pathway to scalable flexible electronics.
  • Multi-faceted Optimization is Key: The success isn't solely due to CNT purity. A combination of bottom-contact architecture, SAM surface modification, robust encapsulation, and careful device modeling was essential to achieve the reported high performance and stability.
  • Flexible Electronics Can Now Be "Smart": The demonstration of a tunable-gain amplifier with a gain of 1000 and shift registers operating at practical frequencies signifies a leap towards more sophisticated flexible electronic systems, moving beyond simple logic gates.

Key Results

  • Ultra-High CNT Purity: Achieved 99.997% semiconducting CNT purity with a 19.9% yield.
  • High-Performance CNT TFTs: Demonstrated good uniformity and high performance with an average mobility of 23.4 cm²/V·s and on/off ratios > 10⁵.
  • Stable Flexible Circuits: Significantly improved bias stability through SAM modification and encapsulation.
  • Digital Circuits:
    • Ring Oscillators: Five-stage pseudo-CMOS ring oscillators operated at 3.5 MHz with a stage delay of 28 ns. A total of 44 oscillators (1056 TFTs) showed an average stage delay of 42.7 ± 13.1 ns, indicating a >99.9% transistor yield.
  • Shift Registers: An 8-stage shift register (304 CNT TFTs) operated at 50 kHz.
  • Analog Circuits:
    • Tunable-Gain Amplifier: Demonstrated a first-of-its-kind tunable-gain amplifier with a gain of 1000 (60 dB) at 20 kHz, controllable by a single tuning voltage.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • While the pseudo-CMOS design offers advantages, it may lead to higher power consumption and larger circuit area compared to true CMOS designs.
  • The paper mentions that the photoresist used for encapsulation contains a small amount of acid, which slightly p-dopes the CNT TFTs, requiring careful control of VTh.
  • The performance of the flexible circuits, while impressive for CNTs, is still being compared to mature metal-oxide TFT technologies, which currently show superior results in some metrics.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that their developed CNTs and pseudo-CMOS design can further enable innovations in flexible CNT-based sensor acquisition systems.
  • The demonstrated key building blocks (SRs, high-gain amplifiers) are poised for integration with various flexible sensors for pre-amplification and improved signal-to-noise ratio.
  • Further exploration into optimizing pseudo-CMOS for even lower power consumption and smaller footprint is implied.
  • The potential for inkjet printing and roll-to-roll fabrication, enabled by solution-processed CNTs, opens avenues for low-cost, large-area manufacturing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Carbon nanotube (CNT) thin-film transistor (TFT) is a promising candidate for flexible and wearable electronics. However, it usually suffers from low semiconducting tube purity, low device yield, and the mismatch between p- and n-type TFTs. Here, we report low-voltage and high-performance digital and analog CNT TFT circuits based on high-yield (19.9%) and ultrahigh purity (99.997%) polymer-sorted semiconducting CNTs. Using high-uniformity deposition and pseudo-CMOS design, we demonstrated CNT TFTs with good uniformity and high performance at low operation voltage of 3 V. We tested forty-four 2-µm channel 5-stage ring oscillators on the same flexible substrate (1,056 TFTs). All worked as expected with gate delays of 42.7 ± 13.1 ns. With these high-performance TFTs, we demonstrated 8-stage shift registers running at 50 kHz and the first tunable-gain amplifier with 1,000 gain at 20 kHz. These results show great potentials of using solution-processed CNT TFTs for large-scale flexible electronics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lei2019low,
  author = {Ting Lei and Leilai Shao and Yu‐Qing Zheng and Gregory Pitner and Guanhua Fang and Chenxin Zhu and Sicheng Li and Ray Beausoleil and H.-S. Philip Wong and Tsung‐Ching Huang and Kwang‐Ting Cheng and Zhenan Bao},
  title = {{Low-voltage high-performance flexible digital and analog circuits based on ultrahigh-purity semiconducting carbon nanotubes}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-10145-9},
}
Figure