Low-threshold motor unit membrane properties vary with contraction intensity during sustained activation with surface EMG visual feedback

Dario Farina, Marco Gazzoni, Federico CameliaJournal of Applied Physiology 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a non-invasive method using surface EMG visual feedback to track individual low-threshold motor units (MUs) for extended periods. They found that MU conduction velocity (CV) changes over time during sustained contractions, and this change is more pronounced at higher firing rates, offering insights into muscle fatigue and control strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how our nervous system controls muscle movement relies heavily on studying motor units (MUs), the fundamental building blocks of muscle activation. Historically, detailed analysis of individual MUs required invasive techniques (like inserting needles into muscles), which limited the ability to study them over long durations or in naturalistic conditions. While surface EMG can detect muscle activity non-invasively, it typically provides a mixed signal from many MUs, making it difficult to isolate and track a single MU's behavior. This paper addresses the challenge of non-invasively studying the dynamic changes in the properties of individual, low-threshold MUs during sustained, low-level contractions, which are relevant for understanding fatigue and neuromuscular disorders.

Methods

The core innovation here is the use of visual feedback of surface EMG signals to guide subjects in activating and maintaining the activity of a single low-threshold motor unit. Subjects were trained to modulate their force output to isolate and observe the action potentials of a specific MU on a computer screen. This allowed them to sustain contractions for 300 seconds at two different target firing rates: approximately 8 pulses per second (low-frequency, LF) and 12 pulses per second (high-frequency, HF).

After data acquisition, a sophisticated signal decomposition algorithm was employed. This algorithm, based on wavelet transforms and a multichannel neural network, was capable of segmenting and classifying individual MU action potentials (MUAPs) from the surface EMG signals. This allowed for the estimation of:

  • Instantaneous Firing Rate (IFR): The rate at which a MU fires at any given moment.
  • Conduction Velocity (CV): The speed at which the electrical signal travels along the muscle fiber membrane.

The researchers then analyzed how these properties changed over the 300-second contraction period and compared them between LF and HF conditions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved human subjects performing voluntary contractions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tracking individual MUs non-invasively is feasible: The visual feedback system proved effective in allowing subjects to isolate and maintain the activity of a single low-threshold MU for extended durations (300s). This opens doors for more detailed non-invasive studies of MU behavior.
  • Muscle fiber properties change during sustained low-level contractions: Even at low force levels, the conduction velocity (CV) of individual MUs decreased over time. This suggests that subtle changes in muscle fiber membrane properties occur even before significant fatigue sets in.
  • Contraction intensity matters for MU changes: The rate of CV decrease was significantly larger during high-frequency (HF) contractions compared to low-frequency (LF) contractions. This implies that the physiological state of the muscle fiber is more dynamic under higher activation demands.
  • Firing rate influences MU properties: The initial CV of a MU was found to be higher at higher firing rates, and there was a significant correlation between instantaneous firing rate and CV. This suggests a complex interplay between neural drive and the electrical properties of the muscle fiber.
  • MU recruitment and substitution are dynamic: The study observed that additional MUs could be recruited during sustained contractions, and in some cases, MUs could be "substituted" or temporarily deactivated and reactivated. This highlights the adaptive nature of motor control.

Key Results

  • CV Decrease: For most MUs, CV significantly decreased over the 300-second contraction. This decrease was more pronounced in HF contractions (larger absolute slope and normalized decrease) compared to LF contractions.
  • Firing Rate and CV Correlation: A positive correlation was found between instantaneous firing rate and CV (R ranging from 0.21 to 0.39). Initial CV was also higher in HF contractions than in LF contractions.
  • Recruitment: More MUs were recruited during HF contractions (11 for abductor pollicis, 6 for abductor digiti minimi) compared to LF contractions (3 and 1 respectively).
  • Newly Recruited MUs: The CV of newly recruited MUs at HF was generally lower than the feedback MU, and these also showed a decrease in CV over their activation period.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low-Threshold MUs Only: The technique is primarily applicable to low-threshold, superficial MUs, limiting its scope for studying deeper or high-threshold units.
  • Muscle Selection: The study focused on specific hand muscles (abductor pollicis and abductor digiti minimi) due to their thin subcutaneous layers and parallel fiber orientation, which aids in signal detection. The applicability to larger muscles might be more challenging.
  • Non-Constant Force: The contractions were not strictly isometric, as subjects modulated force to maintain a target firing rate. This is a departure from some traditional fatigue studies.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this technique provides a practical method for assessing both control and membrane properties of single MUs non-invasively. Future work could explore its application in studying neuromuscular disorders, fatigue development, and the effects of different exercise protocols. The ability to distinguish CV changes at slightly different firing rates is also highlighted as a key advantage for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Single-motor unit (MU) activities were detected from the abductor pollicis and abductor digiti minimi muscles providing the subjects with visual feedback of multichannel surface electromyogram (EMG) signals. The subjects could modulate the force to observe on the surface recordings a single dominant MU and modulate its firing rate for contractions of 300 s with a noninvasive EMG feedback. The firing rate was maintained at approximately 8 pulses per second [low-frequency (LF) contraction] and at approximately 12 pulses per second [high-frequency (HF) contraction]. Single-MU conduction velocity (CV) decreased slightly but significantly over time, and it was possible to identify a significantly larger rate of decrease of CV during the HF with respect to the LF contractions. CV initial value significantly increased with the average firing rate, and CV values were significantly correlated to the instantaneous firing rate (R ranging from 0.21 to 0.39). Both additional MU recruitment and substitution were observed during the contractions. The study provides evidence that 1). it is possible to follow the same MU in a hand muscle at two different intensities (HF and LF) for 300-s durations by using visual feedback of surface EMG, 2). low-threshold single-MU CV changes over time since the beginning of the contraction, and 3). it is possible to distinguish between CV changes of the same MU at slightly different firing rates. The technique provides a practical method for the noninvasive assessment of both control and membrane properties of single MUs.
BibTeX
@article{farina2004low,
  author = {Dario Farina and Marco Gazzoni and Federico Camelia},
  title = {{Low-threshold motor unit membrane properties vary with contraction intensity during sustained activation with surface EMG visual feedback}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Physiology},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1152/japplphysiol.01047.2003},
}
Figure