Low temperature response index for monitoring freezing injury of tea plant

Yilin Mao, He Li, Yu Wang, Kai Fan, Jiazhi Shen, Jie Zhang, Xiao Han, Yujie Song, Caihong Bi, Litao Sun, Zhaotang DingFrontiers in Plant Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a non-destructive method to monitor freezing injury in tea plants by combining hyperspectral imaging with deep learning. By creating a composite "Low Temperature Response Index" (LTRI) and using a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN), they achieved high-accuracy predictions ($R^2 = 0.89$) that could replace slow, destructive laboratory chemical analyses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tea plants (Camellia sinensis) are highly sensitive to cold. Freezing damage is a recurring natural disaster for tea plantations, leading to significant economic losses. To manage this, growers need to quantify the degree of injury.

Traditionally, this requires measuring physiological markers like chlorophyll content, soluble sugars, and enzyme activities (e.g., SOD, POD). However, these "wet lab" methods are a headache: they are destructive (you have to kill the leaf to test it), time-consuming, and labor-intensive. There is a critical need for a rapid, non-invasive way to "see" how much a plant is suffering from cold stress before visible symptoms even appear.

Methods

The authors designed a multi-stage pipeline to move from physical leaves to digital predictions:

  1. Stress Induction: They subjected two tea varieties to various temperatures: Control (25°C), Chilling (4°C), and Freezing (-4°C) for durations of 8 and 12 hours.
  2. The LTRI Index: Instead of predicting just one chemical, they used Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to combine six physiological indicators (SPAD, SS, MDA, CAT, POD, and SOD) into a single Low Temperature Response Index (LTRI). This provides a more holistic view of plant health.
  3. Hyperspectral Imaging (HSI): They captured spectral data (397–1008 nm) for 192 samples. This data contains "hidden" information about the leaf's chemical composition.
  4. Feature Selection: To avoid "the curse of dimensionality," they compared three algorithms to find the most important spectral bands: Successive Projections Algorithm (SPA), Competitive Adaptive Reweighted Sampling (CARS), and Uninformative Variable Elimination (UVE).
  5. Modeling: They tested six different architectures, ranging from traditional machine learning (SVM, Random Forest, PLS) to deep learning (CNN, LSTM).

Datasets

The study used a custom dataset generated in the Tea Biology Laboratory of Qingdao Agricultural University:

  • Samples: 192 total samples from 2-year-old "Zhongcha 108" and "Longjing 43" tea plants.
  • Split: 153 samples for training and 39 for testing (using five-fold cross-validation).
  • Data Type: Hyperspectral cubes (960 × 1101 pixels across 176 spectral channels).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Fusion (LTRI): Predicting a single marker (like MDA) is often noisy. By creating the LTRI, the authors synthesized multiple biological responses into one robust target variable. The results showed that the relationship between the spectrum and the LTRI was stronger than with any single physiological indicator.
  • UVE vs. The Rest: While CARS and SPA are popular for picking "feature bands," the UVE algorithm performed best here. It retained more abundant information (150 bands for LTRI) compared to the aggressive pruning of SPA (16 bands), which proved vital for the deep learning models to learn complex patterns.
  • CNNs Outperform Traditional ML: The Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) was the clear winner. Unlike standard regression models, CNNs are adept at extracting hierarchical features from the spectral data, making them more resilient to the noise inherent in biological samples.

Key Results

  • Best Model: The LTRI-UVE-CNN combination was the top performer.
  • Accuracy: It achieved a Coefficient of Determination ($R^2_p$) of 0.890.
  • Reliability: The Residual Predictive Deviation (RPD) was 2.904. In spectroscopy, an RPD > 2.5 is generally considered excellent for quantitative prediction.
  • Comparison: The CNN model consistently outperformed LSTM and traditional machine learning models (like SVM and PLS) across almost all tested indicators.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: While 192 samples are sufficient for a proof-of-concept, deep learning typically thrives on much larger datasets. Expanding the sample size could further improve model generalization.
  • Controlled vs. Field Conditions: The data was collected in a controlled laboratory environment with artificial climate boxes. Real-world tea plantations have variable lighting, humidity, and complex canopies that might interfere with hyperspectral readings.
  • Variety Specificity: The model was trained on only two varieties. Future work should test if these spectral signatures hold true across a wider range of tea cultivars.
  • Hardware Integration: The next logical step is moving this from a lab-based hyperspectral camera to a portable device or drone-mounted sensor for real-time field monitoring.

Summary updated

Abstract

Freezing damage has been a common natural disaster for tea plantations. Quantitative detection of low temperature stress is significant for evaluating the degree of freezing injury to tea plants. Traditionally, the determination of physicochemical parameters of tea leaves and the investigation of freezing damage phenotype are the main approaches to detect the low temperature stress. However, these methods are time-consuming and laborious. In this study, different low temperature treatments were carried out on tea plants. The low temperature response index (LTRI) was established by measuring seven low temperature-induced components of tea leaves. The hyperspectral data of tea leaves was obtained by hyperspectral imaging and the feature bands were screened by successive projections algorithm (SPA), competitive adaptive reweighted sampling (CARS) and uninformative variable elimination (UVE). The LTRI and seven indexes of tea plant were modeled by partial least squares (PLS), support vector machine (SVM), random forests (RF), back propagation (BP) machine learning methods and convolutional neural networks (CNN), long short-term memory (LSTM) deep learning methods. The results indicated that: (1) the best prediction model for the seven indicators was LTRI-UVE-CNN (R<sup>2 =</sup> 0.890, RMSEP=0.325, RPD=2.904); (2) the feature bands screened by UVE algorithm were more abundant, and the later modeling effect was better than CARS and SPA algorithm; (3) comparing the effects of the six modeling algorithms, the overall modeling effect of the CNN model was better than other models. It can be concluded that out of all the combined models in this paper, the LTRI-UVE-CNN was a promising model for predicting the degree of low temperature stress in tea plants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mao2023low,
  author = {Yilin Mao and He Li and Yu Wang and Kai Fan and Jiazhi Shen and Jie Zhang and Xiao Han and Yujie Song and Caihong Bi and Litao Sun and Zhaotang Ding},
  title = {{Low temperature response index for monitoring freezing injury of tea plant}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2023.1096490},
}
Figure