Low-$Q^{2}$ nucleon structure from an infrared-safe evolution scheme

Rong WangarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new "infrared-safe" mathematical framework that successfully bridges the gap between the messy, low-energy world of nuclear physics and the high-energy realm of particle physics. By starting with just three "valence" quarks and evolving them through an all-order scheme that accounts for effective particle masses and saturated coupling, they can predict the internal structure of the nucleon across the entire energy spectrum.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the internal structure of the nucleon (protons and neutrons) is one of the "holy grails" of modern physics. We describe this structure using Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs), which tell us how momentum is shared among the quarks and gluons inside.

At high energies (high $Q^2$), we have a solid theory called Perturbative Quantum Chromodynamics (pQCD) and a standard set of equations (DGLAP) to describe how these distributions change. However, at low energies (the "infrared" region), the theory breaks down. The strong force coupling constant becomes infinitely large (the "Landau pole" problem), and the quarks, which we usually treat as massless, gain significant "effective" mass due to complex interactions. This paper tackles the challenge of creating a unified "evolution scheme" that works from zero energy all the way to infinity, connecting the simple quark model to the complex data seen in high-energy colliders.

Methods

The author proposes an infrared-safe evolution scheme that modifies the standard DGLAP equations with three key nonperturbative ingredients:

  1. Dressed Parton Masses: Instead of treating quarks and gluons as massless points, the model uses "dressed" masses that vary with momentum, reflecting how quarks get "fat" with energy at low scales due to Dynamical Chiral Symmetry Breaking (DCSB).
  2. Saturating Strong Coupling: To avoid the mathematical catastrophe of the coupling constant blowing up at low energies, the author uses a version of the strong force ($\alpha_s$) that levels off (saturates) at a finite value in the infrared region.
  3. Parton Recombination: At low energies, the nucleon is "crowded." The model includes terms for quarks and gluons recombining, which slows down the rapid growth of gluon density that standard equations would otherwise predict.

The starting point (the "hadronic scale") is a simple input of three valence quarks calculated via the Maximum Entropy Method (MEM).

Datasets

The study validates its theoretical predictions against experimental measurements of the $F_2$ structure function from JLab (Jefferson Lab). Specifically, it compares the model to data in the "resonance region"—a low-energy regime where the nucleon can be excited into short-lived states like the Delta baryon.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Valence Bump": At extremely low $Q^2$, the structure function is dominated almost entirely by the three valence quarks. The paper shows that this "valence-quark bump" is the primary origin of the complex PDFs we see at much higher energies.
  • Quark-Hadron Duality: One of the most striking findings is that while the experimental data shows jagged "resonance peaks," the smooth theoretical curve from the evolution scheme acts as a perfect "average" or modulator for these peaks. This supports the idea of quark-hadron duality—that the physics of quarks can describe the physics of composite hadrons even at low energies.
  • Factorization Breakdown: The paper confirms that at very low $Q^2$, the standard "factorization theorem" (which allows us to separate hard and soft physics) begins to fail. This is a clear signal that "higher-twist" effects—complex multi-parton interactions—become significant.

Key Results

  • Unified Evolution: The scheme successfully delivers consistent PDFs across the entire range from $0 \text{ GeV}^2$ to infinity.
  • Resonance Modulation: The predicted $F_2$ structure functions accurately capture the shape and magnitude of the JLab data, effectively "averaging" the resonance peaks.
  • Scale Independence: The results were found to be robust and relatively insensitive to the exact choice of the starting "hadronic scale" ($Q_0^2$), provided it is sufficiently low (around $0.1 \text{ GeV}^2$ or less).
  • Quantifying the Gap: The study highlights a sizeable discrepancy between theory and experiment at the lowest scales, which quantitatively proves the necessity of high-twist corrections in the infrared region.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation acknowledged is the exclusion of high-twist corrections. While the infrared-safe evolution handles the "leading-twist" (most important) part of the physics, the multi-quark correlations (high-twist) are needed to perfectly match low-energy experimental data.

The author suggests that future high-precision data from facilities like the Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) in the US and the EicC in China will be essential. These experiments will allow researchers to measure electrons at very small angles, providing the high-resolution "microscope" needed to further refine this transition from nonperturbative to perturbative physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

The low-$Q^2$ nucleon structure is given with a simple nonperturbative input of three valence quarks and an all-order infrared-safe evolution scheme, showing some consistences with the experimental data. The resonance peaks in the experimental data of $F_2$ structure function are found to be modulated by the valence quark distributions. With little sea quark distribution at low $Q^2$ the valence-quark bump is clearly shown in the structure function. The three valence quark distributions at the hadronic scale is found to be the dominant origin of the PDFs at the hard scales. The high-twist corrections are needed to explain the sizeable discrepancy between the theory and the experimental measurements at low $Q^2$. The infrared-safe evolution scheme is a powerful tool for connecting the nucleon structures in the nonperturbative and perturbative regions.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2024low,
  author = {Rong Wang},
  title = {{Low-$Q^\{2\}$ nucleon structure from an infrared-safe evolution scheme}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2410.00468},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.00468},
}
Figure