Low Mach Number Limit of Multidimensional Steady Flows on the Airfoil Problem

Mingjie Li, Tian-Yi Wang, Wei XiangarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In this paper, we justify the low Mach number limit of the steady irrotational Euler flows for the airfoil problem, which is the first result for the low Mach number limit of the steady Euler flows in an exterior domain. The uniform estimates on the compressibility parameter $\varepsilon$, which is singular for the flows, are established via a variational approach based on the compressible-incompressible difference functions. The limit is on the Hölder space and is unique. Moreover, the convergence rate is of order $\varepsilon^2$. It is noticeable that, due to the feature of the airfoil problem, the extra force dominates the asymptotic decay rate of the compressible flow to the infinity. And the effect of extra force vanishes in the limiting process from compressible flows to the incompressible ones, as the Mach number goes to zero.

Introduction

In fluid dynamics, the Mach number ($M$) represents the ratio of flow velocity to the local speed of sound. When $M$ is very small, gases behave much like incompressible liquids. While physicists have long assumed that compressible Euler equations "become" incompressible equations as $M \to 0$, proving this mathematically is difficult because the limit is "singular"—the nature of the underlying equations changes fundamentally.

Most previous research focused on flows within bounded containers or general initial-value problems. This paper tackles the exterior domain problem: flow moving past a solid object (like an airfoil) into infinite space. The challenge lies in obtaining "uniform estimates"—mathematical bounds that don't blow up as the compressibility parameter $\varepsilon$ goes to zero—especially when external conservative forces (like gravity or electric fields) are acting on the fluid.

Problem Formulation and Methodology

The authors employ a variational approach to bridge the gap between compressible and incompressible models. By assuming the flow is irrotational (curl-free), the velocity can be represented as the gradient of a potential function ($\nabla \phi$), transforming the Euler equations into a single second-order nonlinear elliptic equation.

Geometric setup of the airfoil problem in an exterior domain $\Omega$.

Key techniques include:

  • Compressible-Incompressible Difference Functions: To get stable estimates, they introduce a variational functional based on the difference between the compressible and incompressible velocity potentials. This allows them to isolate the error terms and prove they vanish as $\varepsilon \to 0$.
  • Subsonic Cut-off: Because the equations are only "nice" (uniformly elliptic) when the flow is subsonic, the authors use a mathematical truncation method to handle the nonlinearity before proving that the actual physical solution stays within the subsonic regime.
  • Bernoulli’s Law: They use a refined version of Bernoulli’s law to link pressure, density, and velocity, which is crucial for proving the convergence of the pressure gradient.

Key Insights and Results

One of the most striking findings is the Vanishing Force Effect. In a compressible flow, an extra conservative force (like an electric field) actually dominates how fast the flow decays as you move infinitely far away from the airfoil. However, in the incompressible limit, this effect completely vanishes.

Additionally, the authors achieve a Superior Convergence Rate of $O(\varepsilon^2)$, whereas many similar limits in fluid dynamics only yield $O(\varepsilon)$. This higher rate is a direct result of the irrotational property of the steady flow. The limit holds in Hölder space ($C^\alpha$), meaning the "smoothness" of the flow is preserved during the transition.

Quantitatively, the paper proves:

  • Existence and Uniqueness: For a sufficiently small Mach number, there exists a unique, smooth subsonic solution.
  • Quantitative Convergence:
    • Density: $\rho^{(\varepsilon)} = 1 + O(\varepsilon^2)$
    • Velocity: $u^{(\varepsilon)} = \bar{u} + O(\varepsilon^2)$
    • Pressure Gradient: $\nabla p^{(\varepsilon)} = \nabla \bar{p} + O(\varepsilon^2)$
  • Asymptotic Decay: The difference between the compressible and incompressible velocity potentials decays at a rate of $(1 + |x|)^{-\beta'}$, where $\beta'$ depends on the dimension and the decay of the external force.

Limitations and Future Work

While this work provides a rigorous foundation for exterior domain problems, it relies on the flow being irrotational. In real-world aerodynamics, objects often create wakes or vortices (rotational flow), which this model does not yet account for. Furthermore, the paper focuses on steady-state flows; extending these results to time-dependent (unsteady) flows remains a significant open challenge. Finally, the results assume the airfoil has a relatively smooth boundary ($C^{2,\alpha}$), as sharp-edged geometries may preclude the existence of classical solutions.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we justify the low Mach number limit of the steady irrotational Euler flows for the airfoil problem, which is the first result for the low Mach number limit of the steady Euler flows in an exterior domain. The uniform estimates on the compressibility parameter $\varepsilon$, which is singular for the flows, are established via a variational approach based on the compressible-incompressible difference functions. The limit is on the Hölder space and is unique. Moreover, the convergence rate is of order $\varepsilon^2$. It is noticeable that, due to the feature of the airfoil problem, the extra force dominates the asymptotic decay rate of the compressible flow to the infinity. And the effect of extra force vanishes in the limiting process from compressible flows to the incompressible ones, as the Mach number goes to zero.
BibTeX
@misc{li2019low,
  author = {Mingjie Li and Tian-Yi Wang and Wei Xiang},
  title = {{Low Mach Number Limit of Multidimensional Steady Flows on the Airfoil Problem}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1901.04320},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.04320},
}

Loading related content...

Figure