Abstract
Collagen preserved in paleontological bones serves as a vital resource for isotopic measurement, radiocarbon dating, and paleoproteomic analysis, offering insights into ancient diets, chronology, and phylogeny. However, traditional proteomic methods are destructive, requiring significant bone material (milligrams to tens of milligrams), which poses a challenge for rare museum artifacts. This study introduces a low-invasive sampling method utilizing dermatological skin tape discs to collect bone micropowders. By combining this sampling technique with an optimized enhanced filter-aided sample preparation (eFASP) protocol and high-resolution mass spectrometry (MALDI FTICR MS and LC-MS/MS), researchers successfully identified genus taxa and post-translational modifications in bones dating from the Holocene to the Upper Pleistocene (up to 130,000 years old). The method demonstrates that high-quality proteomic data can be obtained without visible deterioration of the specimen, facilitating analysis directly at archaeological sites or within museum collections.
Introduction: The Preservation Dilemma
In archaeology and paleontology, taxonomic identification is the cornerstone of reconstructing past ecosystems and human behaviors. Zooarchaeology by Mass Spectrometry (ZooMS) has revolutionized this field by identifying species through peptide mass fingerprinting of bone collagen. Despite its utility, the traditional ZooMS workflow is inherently destructive, typically involving the removal of bone material via drilling or scraping. For unique artifacts, such as carved bone tools or rare hominin remains, even minimal damage is often unacceptable.
Previous attempts to develop non-destructive sampling—such as using PVC erasers or simple surface rubbing—have frequently resulted in low protein yields, contamination, or unsightly residues. There is a pressing need for a "traceless" sampling method that maintains the analytical rigor of traditional proteomics while respecting the integrity of the physical record.
Methodology: A Dermatological Approach to Paleontology
The researchers adapted a tool common in dermatology: D-Squame® skin tape-discs. These 22mm adhesive discs are designed to collect superficial skin cells but proved equally effective at capturing microscopic amounts of bone powder from the surface of ancient specimens.
Sampling and Extraction
The process involves pressing a tape disc onto the bone surface for three seconds. Upon removal, the disc carries a thin layer of bone micropowder. Unlike traditional methods that require harsh acidic demineralization—a process that can degrade delicate proteins—this method utilizes an extraction buffer (8 M urea) combined with sonication to release proteins directly from the tape.
Optimized Digestion (eFASP)
To handle the extremely low concentrations of protein recovered, the team employed an enhanced Filter Aided Sample Preparation (eFASP) protocol. This "all-in-one-tube" approach minimizes sample loss during the cleaning and digestion phases. Crucially, the eFASP washing steps were found to effectively remove adhesive polymers from the tape, preventing them from interfering with subsequent mass spectrometry analysis.
Analytical Techniques
The samples were analyzed using two complementary mass spectrometry platforms:
- MALDI FTICR MS: Provides rapid, ultra-high-resolution peptide mass fingerprints for quick screening.
- LC-MS/MS: Offers deep sequencing of amino acids, enabling precise taxonomic identification and the detection of Post-Translational Modifications (PTMs).
Validation Across Deep Time
The method was tested on a diverse set of samples to ensure its robustness across different preservation states:
- Modern Reference: Bos taurus (cow), Struthio camelus (ostrich), and Cervus elaphus (red deer).
- Neolithic/Bronze Age (3800–150 BC): Samples from French archaeological sites, including wild boar and horse.
- Upper Pleistocene (up to 130,000 BP): Fossilized remains from the Sarrasins cave (Belgium) and Waziers (France), featuring extinct megafauna like Ursus spelaeus (cave bear) and Bos primigenius (aurochs).
Key Findings and Advantages
1. Traceless Sampling
Optical microscopy confirmed that the application of up to five tape strips left no visible trace on the bone surface. This stands in stark contrast to traditional ZooMS, which leaves noticeable scars, or swab-based methods that can leave behind white chemical deposits.
2. Preservation of Molecular Clocks
Because the method avoids boiling and acid treatments, it preserves fragile PTMs such as glutamine deamidation. The degree of deamidation serves as a "molecular clock," allowing researchers to distinguish between authentic ancient proteins and modern environmental contamination—a critical requirement for high-stakes paleontological research.
3. High Taxonomic Accuracy
The proteomic results were 100% consistent with morphological identifications at the family level and 95% consistent at the genus level. Even in 130,000-year-old samples, the researchers achieved approximately 40% sequence coverage of the Collagen alpha-1 chain, providing ample data for confident identification.
4. Resilience to Curation Practices
The study successfully identified an ostrich bone that had undergone aggressive museum cleaning (boiling and hydrogen peroxide treatment). This suggests the tape-disc method can bypass surface alterations caused by historical curation practices.
Future Directions
While the sampling method is highly effective, the primary limitation remains the availability of comprehensive protein databases. Many extinct species lack complete collagen sequences in public repositories like UniProt or NCBI, which can limit identification to the genus or family level.
Future research will likely focus on identifying Non-Collagenous Proteins (NCPs). Because NCPs evolve more rapidly than the highly conserved Type I collagen, they may provide the necessary resolution to distinguish between closely related species that currently appear identical in collagen fingerprints.
Conclusion
The tape-disc sampling method represents a significant leap forward in "low-invasive" archaeology. By enabling high-resolution proteomic analysis without visible damage, it opens the door for the systematic study of the world's most precious museum collections and facilitates rapid, on-site taxonomic identification during excavations.
Summary updated