Low-Cycle Fatigue Behavior of Nuclear-Grade Austenitic Stainless Steel Fabricated by Additive Manufacturing

Jianhui Shi, Huiqiang Liu, Zhimin Liu, Runzhong Wang, Huanchun Wu, Haitao Dong, Xinming Meng, Min YuCrystals 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the low-cycle fatigue behavior of nuclear-grade austenitic stainless steel produced by additive manufacturing (AM) compared to conventionally forged material. While AM offers advantages for complex nuclear components, its fatigue performance, particularly in the Z-direction, is lower than forged counterparts due to microstructural anisotropy and inherent defects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The nuclear power industry increasingly relies on advanced materials for components that must withstand extreme conditions, including cyclic loading. Additive manufacturing (AM) presents a promising alternative to traditional methods for fabricating complex geometries and reducing production time. However, AM processes can introduce unique microstructural features like anisotropy, residual stresses, and defects (e.g., incomplete fusion). These can significantly impact the material's mechanical properties, especially fatigue resistance, which is critical for the safety and reliability of nuclear reactor systems. This paper aims to systematically characterize and compare the low-cycle fatigue behavior of nuclear-grade austenitic stainless steel (Z2CN19-10) produced via Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM) against conventionally forged material, identifying the underlying microstructural reasons for any performance differences.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze the materials:

  • Fatigue Testing: Low-cycle fatigue tests were conducted under strain-controlled conditions using a servo-hydraulic testing machine.
  • Microstructural Characterization:
    • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): Used to examine the overall microstructure and fatigue fracture surfaces.
  • Electron Backscatter Diffraction (EBSD): Employed to analyze crystallographic orientation, grain structure, and residual strain.
  • Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM): Utilized to investigate the dislocation morphology within the crack propagation zones.
  • Mechanical Property Testing: Standard tensile and impact tests were performed at room temperature to assess basic mechanical performance.
  • Chemical Analysis: A direct-reading spectrometer was used to confirm the chemical composition of both AM and forged materials.

The study focused on comparing specimens from different directions (X, Y, and Z) of the AM material against the forged material to understand the impact of AM's inherent anisotropy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from the fabricated and tested materials.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Anisotropy is a Key Factor: The AM material exhibits significant microstructural anisotropy, with directional grain growth (columnar crystals along the Z-direction) and varying residual strain. This directly influences its mechanical properties.
  • AM Material Underperforms Forged: Across the board, the AM stainless steel showed lower tensile strength, impact properties, and fatigue life compared to the conventionally forged material. This highlights the challenges in achieving equivalent performance with current AM processes for critical applications.
  • Z-Direction is Particularly Vulnerable: Fatigue life was consistently lower in the Z-direction specimens of the AM material, suggesting this orientation is most susceptible to fatigue damage.
  • Defects Drive Fatigue Failure: Incompletely melted particles and manufacturing defects (like lack-of-fusion) in the AM material act as stress concentration sites, leading to multiple crack initiation points and reduced fatigue life. Forged materials, with fewer such defects, typically exhibit single crack initiation sites.
  • Plastic Strain Dominance: While AM materials generally have lower fatigue life, the Z-direction specimens showed a higher propensity for plastic strain contribution to fatigue life (indicated by a higher transition fatigue life, NT) within a specific strain amplitude range (0.3% to 0.6%). This suggests a complex interplay between plastic deformation and fatigue mechanisms.
  • Dislocation Behavior Matters: TEM analysis revealed differences in dislocation density and morphology between forged and AM materials. Forged materials generally showed higher dislocation densities, suggesting more robust mechanisms for plastic deformation and energy dissipation, contributing to better fatigue resistance.

Key Results

  • Tensile Strength: AM material's tensile strength (Rm) was reduced by over 51 MPa compared to forged specimens (565 MPa vs. 616 MPa).
  • Fatigue Life (Nf): Forged specimens exhibited superior fatigue performance. For example, at a strain amplitude of 0.6%, Nf for forged material was 1766 cycles, while for AM specimens, it ranged from 693 (Z-direction) to 973 (X-direction) cycles.
  • Transition Fatigue Life (NT): The Z-direction AM specimens showed the highest NT (4192 cycles), indicating a greater contribution of plastic strain to fatigue life in this orientation within a specific strain range.
  • Crack Initiation: Forged specimens typically showed single crack initiation sites, while AM specimens exhibited multiple sites due to defects.
  • Striation Spacing: AM specimens had larger striation spacings (2.3-2.6 µm) compared to forged specimens (2.0 µm), indicating slower crack growth per cycle in the latter.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the AM materials exhibited anisotropy and lower overall fatigue properties compared to forged materials. The study highlights the need for further research to:

  • Improve AM Processes: Develop strategies to mitigate anisotropy and reduce defects in AM processes for nuclear applications.
  • Optimize Post-Processing: Investigate the effectiveness of post-processing treatments (e.g., heat treatments) to enhance the fatigue performance of AM components.
  • In-depth Fracture Mechanism Analysis: Further elucidate the complex fatigue fracture mechanisms, particularly the role of specific defect types and their interaction with dislocation behavior.
  • Long-Term Performance: Extend the investigation to include high-cycle fatigue and the effects of the nuclear environment (e.g., irradiation, high temperatures) on the fatigue behavior of AM materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

The application of additive manufacturing technology in the field of nuclear power is becoming increasingly promising. The low-cycle fatigue behavior of Z2CN19-10 controlled-nitrogen-content stainless steel (SS) was investigated by fatigue equipment, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM), including additive manufactured (AM) and forged materials. The results showed that the microstructure of the AM material exhibited anisotropy for the X, Y, and Z directions. The tensile and impact properties of the X, Y, and Z directions in AM material were similar. The fatigue life (Nf) of X- and Y-direction specimens was better than that of Z-direction specimens. The tensile, impact, and fatigue properties of all AM materials were lower than those of the forged specimens. The Z direction specimens of AM material showed the best plastic strain by the highest transition fatigue life (NT) during the fatigue strain amplitude at 0.3% to 0.6%. The forged specimens showed the best fatigue properties under the plastic strain amplitude control mode. Fatigue fracture surfaces of AM and forged materials exhibited multi- and single-fatigue crack initiation sites, respectively. This could be attributed to the presence of incompletely melted particles and manufacturing defects inside the AM specimens. The dislocation morphology of AM and forged fatigue specimens was observed to study the low-cycle fatigue behaviors in depth.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shi2025low,
  author = {Jianhui Shi and Huiqiang Liu and Zhimin Liu and Runzhong Wang and Huanchun Wu and Haitao Dong and Xinming Meng and Min Yu},
  title = {{Low-Cycle Fatigue Behavior of Nuclear-Grade Austenitic Stainless Steel Fabricated by Additive Manufacturing}},
  booktitle = {Crystals},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/cryst15070644},
}
Figure