Low Correlation Interference OFDM-NLFM Waveform Design for MIMO Radar Based on Alternating Optimization

Tianqu Liu, Jinping Sun, Qing Li, Zhimei Hao, Guohua WangSensors 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for designing OFDM-NLFM waveforms for MIMO radar systems. By employing an alternating optimization strategy combining Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) and Block Coordinate Descent (BCD), they achieve significantly lower auto- and cross-correlation sidelobes compared to existing state-of-the-art methods, improving radar performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

MIMO (Multiple-Input Multiple-Output) radar systems offer advantages like improved power efficiency and clutter suppression by using multiple transmit and receive antennas. A key challenge in MIMO radar is designing waveform sets that minimize interference between signals. Specifically, the auto-correlation function (how well a signal correlates with itself) and the cross-correlation function (how much one signal interferes with another) need to be optimized. Low auto-correlation sidelobes are crucial for accurate pulse compression (determining range and velocity), while low cross-correlation sidelobes are essential to avoid interference between different transmitted signals. Existing OFDM-NLFM waveforms, while promising, still have room for improvement in reducing these correlation peaks. This paper aims to design an OFDM-NLFM waveform set with even lower peak auto-correlation sidelobe ratio (PASR) and peak cross-correlation ratio (PCCR) than the current best (IN-OFDM).

Methods

The core of this paper is a novel waveform design algorithm based on alternating optimization. This approach tackles the complex, high-dimensional optimization problem by breaking it down into smaller, manageable sub-problems. The algorithm iteratively optimizes two sets of parameters:

  1. NLFM Parameters: These define the time-frequency structure of the non-linear frequency modulation (NLFM) signal. The Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) algorithm is used to find the optimal continuous NLFM parameters. PSO is chosen for its efficiency in handling complex, high-dimensional continuous optimization problems.
  2. Discrete Code Matrices: These include the sub-chirp sequence code matrix (which determines the order of sub-chirps) and the sub-chirp rate plus-and-minus (PM) code matrix (which determines if a sub-chirp is an up-chirp or down-chirp). The Block Coordinate Descent (BCD) algorithm is employed to optimize these discrete parameters. BCD is effective for optimizing discrete variables by iteratively updating blocks of parameters.

The two sub-algorithms (PSO and BCD) are executed alternately. The output of one algorithm serves as the input for the other, ensuring that the overall objective function (minimizing PASR and PCCR) monotonically decreases until convergence.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a simulation-based design and evaluation process rather than using pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Alternating Optimization for Mixed Variables: The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of alternating optimization for problems with both continuous (NLFM parameters) and discrete (code matrices) variables. This is a powerful strategy for complex optimization tasks.
  • Synergy of PSO and BCD: Combining PSO for continuous optimization and BCD for discrete optimization proves to be a robust approach for this specific waveform design problem, leveraging the strengths of each algorithm.
  • Impact of NLFM Structure on Correlation: The research highlights how carefully designing the time-frequency structure of NLFM signals, through the optimization of NLFM parameters, directly impacts the auto- and cross-correlation properties of the resulting OFDM-NLFM waveforms.
  • Importance of Code Matrices: The sub-chirp sequence and PM code matrices play a crucial role in further suppressing correlation peaks by controlling the order and direction of sub-chirps.

Key Results

The proposed OFDM-NLFM waveform set design algorithm achieved significant improvements over the existing IN-OFDM waveform:

  • PASR Reduction: The optimized waveform set achieved a PASR approximately 4.03 dB lower than IN-OFDM.
  • PCCR Reduction: The optimized waveform set achieved a PCCR approximately 5.2845 dB lower than IN-OFDM.
  • Stability: Analysis of random initializations showed that the proposed method is stable, with low standard deviations in PASR and PCCR values across different runs.
  • Convergence: The convergence curves demonstrated that the objective function (max[PASR, PCCR]) rapidly decreased from initial values around -7 to -14 dB to values around -20 dB.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Time-Domain Segmentation Parameters: The paper acknowledges that time-domain segmentation parameters can influence the results. While they explored this effect, they suggest that careful selection of these parameters is crucial for optimal performance. Future work could involve jointly optimizing these parameters.
  • Computational Complexity: While the alternating optimization approach decomposes the problem, the overall optimization process can still be computationally intensive, especially for larger MIMO systems.
  • Parameter Space Exploration: The paper mentions that the design freedoms of the OFDM-NLFM waveform set can be limited when M (number of transmit signals) is large. Further research could explore how to maintain design flexibility in such scenarios.

The authors suggest that further research could focus on optimizing the time-domain segmentation parameters and exploring the impact of other system parameters on the waveform design.

Summary updated

Abstract

The OFDM chirp signal is suitable for MIMO radar applications due to its large time-bandwidth product, constant time-domain, and almost constant frequency-domain modulus. Particularly, by introducing the time-frequency structure of the non-linear frequency modulation (NLFM) signal into the design of an OFDM chirp waveform, a new OFDM-NLFM waveform with low peak auto-correlation sidelobe ratio (PASR) and peak cross-correlation ratio (PCCR) is obtained. IN-OFDM is the OFDM-NLFM waveform set currently with the lowest PASR and PCCR. Here we construct the optimization model of the OFDM-NLFM waveform set with the objective function being the maximum of the PASR and PCCR. Further, this paper proposes an OFDM-NLFM waveform set design algorithm inspired by alternating optimization. We implement the proposed algorithm by the alternate execution of two sub-algorithms. First, we keep both the sub-chirp sequence code matrix and sub-chirp rate plus and minus (PM) code matrix unchanged and use the particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm to obtain the optimal parameters of the NLFM signal’s time-frequency structure (NLFM parameters). Next, we keep current optimal NLFM parameters unchanged, and optimize the sub-chirp sequence code matrix and sub-chirp rate PM code matrix using the block coordinate descent (BCD) algorithm. The above two sub-algorithms are alternately executed until the objective function converges to the optimal solution. The results show that the PASR and PCCR of the obtained OFDM-NLFM waveform set are about 5 dB lower than that of the IN-OFDM.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2021low,
  author = {Tianqu Liu and Jinping Sun and Qing Li and Zhimei Hao and Guohua Wang},
  title = {{Low Correlation Interference OFDM-NLFM Waveform Design for MIMO Radar Based on Alternating Optimization}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=JhHHKGYYga},
}
Figure