Love, Life, and “Leftover Ladies” in Urban China

Jing You, Xuejie Yi, Meng ChenMunich 2016

TL;DR

This paper investigates the complex factors influencing marriage decisions for urban Chinese women aged 27 and above, a demographic often labeled "leftover ladies." It reveals that while higher education is generally beneficial, it paradoxically decreases marriage probability in China, a phenomenon termed "marital college-discount," suggesting a persistent patriarchal ideology that prioritizes traditional roles over educated women's career pursuits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the seemingly paradoxical trend in urban China where, despite a skewed sex ratio favoring men, marriage rates are declining, particularly among well-educated women in their late 20s and 30s. This demographic, termed "leftover ladies," faces societal pressure and a complex interplay of personal, social, and economic factors influencing their marital prospects. The research aims to disentangle these factors, moving beyond simplistic explanations to understand the multidimensional decision-making process involved in marriage formation for this group.

Methods

The authors employ a recursive and dynamic mixed-equation model to analyze the joint decisions of urban Chinese women regarding their careers, education, and marriage. This approach allows them to capture the interdependencies and feedback loops between these life choices. They incorporate a wide array of individual and household characteristics, including demographic traits, wealth, work-related indicators, personality, attitudes, physical attractiveness, social status, and local gender norms. Counterfactual analysis is used to explore multidimensional matching patterns, examining monotonicity, complementarity, and substitution among these factors.

Datasets

The study utilizes two nationally representative datasets:

  • China General Social Survey (CGSS): Waves from 2008, 2010, and 2011.
  • China Family Panel Survey (CFPS): Waves from 2010 and 2012.

These datasets were chosen for their comprehensive coverage of individual and household information relevant to marriage decisions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Marital College-Discount": The most striking finding is that higher education, particularly college and postgraduate degrees, significantly reduces the probability of marriage for urban Chinese women. This contradicts the "marital college-plus premium" observed in some Western countries and highlights a unique aspect of the Chinese marriage market.
  • Persistent Patriarchy: Despite modernization, traditional patriarchal gender norms continue to heavily influence marriage markets in China. Women's higher education and desirable traits are perceived as "negative signals" for traditional household production, creating a dilemma for educated women.
  • Multidimensional Matching: Marriage formation is not driven by a single factor but by a complex interplay of traits, where complementarity and substitutability exist between different criteria. For example, while education might deter marriage, other factors like sociability can mitigate this effect.
  • "Win-Win" of Working: Longer working hours, while seemingly a trade-off with dating, can create opportunities for women to meet potential partners and earn more, potentially leading to a "win-win" scenario.

Key Results

  • College education reduces the probability of marriage by 2.88%-3.6%.
  • A postgraduate degree further reduces it by 8.4%-10.4%.
  • Counterfactual simulations show that factors like grit and sociability reduce the likelihood of non-marriage, while self-efficacy increases it.
  • Facial attractiveness and fitness reduce non-marriage rates, especially for less-educated women, but can increase it for highly educated women.
  • Women with higher expectations of future social status than men's median are less likely to marry, and their educational attainment is significantly lower than that of single women with similar expectations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study acknowledges that some variables were not available across all datasets or waves, leading to potential limitations in the scope of analysis for certain factors. For instance, data on traits or leisure activities were not available for all CFPS waves.
  • Endogeneity: The paper notes potential endogeneity issues, particularly concerning living arrangements and marital status, and mentions that estimators were used to address this.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research could explore the nuances of these "negative signals" and how they interact with evolving gender ideologies. The study also opens avenues for investigating the long-term implications of these trends on family formation and societal structures in China.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Chinese urban society in recent years has shown rising age at first marriage and declining marriage rates, especially among professional females with at least college degrees in their late 20s or their 30s. We exploit two nationally representative datasets over the period 2008-2012 and investigate the determinants of forming marriage for urban women aged 27 or above who are termed “leftover”. We estimate a recursive and dynamic mixed-equation model to describe women’s joint decisions on career, education and marriage. This considers various traits including demographic characteristics, wealth, work-related indicators, personality, attitudes and expectation, physical and facial attractiveness, leisure activities, personal and parental social status, local gender identity norms and marriage market conditions. We find “marital college-discount”: college education reduces the probability of marriage by 2.88%-3.6% and a postgraduate degree further oppresses it by 8.4%-10.4%. Counterfactual analysis indicates monotonicity, complementarity and substitution in multidimensional matching patterns. Patriarchy still appears to prevail.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{you2016love,
  author = {Jing You and Xuejie Yi and Meng Chen},
  title = {{Love, Life, and “Leftover Ladies” in Urban China}},
  booktitle = {Munich},
  year = {2016},
}

Loading related content...

Figure