Loop I/NPS morphology predictions in the ultralong-wavelength band

Yanping Cong, Bin Yue, Yidong Xu, Furen Deng, Jiajun Zhang, Xuelei ChenarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

This paper, recently published by Cong et al., tackles one of the most persistent mysteries in Galactic astronomy: the origin of the Loop I/North Polar Spur (NPS). By modeling how this giant radio structure would look at "ultralong" wavelengths—frequencies so low they are blocked by Earth’s ionosphere—the authors provide a roadmap for upcoming space missions to finally settle a decades-old debate.

TL;DR

Researchers modeled the appearance of the North Polar Spur at ultralong wavelengths ($\lesssim 30$ MHz) to distinguish between two competing theories: is it a nearby supernova remnant or a giant bubble from the Galactic Center? They found that at 1 MHz, the structure should remain bright if it is local but will largely disappear at low latitudes if it is distant, providing a clear "smoking gun" for future space-based radio telescopes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The North Polar Spur is a massive, arc-like structure of radio emission towering over the Galactic plane. Despite being discovered nearly 70 years ago, astronomers are split on its location:

  1. The Local Scenario: It consists of nearby supernova remnants (SNRs) just ~150 parsecs away, essentially in our "cosmic backyard."
  2. The Galactic Center (GC) Scenario: It is a gargantuan bubble (associated with the Fermi and eROSITA bubbles) blown by activity at the center of the Milky Way, roughly 8,000 parsecs away.

At standard radio frequencies (GHz range), both models can be tuned to fit the data. However, at ultralong wavelengths (decameter to hectometer scales), the Interstellar Medium (ISM) becomes opaque due to free-free absorption—where free electrons soak up radio photons. This paper explores whether this absorption can act as a "distance marker" to reveal where the NPS actually sits.

Methods

The authors developed a phenomenological model of the Milky Way’s radio emissivity and electron distribution:

  • Emissivity Modeling: They used a two-disk model (thin and thick disks) and added a spherical shell to represent the Loop I/NPS. They calibrated these models using the classic Haslam 408 MHz all-sky map.
  • Two Scenarios: They created two distinct versions of the NPS—one small and nearby (SNRs model) and one massive and distant (GC model).
  • Electron Density: To calculate absorption, they employed two standard models of Galactic electron distribution (NE2001 and YMW16) and refined the local electron density using X-ray data from the HaloSat satellite.
  • Radiative Transfer: By integrating the emission and absorption along various lines of sight, they predicted how the sky would look at 10, 3, and 1 MHz.

Datasets

  • Haslam 408 MHz Map: Used as the primary baseline for fitting the synchrotron emissivity of the Galactic disk and the NPS.
  • Planck Collaboration Data: Provided emission measure (EM) and electron temperature maps to account for free-free emission and absorption.
  • HaloSat X-ray Observations: Used to derive the specific electron density within the Loop I/NPS structure itself.
  • NE2001 & YMW16: Standard numerical models for the distribution of free electrons in the Milky Way.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The ISM as a Filter: At frequencies below 10 MHz, the diffuse electrons in the Galaxy stop being transparent. The further away a source is, the more "fog" (electrons) its signal must pass through.
  • The 1 MHz "Tie-Breaker": The most significant divergence occurs at ~1 MHz. If the NPS is local, the signal travels through very little ISM and remains a bright, clear arc. If it is at the Galactic Center, the dense electron layers near the Galactic plane will almost entirely absorb the signal at latitudes below $30^\circ$.
  • Temperature Matters: The authors found that the electrons within the NPS itself are quite hot ($\sim 10^6$ K), which actually makes the structure's internal absorption negligible. The real "dimmer switch" is the intervening ISM between us and the source.

Key Results

  • SNRs Model (Local): The Loop I/NPS remains a conspicuous, bright arc across the sky even at 1 MHz.
  • GC Model (Distant): The structure begins to fade below 3 MHz. By 1 MHz, the part of the arc near the Galactic plane ($b \lesssim 30^\circ$) becomes invisible, leaving only the "top" of the spur visible at high latitudes.
  • Model Consistency: Interestingly, the authors found that the YMW16 electron model predicts even stronger absorption than NE2001, suggesting that the GC scenario would result in an even darker low-latitude NPS than previously thought.

Limitations and Future Work

The study relies on phenomenological models—it describes the geometry and brightness of the structures without simulating the complex magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) of the shocks that create them. Additionally, the accuracy of the results depends on the precision of Galactic electron models (like NE2001), which are known to have uncertainties in specific regions of the Galactic plane.

The ultimate test will come from the "dark side" of the Moon or high Earth orbit. Upcoming missions like the DSL (Discovering the Sky at the Longest Wavelengths) and FARSIDE are designed to observe at these ultralong wavelengths, free from Earth's radio interference. This paper provides the specific predictions these missions need to finally solve the mystery of the North Polar Spur.

Summary updated

Abstract

Loop I/North Polar Spur (NPS) is the giant arc structure above the Galactic plane observed at radio wavelengths ($\lesssim 10$ GHz). There has been long-standing debate about its origin. While many people believe that it black consists of nearby supernova remnants (SNRs), some others consider it as a giant bubble close to the Galactic Center (GC), associated with the Fermi Bubble and the eROSITA X-ray bubble. At ultra-long wavelengths (wavelength $\gtrsim 10$ m or frequency $\lesssim 30$ MHz), particularly below $\sim 10$ MHz, the free-free absorption of the radio signal by diffuse electrons in the interstellar medium (ISM) becomes significant, resulting in different sky morphologies from those at higher frequencies. In this paper, we develop emissivity models for the two Loop I/NPS origin scenarios, and predict the Loop I/NPS morphology at ultra-long wavelengths in both scenarios, taking into account the free-free absorption effect.We find that in the SNRs model, the full Loop I/NPS will still be a bright arc even at $\sim 1$ MHz. In the GC model, the arc is fully visible only above $\sim 3$ MHz. While below this frequency, it is visible only at Galactic latitudes $b\gtrsim 30\degree$; the $b\lesssim 30 \degree$ part becomes invisible due to the absorption by the ISM electrons between the GC and the Sun. The upcoming space missions aiming at ultra-long wavelengths, such as the DSL and the FARSIDE, can potentially distinguish these two scenarios and provide decisive information about the origin of the Loop I/NPS.
BibTeX
@misc{cong2024loop,
  author = {Yanping Cong and Bin Yue and Yidong Xu and Furen Deng and Jiajun Zhang and Xuelei Chen},
  title = {{Loop I/NPS morphology predictions in the ultralong-wavelength band}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2501.00431},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.00431},
}

Loading related content...

Figure