Loop corrections for approximate inference

Joris M. Mooij, Bert KappenarXiv 2006 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Loop Correcting" (LC) methods to significantly improve the accuracy of approximate inference in graphical models, especially those with complex cyclic dependencies ("loops"). By iteratively refining estimates of variable interactions, LCBP achieves state-of-the-art accuracy, often outperforming existing methods on challenging real-world problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Approximate inference in graphical models is crucial for tasks like machine learning, computer vision, and statistical physics. Many real-world problems involve complex probability distributions represented by graphical models that contain "loops" – cycles of dependencies. Standard approximate inference algorithms like Belief Propagation (BP) struggle with these loops, leading to inaccurate results. While methods like the Cluster Variation Method (CVM) and Expectation Propagation (EP) attempt to handle loops, they often have limitations in terms of applicability, computational cost, or accuracy, especially for dense networks or those with complex interactions. This paper aims to provide a general, accurate, and robust method for approximate inference that effectively handles loops.

Methods

The core of the proposed method, termed "Loop Correcting" (LC), is to iteratively refine approximate "cavity distributions." A cavity distribution for a variable represents the influence of its neighbors when the variable itself and its direct interactions are removed. The key idea is to:

  1. Estimate initial cavity distributions: This is done using an existing approximate inference method (e.g., BP, Mean Field, TreeEP) on a "cavity network" where loops involving the target variable are broken.
  2. Estimate error factors: The difference between the exact and approximate cavity distributions is modeled as a product of "error factors" defined on small subsets of the variable's Markov blanket.
  3. Impose consistency constraints: By exploiting the fact that all cavity distributions should be consistent with the overall model, the authors derive equations that allow them to solve for these error factors.
  4. Update cavity distributions: The initial cavity distributions are improved by incorporating the estimated error factors.
  5. Compute final marginals: The improved cavity distributions are used to compute more accurate marginal probabilities for the original graphical model.

The paper presents a specific implementation called "Loop Corrected Belief Propagation" (LCBP), which uses BP for initial estimates and iteratively refines them. A key advantage is its generality, applicable to arbitrary factor graphs with multi-valued variables and factors.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its methods on several types of synthetic and real-world graphical models:

  • Random regular graphs: With binary variables and pairwise interactions, varying parameters like degree, interaction strength (β), and local field strength (Θ).
  • Random factor graphs: With binary variables and higher-order factors (k > 2).
  • ALARM network: A well-known Bayesian network used in medical diagnosis.
  • PROMEDAS network: Another "real-world" medical diagnostic network, significantly larger and more complex than ALARM.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Loops are the primary source of error: The paper strongly emphasizes that loops in graphical models are the main culprit behind inaccurate approximate inference.
  • Cavity distributions as a key to loop correction: By analyzing the influence of loops through cavity distributions, the method can systematically correct for their effects.
  • Error factors capture loop influence: Modeling the approximation error as product of factors on the Markov blanket provides a tractable way to estimate and correct for loop effects.
  • Consistency is key: The derived consistency constraints are crucial for solving for the error factors and achieving accurate loop correction.
  • LCBP is a robust generalization: The proposed LCBP method is shown to be more general and robust than previous approaches, particularly in handling complex interactions and arbitrary factor graphs.
  • Error reduction is significant: The loop-corrected error is often observed to be approximately the square of the original error, indicating a substantial improvement.

Key Results

  • State-of-the-art accuracy: LCBP consistently achieved the most accurate results across various synthetic and real-world benchmarks, significantly outperforming standard BP, TreeEP, and CVM methods.
  • Substantial error reduction: For instance, on PROMEDAS networks, LCBP reduced BP errors by over four orders of magnitude in many cases. The loop-corrected error was often the square of the uncorrected error.
  • Robustness to strong interactions: Unlike cumulant-based methods (LCBP-Cum), LCBP remained accurate even with strong interactions, where other methods struggled or failed to converge.
  • Generality: LCBP is applicable to arbitrary factor graphs, including those with multi-valued variables and factors involving more than two variables, a significant advantage over prior methods.
  • Computational cost: While LCBP is more computationally expensive than BP, it offers a favorable trade-off between accuracy and computation time compared to other loop-correcting methods like CVM-Loop, especially for complex graphs. For large N, LCBP's computation time scales quadratically, making it feasible where exact inference is intractable.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational complexity: The current implementation of LCBP can be computationally expensive, scaling exponentially with the size of Markov blankets. This limits its direct applicability to networks with very large Markov blankets.
  • Cumulant-based methods' limitations: The cumulant-based approach (LCBP-Cum) is less robust to strong interactions and is restricted to binary variables and pairwise factors.
  • Future research directions:
    • Developing more efficient implementations of LCBP that combine generality with speed, possibly by exploring alternative parameterizations (cumulants vs. interactions) or approximations.
  • Extending the framework to provide loop-corrected approximations of the normalization constant (Z).
  • Finding an approximate "free energy" function whose stationary points coincide with LCBP's fixed points, potentially framing LCBP as a minimization procedure.
  • Further comparing LCBP with other emerging loop-correction techniques.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a method for improving approximate inference methods that corrects for the influence of loops in the graphical model. The method is applicable to arbitrary factor graphs, provided that the size of the Markov blankets is not too large. It is an alternative implementation of an idea introduced recently by Montanari and Rizzo (2005). In its simplest form, which amounts to the assumption that no loops are present, the method reduces to the minimal Cluster Variation Method approximation (which uses maximal factors as outer clusters). On the other hand, using estimates of the effect of loops (obtained by some approximate inference algorithm) and applying the Loop Correcting (LC) method usually gives significantly better results than applying the approximate inference algorithm directly without loop corrections. Indeed, we often observe that the loop corrected error is approximately the square of the error of the approximate inference method used to estimate the effect of loops. We compare different variants of the Loop Correcting method with other approximate inference methods on a variety of graphical models, including "real world" networks, and conclude that the LC approach generally obtains the most accurate results.
BibTeX
@misc{mooij2006loop,
  author = {Joris M. Mooij and Bert Kappen},
  title = {{Loop corrections for approximate inference}},
  year = {2006},
  eprint = {cs/0612030},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/cs/0612030},
}
Figure