Longitudinal impact of psychosocial status on children’s mental health in the context of COVID-19 pandemic restrictions

Flore Moulin, Marion Bailhache, Maëva Monnier, Xavier Thierry, Stéphanie Vandentorren, Sylvana M. Côté, Bruno Falissard, Thierry Siméon, Bertrand Geay, Laeticia Marchand, Marie‐Noëlle Dufourg, Pierre‐Yves Ancel, Marie‐Aline Charles, Alexandra Rouquette, Maria Melchior, Cédric Galera, on behalf of the Sapris study groupEuropean 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the longitudinal impact of pre-pandemic socioeconomic status (SES) and pandemic-related financial instability on children's mental health. Utilizing data from the French ELFE cohort (n=4,575), researchers assessed Attention-deficit/Hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and emotional symptoms during the 2020 COVID-19 school closures. Findings indicate that low pre-pandemic SES and proximal income loss independently increased ADHD risks. Crucially, a "double hit" effect was observed for emotional symptoms: children with a history of low SES who also experienced family income decline during the pandemic faced the highest risk (aOR 1.54). These results highlight the specific vulnerability of socioeconomically disadvantaged families to pandemic-related stressors and the need for targeted financial and mental health interventions.

Introduction

While the global surge in pediatric mental health issues following the COVID-19 pandemic is well-documented, early research often provided only cross-sectional snapshots. There has been a critical lack of understanding regarding how a child's social and economic trajectory prior to the pandemic influenced their resilience during lockdowns. This study addresses this gap by examining the longitudinal impact of family SES on two specific mental health domains: ADHD symptoms and emotional symptoms, specifically investigating whether pre-existing social disadvantages exacerbated the psychological toll of pandemic-related financial instability.

Methods

The researchers utilized data from the ELFE (Etude Longitudinale Française depuis l'Enfance) cohort, a multidisciplinary study following over 18,000 children born in France in 2011. This analysis focused on a sample of 4,575 children with complete longitudinal data from age 5 (pre-pandemic) to age 8–9 (during the 2020 school closures, tracked via the SAPRIS survey).

  • Assessment: Mental health was measured using the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ).
  • Statistical Analysis: Binary logistic regression estimated adjusted Odds Ratios (aOR), controlling for covariates such as child sex, prior mental health status, sleeping difficulties, and family structure. Missing data were handled using Classification and Regression Tree (CART) multiple imputation.

Key Results

ADHD and Hyperactivity Symptoms

The study found that drivers for ADHD symptoms were independently associated with both prior social status and immediate financial shocks. Children from low SES families faced a 26% higher risk (aOR 1.26) of elevated ADHD symptoms during school closures, while a decline in family income during the crisis increased this risk by 38% (aOR 1.38).

Table 3: Adjusted Odds Ratios for hyperactivity/inattention symptoms during school closure, showing independent risks from prior SES and income decline.

Emotional Symptoms and the "Double Hit" Effect

Emotional symptoms were particularly sensitive to the immediate financial shock of the pandemic, with income decline associated with a 23% higher risk (aOR 1.23) overall. However, the most striking finding was the interaction between pre-existing poverty and new financial loss. For children in the low prior SES group who also experienced a decline in income, the risk of abnormal emotional symptoms jumped significantly to an aOR of 1.54. In contrast, children from higher SES families who lost income did not show the same significant increase in emotional risk, suggesting that prior socioeconomic stability acts as a buffer.

Table 4: Interaction effect between prior socioeconomic status and income decline on emotional symptoms, highlighting the "double hit" vulnerability.

Discussion

The findings confirm a strong continuity of symptoms; children displaying difficulties at age 5 were significantly more likely to struggle at age 9. This suggests the pandemic acted as a stressor on top of existing developmental trajectories rather than creating entirely new clusters of issues.

Limitations include reliance on parental self-reports (informant bias) and the use of the SDQ as a screening tool rather than a clinical diagnosis. Future work should investigate whether these mental health gaps narrow as children return to normal social environments. The researchers emphasize that targeted financial assistance may be a primary and necessary mental health intervention for socioeconomically deprived families during periods of societal crisis.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{moulin2022longitudinal,
  author = {Flore Moulin and Marion Bailhache and Maëva Monnier and Xavier Thierry and Stéphanie Vandentorren and Sylvana M. Côté and Bruno Falissard and Thierry Siméon and Bertrand Geay and Laeticia Marchand and Marie‐Noëlle Dufourg and Pierre‐Yves Ancel and Marie‐Aline Charles and Alexandra Rouquette and Maria Melchior and Cédric Galera and on behalf of the SAPRIS study group},
  title = {{Longitudinal impact of psychosocial status on children’s mental health in the context of COVID-19 pandemic restrictions}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s00787-022-02010-w},
}
Figure