Long-term stress and trait anxiety alter brain network balance in dynamic decisions during working memory

Liangying Liu, Jianhui Wu, Haiyang Geng, Chao Liu, Yuejia Luo, Jing Luo, Shaozheng QinbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals how long-term stress and trait anxiety interact to influence decision-making during working memory. The findings suggest that while stress alone can speed up decisions, high trait anxiety under stress can lead to slower, more effortful decision-making by altering brain network communication. This work offers a neurocognitive model for understanding how these factors contribute to adaptive and maladaptive responses to stress.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

We all experience stress, and some of us are naturally more anxious than others. While we know that both long-term stress and trait anxiety can significantly impact our brain and how we think, especially in complex tasks like working memory, the interaction between these two factors has remained unclear. Specifically, how do these individual differences in anxiety influence the brain's response to prolonged stress, and how does this combined effect shape our ability to make dynamic decisions? This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying the interplay of long-term stress and trait anxiety on decision-making during working memory.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining neuroimaging (fMRI), computational modeling, and behavioral assessments.

  • fMRI: Participants performed a numerical N-back task while their brain activity was scanned. This task is a standard measure of working memory.
  • Drift Diffusion Model (DDM): This computational model was used to analyze trial-by-trial reaction times (RTs) and decision-making processes. The DDM decomposes decisions into key parameters like "drift rate" (how quickly evidence is accumulated) and "decision threshold" (how much evidence is needed to make a decision).
  • Network Analysis: The study examined functional connectivity and decoupling between three key brain networks: the Fronto-Parietal Network (FPN, involved in executive control), the Default Mode Network (DMN, associated with internal thought), and the Salience Network (SN, involved in detecting and orienting to important stimuli).
  • Psychological Assessments: Participants completed questionnaires to measure trait anxiety and psychological distress.

Datasets

The study utilized data from two groups of male participants:

  • Long-term stress group: 38 participants preparing for a competitive exam (CNPEE) for at least 6 months.
  • Control group: 34 participants not anticipating major stressors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stress vs. Anxiety Interaction: The study highlights that the effects of stress on decision-making are not uniform. Trait anxiety acts as a crucial modulator, changing how individuals respond to prolonged stress.
  • Adaptive vs. Maladaptive Pathways: The findings suggest that stress can lead to faster, more efficient decision-making in some individuals (potentially adaptive), but in those with high trait anxiety, it can lead to slower, more effortful processing (potentially maladaptive).
  • Brain Network Reorganization: The research pinpoints specific changes in brain network communication (FPN-DMN decoupling, SN hyper-activation) as the neurocognitive underpinnings of these behavioral differences.
  • FPN as a Mediator: The fronto-parietal network appears to play a mediating role, with its activity under stress influencing the relationship between trait anxiety and decision speed, but only in the stressed group.

Key Results

  • Behavioral:
    • Participants under long-term stress showed higher psychological distress.
  • Stress group exhibited faster reaction times (RTs) and a faster drift rate (evidence accumulation) in the 2-back task, but a lower decision threshold in the 0-back task.
  • High trait anxiety predicted greater psychological distress in both groups.
  • Critically, high trait anxiety under long-term stress led to slower evidence accumulation (drift rate).
  • Neuroimaging:
    • Long-term stress was associated with hyper-activation in the anterior insula and dACC (SN regions).
  • Less deactivation was observed in DMN regions (PCC, mPFC) in the stress group.
  • Stronger decoupling between the FPN and DMN was observed in the stress group.
  • High trait anxiety in the stress group was linked to higher WM-related activity in FPN regions (IPS, MFG), which in turn was associated with slower drift rate.
  • Stronger FPN-DMN decoupling was observed in individuals with high trait anxiety under long-term stress.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Gender Specificity: The study included only male participants to control for menstrual cycle confounds, limiting the generalizability of findings to females. Future work should investigate these effects in mixed-gender or female-only samples.
  • Intelligence and Other Stressors: Individual intelligence might influence WM performance, and the study acknowledges that sleep disruption and other stressors associated with exam preparation could complicate findings. Future studies could control for these factors or explore their specific contributions.
  • Task Design: The block design of the WM task limits trial-by-trial parametric modulation analyses. The authors suggest future studies with novel designs to address this.
  • Generalizability of Stressor: The study used exam stress as a naturalistic long-term stressor. Exploring other types of long-term stressors would be valuable.
  • Personalized Interventions: The findings suggest that understanding the interplay of stress and trait anxiety could inform personalized assessments and interventions for stress-related adaptation or maladaptation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Long-term stress has a profound impact on the human brain and cognition, and trait anxiety influences stress-induced adaptive and maladaptive effects. However, the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying long-term stress and trait anxiety interactions remain elusive. Here we investigated how long-term stress and trait anxiety interact to affect dynamic decisions during working-memory (WM) by altering functional brain network balance. In comparison to controls, male participants under long-term stress experienced higher psychological distress and exhibited faster evidence accumulation but had a lower decision-threshold during WM. This corresponded with hyper-activation in the anterior insula, less WM-related deactivation in the default-mode network, and stronger default-mode network decoupling with the frontoparietal network. Critically, high trait anxiety under long-term stress led to slower evidence accumulation through higher WM-related frontoparietal activity, and increased decoupling between the default-mode and frontoparietal networks. Our findings provide neurocognitive evidence for long-term stress and trait anxiety interactions on executive functions with (mal)adaptive changes.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2021long,
  author = {Liangying Liu and Jianhui Wu and Haiyang Geng and Chao Liu and Yuejia Luo and Jing Luo and Shaozheng Qin},
  title = {{Long-term stress and trait anxiety alter brain network balance in dynamic decisions during working memory}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.05.07.442883},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure