Long-Term Petroleum Hydrocarbons Pollution after a Coastal Oil Spill

Weijun Guo, Xinggang Wang, Sihong Liu, Xiangpeng Kong, Pengcheng Wang, Tiao-Jian XuJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the long-term fate of petroleum hydrocarbons (PHs) in seawater and sediment following the 2010 Dalian New Port oil spill. It reveals that while seawater recovers relatively quickly, sediments act as persistent reservoirs, leading to renewed water column contamination during storm events. This highlights the enduring impact of oil spills and the critical role of sediment dynamics in long-term coastal pollution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal oil spills, like the Dalian New Port oil spill (DLNPOS) in 2010, pose significant environmental challenges. While immediate cleanup efforts focus on visible oil slicks, the long-term persistence and fate of petroleum hydrocarbons (PHs) in different environmental compartments (seawater and sediment) remain a critical concern. Understanding how PHs behave over extended periods, particularly their interaction with sediments and their re-release into the water column, is crucial for assessing the true extent of damage and for developing effective long-term environmental management strategies. This paper addresses the gap in knowledge regarding the multi-year evolution of PH pollution after a major coastal oil spill, specifically focusing on the Dalian Bay region.

Methods

The researchers conducted a long-term monitoring study of petroleum hydrocarbon (PH) concentrations in both seawater and sediment. They employed UV spectrophotometry for the quantitative analysis of total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH), dissolved petroleum hydrocarbons (DPH), and particulate petroleum hydrocarbons (PPH). Seawater samples were analyzed directly, while sediment samples were air-dried and extracted with hexane. The study involved extensive field sampling over several years, from 2010 to 2021, with a particular focus on the period ten years after the spill. They also incorporated hydrodynamic modeling to understand the transport processes of PHs.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a series of field surveys conducted between 2003 and 2021 in the Dalian Bay area. This included pre-spill baseline data (2003, 2006, 2008) and post-spill data collected at various intervals, including two months after the spill (September 2010), and then annually in September (with an exception in December 2020 due to COVID-19). The sampling covered 32 sites, divided into nearshore and offshore areas.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sediments as Long-Term Reservoirs: The most striking insight is that coastal sediments act as persistent sinks for petroleum hydrocarbons. While seawater clears relatively quickly, the oil trapped in sediments can remain for years, posing a continuous threat.
  • Storms as Re-Suspension Events: Sediment-bound PHs are not static. Storm events, with their increased wave action and turbulence, can resuspend these contaminated sediments, leading to a significant, albeit temporary, increase in PH concentrations in the water column. This explains the observed spikes in seawater PH levels during or after stormy periods.
  • Shift in Pollution Hotspots: Over time, the focus of high PH concentrations has shifted from the immediate spill site to the inner corners of bays like Dalian Bay. This is attributed to a combination of hydrodynamic transport and ongoing industrial emissions from coastal outfalls.
  • Persistence of Oil-Sediment Aggregates: The formation of oil-mineral aggregates (OMA) plays a crucial role in the transport and sedimentation of oil. These aggregates, once settled, are more resistant to degradation, contributing to the long-term persistence of oil in the seabed.
  • Complex PH Speciation: The study highlights the importance of distinguishing between dissolved (DPH) and particulate (PPH) forms of PHs. During storm events, the increase in TPH is primarily driven by the rise in PPH due to sediment resuspension, rather than an increase in dissolved components.

Key Results

  • Seawater Recovery: Seawater PH concentrations returned to near pre-spill levels within approximately two years after the DLNPOS.
  • Sediment Persistence: PH contamination in sediments persisted for several years, with significant levels observed even a decade after the spill.
  • Storm-Induced PH Increase: A significant increase in seawater PH levels was observed following storm events, with particulate PHs (PPH) showing a marked rise due to sediment resuspension. For example, PPH increased sharply from 0.008 mg/L in December 2020 to 0.055 mg/L in September 2021, coinciding with high suspended sediment concentrations.
  • Spatial Shift: Hotspots of high PH concentrations in the water column shifted from the original spill site to the inner bay areas over the study period.
  • Ongoing Industrial Impact: The research suggests that continuous industrial emissions from coastal outfalls are now a significant contributor to regional oil contamination, potentially leading to indefinite persistence of PH pollution.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while seawater quality may improve after cleanup, the underlying pollution in sediments persists. They also note that the study focused on the overall fate of PHs in seawater and sediment. Future work should investigate other aspects, such as the persistence of specific organic pollutants and the bioaccumulation and trophic transfer of oil residues around the spill site. The study also implies that the long-term environmental impact of oil spills is complex and requires ongoing monitoring and comprehensive remediation strategies that consider sediment dynamics and continuous anthropogenic inputs.

Summary updated

Abstract

The long-term status of petroleum hydrocarbons in both seawater and sediment contaminated by the Dalian New Port oil spill has been investigated since 2010. Seawater recovery is relatively swift and is complete within two years, while oil contamination persists in the coastal sediments for several years. Because of the slow degradation and low mobility in sediments, they serve as long-term reservoirs for residual oils. The erosion of sediments into the water column leads to an abrupt increase in hydrocarbons during storms. The cumulative results of hydrodynamic transport and ongoing industrial emissions lead to a spatial shift of hot spots with high petroleum hydrocarbon concentrations from the spill site to the inner corner of the bay. In addition to continuous petroleum hydrocarbon emissions from contiguous coastal outfalls, the regional oil contamination will persist indefinitely. The research provides comprehensive information for years to come to evaluate the long-term damage and multiphase medium impacts of a large oil spill.
BibTeX
@article{guo2022long,
  author = {Weijun Guo and Xinggang Wang and Sihong Liu and Xiangpeng Kong and Pengcheng Wang and Tiao-Jian Xu},
  title = {{Long-Term Petroleum Hydrocarbons Pollution after a Coastal Oil Spill}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse10101380},
}
Figure