Abstract
Study of the neural deficits caused by mismatched binocular vision in early childhood has predominantly focused on circuits in the primary visual cortex (V1). Recent evidence has revealed that neurons in mouse dorsolateral geniculate nucleus (dLGN) can undergo rapid ocular dominance plasticity following monocular deprivation (MD). It remains unclear, however, whether the long-lasting deficits attributed to MD during the critical period originate in the thalamus. Using in vivo two-photon Ca<sup>2+</sup> imaging of dLGN afferents in superficial layers of V1 in female and male mice, we demonstrate that 14 d MD during the critical period leads to a chronic loss of binocular dLGN inputs while sparing response strength and spatial acuity. Importantly, MD leads to profoundly mismatched visual tuning properties in remaining binocular dLGN afferents. Furthermore, MD impairs binocular modulation, reducing facilitation of responses of both binocular and monocular dLGN inputs during binocular viewing. As predicted by our findings in thalamic inputs, Ca<sup>2+</sup> imaging from V1 neurons revealed spared spatial acuity but impaired binocularity in L4 neurons. V1 L2/3 neurons in contrast displayed deficits in both binocularity and spatial acuity. Our data demonstrate that critical-period MD produces long-lasting disruptions in binocular integration beginning in early binocular circuits in dLGN, whereas spatial acuity deficits first arise from circuits further downstream in V1. Our findings indicate that the development of normal binocular vision and spatial acuity depend upon experience-dependent refinement of distinct stages in the mammalian visual system.
Introduction
For decades, the prevailing "cortical-centric" view of amblyopia (lazy eye) suggested that the primary visual cortex (V1) is the first site where signals from the two eyes combine and, consequently, the primary site of failure when vision is imbalanced during childhood. The thalamus (specifically the dorsolateral geniculate nucleus, or dLGN) was largely viewed as a passive relay station where eye-specific signals remained segregated. However, recent evidence has shown that the dLGN actually contains binocular neurons. This research investigates whether the long-term, chronic deficits caused by monocular deprivation (MD) actually originate in these early thalamic circuits rather than the cortex.
Methods
The researchers employed in vivo two-photon calcium ($Ca^{2+}$) imaging to visualize the activity of individual thalamocortical axons (boutons) in the superficial layers of V1 in awake mice. By imaging the axons, they could directly monitor the information the thalamus was sending to the cortex.
Mice underwent 14 days of eyelid closure during the juvenile "critical period" of development. They were then allowed to reach adulthood before imaging. Specific Cre-driver lines were used to selectively label and image either thalamic inputs or specific layers of the visual cortex (L4 and L2/3). Visual stimulation consisted of drifting gratings of varying orientations and spatial frequencies to map the "tuning" of individual neurons and boutons.
Results
Thalamic Vulnerability and Binocular Loss
The binocular circuits in the dLGN were found to be highly sensitive to early visual experience. MD caused a staggering 69% reduction in the number of binocular thalamic inputs. While the number of monocular inputs remained relatively stable, the binocular fraction of dLGN boutons dropped significantly compared to control groups.
Decoupling of Acuity and Binocularity
A striking finding of the study is that MD affects visual properties at different stages. Binocularity (the ability to use both eyes) breaks early in the thalamus. However, spatial acuity (the ability to see fine detail) remains perfectly intact in the thalamus and V1 Layer 4, only failing once the signal reaches V1 Layer 2/3.
Tuning Mismatch and Loss of Facilitation
The few binocular thalamic inputs that survived MD were functionally impaired. In healthy mice, a binocular neuron usually prefers the same orientation and frequency in both eyes. After MD, these remaining inputs showed a profound mismatch in their tuning properties between the two eyes. Additionally, MD abolished the normal "boost" in neural response (facilitation) typically provided by binocular viewing.
Discussion
These findings demonstrate that critical-period MD produces long-lasting disruptions in binocular integration beginning in early binocular circuits in the dLGN, whereas spatial acuity deficits arise further downstream in V1. This challenges the traditional view that the neural deficits underlying amblyopia begin solely in the primary visual cortex. The study suggests that the development of normal binocular vision and spatial acuity depend upon experience-dependent refinement of distinct stages in the mammalian visual system. These results may have critical implications for understanding and treating developmental visual disorders.
Summary updated