Long-lived atmospheric trace gases measurements in flask samples from three stations in India

Xin Lin, Nuggehalli K. Indira, Michel Ramonet, Marc Delmotte, Philippe Ciais, B. C. Bhatt, M. V. Reddy, Dorje Angchuk, S. Balakrishnan, Sonam Jorphail, Tsewang Dorjai, T. T. Mahey, Samarjit Patnaik, Mehmuna Begum, C. A. M. Brenninkmeijer, S. Durairaj, R. Kirubagaran, Martina Schmidt, P. S. Swathi, Nambali Valsalan Vinithkumar, Camille Yver Kwok, V. K. GaurAtmospheric 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new network of three atmospheric monitoring stations in India (Hanle, Pondicherry, and Port Blair) to address the critical need for better greenhouse gas (GHG) flux estimations in the region. By analyzing flask samples from 2007-2011, the study provides valuable insights into the seasonal cycles, regional gradients, and emission sources of key GHGs like CO2 and CH4, highlighting the impact of India's rapid development and monsoon patterns.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Indian subcontinent is experiencing rapid economic growth and urbanization, leading to a significant increase in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. However, accurately quantifying these emissions and understanding their regional variations is challenging due to a lack of comprehensive atmospheric observation networks. Existing methods, like atmospheric inversions, are hampered by sparse data, leading to uncertainties in GHG budgets. This study aims to fill this data gap by establishing and analyzing data from three new monitoring stations across diverse geographical locations in India.

Methods

The core of this study involves collecting whole air samples in pre-conditioned 1-liter glass flasks from three stations: Hanle (HLE) at high altitude in the Himalayas, Pondicherry (PON) on the southeastern coast, and Port Blair (PBL) on an oceanic island in the Bay of Bengal. These samples were then transported to LSCE, France, for analysis using two coupled gas chromatograph (GC) systems. These systems employed flame ionization detectors (FID) and electron capture detectors (ECD) to measure CO2, CH4, N2O, and SF6, and a reduced gas detector (RGD) for CO and H2. Standard laboratory procedures for calibration, quality control, and uncertainty estimation were followed. Data analysis involved fitting smoothed curves to time series to determine annual means, seasonal cycles, and trends. Synoptic variations were investigated by analyzing covariances between different trace gases.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of flask air samples collected from the three newly established Indian stations:

  • Hanle (HLE): 32.780° N, 78.960° E, 4517 m a.s.l. (2007-2011)
  • Pondicherry (PON): 12.010° N, 79.860° E, 20 m a.s.l. (2007-2011)
  • Port Blair (PBL): 11.650° N, 92.760° E, 20 m a.s.l. (2009-2011)

The data were compared with existing datasets from NOAA/ESRL stations:

  • Assy Plateau, Kazakhstan (KZM): 43.25° N, 77.88° E, 2519 m a.s.l.
  • Mt. Waliguan, China (WLG): 36.29° N, 100.90° E, 3810 m a.s.l.

Additionally, back trajectories were generated using the HYSPLIT model driven by GDAS data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • India's Growing GHG Footprint: The study confirms that India is a significant and growing emitter of GHGs, with emissions increasing rapidly due to population and economic growth.
  • Monsoon's Dominance: The Indian monsoon plays a crucial role in shaping the seasonal cycles of GHGs, influencing atmospheric transport, convection, and biogenic activity.
  • Regional Emission Hotspots: Distinct regional gradients in GHG concentrations point to significant emission sources in southern and northeastern India, likely linked to agricultural activities, livestock, and urban/industrial sources.
  • SF6 as a Tracer: SF6, a purely anthropogenic gas, shows weak emissions in India, contrasting with higher emissions in Europe and the US, and its seasonal cycle is influenced by atmospheric circulation rather than direct emissions.
  • CO and CH4 Linkages: The covariances between CO and CH4 (and CO2) provide valuable clues about emission sources, distinguishing between biogenic, fossil fuel, and biomass burning contributions.

Key Results

  • CO2: Annual mean CO2 concentrations increased at HLE from 382.3±0.3 ppm in 2007 to 391.4±0.3 ppm in 2011. PON showed higher concentrations than HLE, reflecting greater influence from southern Indian emissions. PBL had slightly lower CO2 than HLE.
  • CH4: Annual mean CH4 at HLE increased from 1814.8±2.9 ppb in 2007 to 1849.5±5.2 ppb in 2011. PON and PBL exhibited higher CH4 levels than HLE, indicating significant regional emissions, particularly during winter due to the NE monsoon.
  • N2O: Annual mean N2O concentrations rose at HLE from 322.2±0.1 ppb in 2007 to 325.2±0.1 ppb in 2011. PON and PBL showed notably higher N2O levels and variability compared to HLE, suggesting substantial N2O sources in South Asia.
  • SF6: SF6 mole fractions at HLE increased from 6.26±0.03 ppt in 2007 to 7.38±0.01 ppt in 2011. A slight negative gradient was observed between PON and HLE, indicating weak SF6 emissions in India.
  • CO: HLE showed a slight decrease in CO mole fractions from 104.7±1.4 ppb in 2007 to 99.4±2.2 ppb in 2011. PON and PBL had significantly higher CO concentrations than HLE, influenced by regional biofuel and agricultural burning.
  • H2: No significant trend was observed for H2 at any station. PON and PBL showed higher H2 mole fractions than HLE, suggesting substantial regional H2 sources.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Gaps and Short Time Series: The study acknowledges that the observation records are relatively short, particularly for PBL, which can lead to higher uncertainties in seasonal cycle estimates and statistical correlations.
  • Network Expansion: The authors emphasize the need for further extension of the ground station network to other parts of India to better constrain regional and continental GHG budgets.
  • Further Analysis: Future work could involve analyzing carbon isotopic measurements and conducting chemical transport model experiments to disentangle the contributions of meteorology and biogenic emissions to observed trace gas variations. Investigating specific elevated CH4 and CO events at PBL with more detailed source attribution is also suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid growth in population and economic development, emissions of greenhouse gases (GHGs) from the Indian subcontinent have sharply increased during recent decades. However, evaluation of regional fluxes of GHGs and characterization of their spatial and temporal variations by atmospheric inversions remain uncertain due to a sparse regional atmospheric observation network. As a result of an Indo-French collaboration, three new atmospheric stations were established in India at Hanle (HLE), Pondicherry (PON) and Port Blair (PBL), with the objective of monitoring the atmospheric concentrations of GHGs and other trace gases. Here we present the results of the measurements of CO2, CH4, N2O, SF6, CO, and H2 from regular flask sampling at these three stations over the period 2007–2011. For each species, annual means, seasonal cycles and gradients between stations were calculated and related to variations in natural GHG fluxes, anthropogenic emissions, and monsoon circulations. Covariances between species at the synoptic scale were analyzed to investigate the likely source(s) of emissions. The flask measurements of various trace gases at the three stations have the potential to constrain the inversions of fluxes over southern and northeastern India. However, this network of ground stations needs further extension to other parts of India to better constrain the GHG budgets at regional and continental scales.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lin2015long,
  author = {Xin Lin and Nuggehalli K. Indira and Michel Ramonet and Marc Delmotte and Philippe Ciais and B. C. Bhatt and M. V. Reddy and Dorje Angchuk and S. Balakrishnan and Sonam Jorphail and Tsewang Dorjai and T. T. Mahey and Samarjit Patnaik and Mehmuna Begum and C. A. M. Brenninkmeijer and S. Durairaj and R. Kirubagaran and Martina Schmidt and P. S. Swathi and Nambali Valsalan Vinithkumar and Camille Yver Kwok and V. K. Gaur},
  title = {{Long-lived atmospheric trace gases measurements in flask samples from three stations in India}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-15-9819-2015},
}
Figure