Logistics Service Selection Strategy of Green Manufacturers in Green Low-Carbon Supply Chain

Xigang Yuan, Wenwen Sheng, Min Wang, Dalin ZhangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how green manufacturers can optimize their logistics service and sales channel strategies within a green low-carbon supply chain. It reveals that the choice between third-party logistics (3PL) providers and e-commerce platform logistics depends on market demand and service levels, with a preference for agency channels regardless of the logistics provider.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's e-commerce landscape, manufacturers face complex decisions regarding how to sell their products and how to deliver them. This is particularly true in the context of "green low-carbon supply chains," where environmental considerations are paramount. While existing research has explored sales channel selection and logistics service strategies separately, there's a need to understand how these decisions interact within a green supply chain framework. Specifically, manufacturers must decide between using third-party logistics (3PL) providers or leveraging the logistics services offered by e-commerce platforms. They also need to choose between different sales models, such as direct selling combined with reselling or agency channels. This paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing these intertwined strategic choices for manufacturers operating in a green low-carbon supply chain.

Methods

The study employs a theoretical modeling approach using backward induction. This method is standard for solving sequential decision-making problems in game theory. The researchers construct four theoretical models representing different combinations of sales channels (direct selling + reselling, direct selling + agency) and logistics service providers (3PL or e-commerce platform). They then analyze the equilibrium outcomes for each model, focusing on how manufacturers and e-commerce platforms make their optimal decisions regarding pricing, sales, and logistics service provision to maximize their profits.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and mathematical analysis rather than empirical data or simulations on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Logistics Choice is Context-Dependent: The optimal choice between a 3PL provider and an e-commerce platform's logistics service is not static. It hinges on the interplay of basic market demand and the relative service levels of the providers.
  • E-commerce Platform Logistics Can Be a Double-Edged Sword: While e-commerce platform logistics can be beneficial for manufacturers, especially when 3PL services are weak, it can also lead to higher retail prices and potentially lower profits for the manufacturer if the platform leverages its position.
  • Agency Channels are Generally Preferred: Regardless of whether a manufacturer opts for 3PL or e-commerce platform logistics, the study suggests that a dual-channel model combining direct selling with an agency channel is generally more profitable for the manufacturer.
  • Coopetition Dynamics: The paper touches upon the idea of "coopetition" (cooperation and competition) between manufacturers and e-commerce platforms, where platforms might share logistics services to gain an advantage, but this sharing is contingent on profitability for both parties.

Key Results

The paper presents several theorems outlining specific conditions under which manufacturers should choose particular logistics and sales strategies:

  • Direct Selling + Reselling Channel:
    • If market demand and 3PL service levels are low, manufacturers favor e-commerce platform logistics.
  • If market demand and 3PL service levels are high, manufacturers prefer 3PL services.
  • Direct Selling + Agency Channel:
    • If the 3PL service level is between a critical value and the e-commerce platform's service level, manufacturers choose e-commerce platform logistics.
  • Otherwise, they opt for 3PL services.
  • Sales Channel Preference: Regardless of the logistics service provider chosen, manufacturers are advised to opt for the direct selling + agency channel model.
  • Profitability: Numerical analysis suggests that in the direct selling + agency channel model, the e-commerce platform's logistics service can lead to a "win-win" situation for both manufacturer and platform under certain conditions (medium service levels). However, in the direct selling + reselling channel model, the impacts are often opposite – beneficial for one party, detrimental to the other.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Consumer Logistics Costs: The current model does not account for consumers paying additional logistics costs. Future work could incorporate this by having consumers bear some of these costs.
  • 3PL as an Independent Player: The third-party logistics provider is not modeled as an independent decision-maker in the game. Future research could include the 3PL as an active participant.
  • Exogenous Variables: Logistics service levels and sales commission rates are treated as fixed. Future studies could explore these as endogenous decision variables.
  • Green Input Cost Coefficient: While mentioned in the abstract, the specific impact of the "green input cost coefficient" on optimal decisions and profits is not deeply explored in the provided text and could be a focus for future work.
  • Numerical Analysis Scope: The numerical analysis is limited and primarily used to illustrate findings rather than provide exhaustive scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

In order to analyze the logistics service mode and sales mode selection strategy, a green low-carbon supply chain consisting of a single manufacturer and a single e-commerce platform is considered. First, in the green low-carbon supply chain which consists of a direct selling channel and reselling channel, the selection strategy of the manufacturer's logistics service mode is analyzed. Second, in the green low-carbon supply chain which consists of a direct selling channel and an agency channel, the selection strategy of the manufacturer's logistics service mode is analyzed. Last, the manufacturer's sales mode is analyzed. We use the backward induction method to solve the theoretical model. This study contributes to the literature by considering the optimal decision of a green low-carbon supply chain. This study brings together the literature from streams on the selling channel selection strategy in green supply chains and the logistics service strategy in green supply chains. The impacts of the logistics service cost, the selling cost, and the green input cost coefficient on the optimal decision and the firms' profit are discussed. The result shows that in the direct selling channel and reselling channel, when the basic market demand and the logistics service level of the third-party logistics service provider are low, manufacturers will choose the e-commerce platform logistics service; in the opposite case, manufacturers will choose the third-party logistics service. In the direct selling channel and agency channels, when the logistics service level of the third-party logistics service provider is greater than or equal to a certain critical value and less than or equal to the logistics service level of the e-commerce platform, manufacturers will choose the e-commerce platform logistics service; in the opposite case, manufacturers will choose the third-party logistics service. No matter whether the manufacturer chooses the logistics service provided by the third-party logistics service provider or the logistics service provided by the e-commerce platform, the manufacturer should choose the direct selling channel and the agency channel.
BibTeX
@article{yuan2023logistics,
  author = {Xigang Yuan and Wenwen Sheng and Min Wang and Dalin Zhang},
  title = {{Logistics Service Selection Strategy of Green Manufacturers in Green Low-Carbon Supply Chain}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20043356},
}
Figure