Local Retail Food Environment and Consumption of Fruit and Vegetable among Adults in Hong Kong

Ting Zhang, Bo HuangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the local food environment in Hong Kong influences fruit and vegetable (FV) consumption among adults. It finds that areas with a higher ratio of unhealthy food outlets (fast food, convenience stores) to healthy ones (grocery stores) are associated with significantly lower FV intake, suggesting "food swamps" are a bigger issue than "food deserts" in this urban setting.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Globally, insufficient fruit and vegetable consumption is a major contributor to non-communicable diseases. While the impact of the food environment on dietary habits is recognized, most research has focused on Western countries. There's a need to understand these associations in non-Western, urban contexts, where food environments and cultural eating patterns might differ. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining how the density and type of retail food outlets in Hong Kong, a densely populated Asian metropolis, relate to adult consumption of fruits and vegetables.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and logistic regression. They characterized the local food environment by measuring the density of three types of retail food outlets: grocery stores, convenience stores, and fast-food restaurants, within a 1000-meter Euclidean buffer around participants' homes. A key metric developed was the Retail Food Environment Index (RFEI), calculated as the ratio of unhealthy food outlets (fast food and convenience stores) to healthy ones (grocery stores). Logistic regression models were then used to assess the association between these food environment measures (stratified into quartiles) and infrequent FV consumption (less than 7 days a week), controlling for various socio-demographic covariates.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary datasets:

  1. Individual Cross-Sectional Survey Data: Collected from 1977 adults (aged 18+) as part of the Strategic Public Research (SPPR) project. This dataset included information on FV consumption, socio-demographics, and precise home location.
  2. Retail Food Outlet Data: Obtained from the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department (FEHD) of Hong Kong, containing addresses and categories for over 15,000 food outlets. This data was geocoded and categorized into the three study types (grocery stores, convenience stores, fast-food restaurants).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Food Swamps" Over "Food Deserts": The findings strongly suggest that in Hong Kong's urban landscape, the abundance of unhealthy food options ("food swamps") is a more significant barrier to healthy eating than a lack of access to healthy options ("food deserts").
  • RFEI as a Predictive Indicator: The Retail Food Environment Index (RFEI), which captures the relative density of unhealthy to healthy food outlets, proved to be a more robust predictor of infrequent FV consumption than the absolute density of any single outlet type. This highlights the importance of the balance of food options.
  • Context Matters: The study underscores that Western-centric assumptions about food environments may not directly translate to non-Western settings, necessitating culture-specific approaches to food environment assessment.
  • Ecological Model Importance: The study emphasizes that accounting for multiple influencing factors (socio-demographics, etc.) is crucial for understanding the true impact of the food environment, as initial associations can be attenuated or become significant only after adjustment.

Key Results

  • Adults living in areas with the highest RFEI (Q4, >5.76) had significantly higher odds of infrequent fruit consumption (OR = 1.36, 95% CI 1.04–1.78) and infrequent vegetable consumption (OR = 1.72, 95% CI 1.11–2.68) compared to those in the lowest RFEI areas (Q1, <2.25), after adjusting for covariates.
  • A high density of fast-food restaurants (Q4, >53) was also associated with increased odds of infrequent fruit consumption, though this association was attenuated after covariate adjustment.
  • The absolute density of grocery stores or convenience stores alone did not show significant associations with infrequent FV consumption once covariates were included.
  • Hong Kong exhibits a high density of both healthy and unhealthy food outlets compared to some Western cities, with an average of 43.27 healthy outlets and 187.81 unhealthy outlets within a 1000m radius.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study cannot establish causality between the food environment and dietary behavior.
  • GIS Sensitivity: Further research is needed to explore the impact of different GIS parameters (e.g., buffer types, distance metrics) on findings.
  • Community vs. Consumer Environment: The study focused on the "community nutritional environment" (availability of outlets) and did not assess the "consumer nutritional environment" (e.g., prices, promotions, nutritional quality within stores).
  • Mediating/Moderating Factors: The study did not explore how individual characteristics (like income or age) might mediate or moderate the relationship between the food environment and FV consumption.

Future work could involve longitudinal studies, incorporating consumer-level food environment data, and exploring interventions like zoning regulations to improve local food environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Outside of western countries, the study of the local food environment and evidence for its association with dietary behavior is limited. The aim of this paper was to examine the association between the local retail food environment and consumption of fruit and vegetables (FV) among adults in Hong Kong. Local retail food environment was measured by density of different types of retail food outlets (grocery stores, convenience stores, and fast food restaurants) within a 1000 m Euclidean buffer around individual's homes using a geographic information system (GIS). The Retail Food Environment Index (RFEI) was calculated based on the relative density of fast-food restaurants and convenience stores to grocery stores. Logistic regressions were performed to examine associations using cross-sectional data of 1977 adults (18 years or older). Overall, people living in an area with the highest RFEI (Q4, >5.76) had significantly greater odds of infrequent FV consumption (<7 days/week) after covariates adjustment (infrequent fruit consumption: OR = 1.36, 95% CI 1.04⁻1.78; infrequent vegetable consumption: OR = 1.72, 95% CI 1.11⁻2.68) in comparison to the lowest RFEI (Q1, <2.25). Highest density of fast food restaurants (Q4, >53) was also significantly associated with greater odds of infrequent fruit consumption (<7 days/week) (unadjusted model: OR = 1.34, 95% CI 1.04⁻1.73), relative to lowest density of fast food restaurants (Q1, <13). No significant association of density of grocery stores or convenience stores was observed with infrequent FV consumption regardless of the covariates included in the model. Our results suggest that the ratio of fast-food restaurants and convenience stores to grocery stores near people's home is an important environmental factor in meeting fruit and vegetable consumption guidelines. "Food swamps" (areas with an abundance of unhealthy foods) rather than "food deserts" (areas where there is limited access to healthy foods) seems to be more of a problem in Hong Kong's urban areas. We advanced international literature by providing evidence in a non-western setting.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2018local,
  author = {Ting Zhang and Bo Huang},
  title = {{Local Retail Food Environment and Consumption of Fruit and Vegetable among Adults in Hong Kong}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph15102247},
}
Figure