Local Evolution Model of the Communication Network for Reducing Outage Risk of Power Cyber-Physical System

Yuchen Fang, Xiafei Tang, Li Tang, Yang Chen, Weiyu WangEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel "local evolution model" for communication networks within power cyber-physical systems (CPS). By strategically adding communication links based on reconnection probabilities, the model aims to achieve a "one-to-one correspondence" with the power grid, thereby enhancing system observability, controllability, and significantly reducing the risk of cascading failures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern power grids are increasingly integrated with communication networks, forming complex cyber-physical systems (CPS). This deep integration is crucial for enhanced observability and control, but it also introduces vulnerabilities. A key challenge is that communication networks often don't perfectly mirror the power grid's topology; they are typically smaller and have a "partial interdependency." This mismatch hinders effective control and makes existing models for cascading failure analysis insufficient. The paper addresses this gap by proposing a method to evolve the communication network to better match the power grid, thereby mitigating the risks associated with this partial interdependency.

Methods

The core of the paper is the "local evolution model" for the communication network. This model works by:

  • Node and Link Addition: It simulates the growth of the communication network by adding new nodes and links. This process is guided by a "reconnection probability" (p), which dictates how new connections are formed. The goal is to gradually achieve a "one-to-one correspondence" between communication nodes/links and power grid nodes/lines.
  • Power Flow Entropy: The paper utilizes "power flow entropy" as a sensitivity index. A higher entropy indicates a more unbalanced power flow distribution, signaling a higher risk of cascading failures. This metric is used to identify critical transmission lines that, if they fail without a corresponding communication link, could destabilize the system.
  • Cascading Failure Simulation: A model for cascading failure propagation in partially interdependent networks is employed. This model simulates the impact of failures in either the power grid or the communication network and analyzes how these failures spread.
  • Reliability Index: The "cumulative probability of load loss" is used as a key metric to compare the operational reliability of different CPS configurations under various reconnection probabilities.

Datasets

The paper uses a provincial power grid as a case study for evaluation. Specific details about the dataset's origin or how it was acquired are not extensively detailed, but it is mentioned that data is available from the State Grid under specific licenses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "One-to-One Correspondence" is Key: The paper strongly emphasizes that achieving a closer "one-to-one correspondence" between communication and power grid elements is vital for improving CPS reliability.
  • Optimal Reconnection Probability: There's an optimal reconnection probability (around p=0.06) for evolving the communication network that balances achieving the desired correspondence with minimizing load loss during cascading failures.
  • Power Flow Entropy as a Diagnostic Tool: Power flow entropy effectively identifies critical transmission lines that lack communication counterparts, highlighting areas of vulnerability.
  • Evolutionary Approach Reduces Risk: The proposed local evolution model for the communication network demonstrably improves the CPS's resilience to cascading failures.

Key Results

  • The study found that an optimal reconnection probability of p = 0.06 for the communication network evolution leads to the lowest cumulative probability of load loss, indicating improved resilience.
  • By adding communication links to critical transmission lines, the risk of the power CPS entering a "self-organized critical state" (a precursor to cascading failures) is significantly reduced. For instance, adding at least three communication links was shown to prevent the system from entering this state.
  • The paper demonstrates that by strategically adding communication links, the power flow entropy can be effectively reduced, thereby enhancing the power grid's reliability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optimal Plan for Link Addition: While the paper identifies critical lines based on power flow entropy, the optimal plan for adding the smallest number of communication links to achieve resilience is explored through "Plan A," "Plan B," and "Plan C." Plan B, adding two links, showed improvement, but Plan C, adding three links, was found to be the most robust, preventing the self-organized critical state. The paper suggests that further research will focus on obtaining the optimal model for achieving the best evolution results.
  • Data Availability: While the data is stated to be available from the State Grid, it is subject to restrictions, implying that direct replication might require specific permissions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The deep integration of power grids and communication networks is the basis for realizing the complete observability and controllability of power grids. The communication node or link is always built according to the physical nodes. This step is alternatively known as “designing with the same power tower”. However, the communication networks do not form a “one-to-one correspondence” relationship with the power physical network. The existing theory cannot be applied to guide the practical power grid planning. In this paper, a local evolution model of a communication network based on the physical power grid topology is proposed in terms of reconnection probabilities. Firstly, the construction and upgrading of information nodes and links are modeled by the reconnection probabilities. Then, the power flow entropy is employed to identify whether the power cyber-physical system (CPS) is at the self-organized state, indicating the high probability of cascading failures. In addition, on the basis of the cascading failure propagation model of the partially dependent power CPS, operation reliabilities of the power CPS are compared with different reconnection probabilities using the cumulative probability of load loss as the reliable index. In the end, a practical provincial power grid is analyzed as an example. It is shown that the ability of the power CPS to resist cascading failures can be improved by the local growth evolution model of the communication networks. The ability is greater when the probability of reconnection is p = 0.06. By updating or constructing new links, the change in power flow entropy can be effectively reduced.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fang2022local,
  author = {Yuchen Fang and Xiafei Tang and Li Tang and Yang Chen and Weiyu Wang},
  title = {{Local Evolution Model of the Communication Network for Reducing Outage Risk of Power Cyber-Physical System}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15217876},
}
Figure