TL;DR
Automated Truck Platooning (ATP) promises fuel efficiency but poses a significant risk to highway bridges due to concentrated heavy loads. This study investigates the load effects of ATP on Chinese highway bridges, developing load models and identifying critical parameters like platooning size, inter-truck spacing, and truck mass. The findings suggest that while Grade-I bridges can generally handle ATP, careful management of platooning strategies is crucial to prevent adverse impacts on all bridge types.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Highway transportation is a cornerstone of freight movement, but heavy-duty trucks are major contributors to carbon emissions. Automated Truck Platooning (ATP) offers a solution by allowing trucks to travel in close proximity, reducing aerodynamic drag and thus fuel consumption and emissions. However, this technology introduces a new challenge: the concentrated load of multiple heavy-duty trucks on highway bridges. Existing bridge design codes, particularly in China, may not adequately account for these dense, closely spaced heavy loads. This study aims to bridge this gap by analyzing the load effects of ATP on Chinese highway bridges and proposing strategies to ensure their safety and the successful implementation of ATP.
Methods
The researchers employed an influence line method to assess the load effects of ATP on bridges. They developed ATP load models based on current Chinese road traffic regulations and adopted typical Chinese highway bridge models. The study systematically analyzed the impact of various parameters, including:
- Truck Type: Three typical semi-trailer trucks and a design truck were considered.
- Platooning Size: The number of trucks in a platoon ranged from 1 to 8.
- Inter-truck Spacing: Both standard (20 m) and extreme (4 m) spacings were investigated, along with a range of values in between.
- Truck Capacity Utilization Rate: This represented the ratio of the truck's actual gross mass to its legal upper limit, ranging from 60% to 100%.
- Critical Wheelbase Reduction: The study considered reductions in the critical wheelbase of trucks, as this affects load distribution.
The load effects of ATP were compared against those calculated using current Chinese bridge design specifications (JTG D60–2015) to identify critical loading conditions and potential safety margins. Numerical calculations were performed using MATLAB.
Datasets
The study utilized existing Chinese bridge design codes (MOT 1985, MOT 2004, and MOT 2015) and legal limits for freight trucks in China (GB 1589—2016) to develop their ATP load models and assess bridge responses. No new datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- ATP Load Magnification: ATP loads can significantly exceed those from conventional design lane loads, especially with reduced inter-truck spacing and increased platooning size.
- Critical Parameters: Inter-truck spacing, platooning size, truck mass (capacity utilization rate), and critical wheelbase are key factors influencing ATP's impact on bridges.
- Bridge Grade Matters: Grade-I highway bridges generally demonstrate better capacity to withstand ATP loads compared to Grade-II bridges, which may require more stringent controls.
- Unfavorable Span Ranges: Certain span lengths for Grade-II simply supported bridges were identified as "unfavorable" where ATP loads consistently exceed design limits.
- Inter-truck Spacing Thresholds: The study identified critical inter-truck spacing thresholds that must be maintained to ensure bridge safety, which vary based on bridge grade, truck type, and platooning size.
- Mass Limits are Crucial: Limiting the gross mass of platooning trucks, particularly for Grade-II bridges and larger platoons, is essential for mitigating adverse effects.
- Continuous Bridges are More Sensitive: Continuous bridges, especially those with larger side-to-main span ratios, are more sensitive to platooning size than simply supported bridges.
Key Results
- Load Effect Increase: ATP load effects increase with platooning size and decrease with inter-truck spacing.
- Unfavorable Span Ranges for Grade-II Bridges: For Grade-II simply supported bridges, unfavorable span ranges for bending moment were identified between 17–40 m, and for shear force between 11–40 m, under two-truck ATP loads.
- Truck Mass Control: Overloaded trucks should be prohibited in ATP. For Grade-II bridges, a six-axle truck's mass limit should be around 46 t (95% capacity utilization) to avoid unfavorable span ranges.
- Inter-truck Spacing Thresholds: For Grade-I simply supported bridges, a standard inter-truck spacing of 20 m is generally accommodatable. For Grade-II bridges, maintaining inter-truck spacing above 20 m is recommended for five-axle trucks, and for six-axle trucks, a mass limit of 44 t is suggested if spacing is 20 m.
- Continuous Bridge Suggestions: For Grade-I continuous bridges, a two-truck ATP with standard spacing is generally acceptable. For larger platoons or Grade-II bridges, additional mass limits and careful consideration of platooning size and spacing are necessary.
- General Upper Mass Limits: A formula was proposed for general upper mass limits for platooning trucks, with a recommended maximum platooning size of three trucks for simpler regulation.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations: The study primarily focused on simply supported and three-span continuous bridges. The analysis of load effects was based on simplified bridge models and did not fully capture complex dynamic behaviors. The study also acknowledged that the current Chinese truck weight regulations are not always strictly enforced, which could influence real-world ATP impacts.
- Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into the coupled vibration system of ATP and highway bridges to ensure the safety of both bridge structures and truck operations. More complex bridge types and dynamic analyses would be beneficial.
Summary updated