Load Calculation Method for Deep-Buried Layered Soft Rock Tunnel Based on Back-Analysis of Structural Deformation

Lixin Zhang, Lijun Chen, Jianxun Chen, Yanbin Luo, Huijie Guo, Yang Zhai, Pengkun WangSymmetry 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Deformation-Structure" (D-S) load calculation method for deep-buried layered soft rock tunnels. By leveraging measured structural deformations, this approach provides a more accurate and reliable way to determine the loads on primary tunnel supports, addressing limitations of existing methods in complex geological conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Deep-buried tunnels, especially those in layered soft rock, face significant challenges due to the complex redistribution of stresses after excavation. This can lead to deformation-related disasters like cracking and instability of support structures. A critical factor in preventing these issues is accurately calculating the loads acting on the primary support. However, traditional methods often struggle with the anisotropic nature of layered soft rock, making their application limited and potentially leading to inaccurate load estimations. The authors aim to bridge this gap by proposing a method that directly uses observed structural behavior to infer these loads.

Methods

The core of this paper is the proposed "Deformation-Structure" (D-S) load calculation method. This approach models the primary tunnel support as a series of elastic beam elements. Crucially, it incorporates "spring elements" to represent the elastic resistance of the surrounding rock, which indirectly accounts for the anisotropic characteristics of layered rock. The method relies on measured deformation data from the tunnel structure. By establishing a comprehensive stiffness matrix that considers the geometric shape, construction stages, and constraints, the D-S method uses deformation compatibility and static equilibrium conditions to solve for nodal displacements and, subsequently, the equivalent node loads. This allows for the determination of the load magnitude and distribution acting on the primary support.

Datasets

The study utilizes a dataset of 182 sets of sample data from 56 typical deep-buried layered soft rock tunnels. This data, collected through field measurements and literature research, includes information on loads and deformations. The Muzhailing Super-long Highway Tunnel in China serves as a primary case study for applying and validating the D-S method.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Deformation as a Proxy for Load: The fundamental insight is that structural deformation is a direct consequence of the loads acting on it. By measuring deformation, we can "back-calculate" the forces responsible.
  • Addressing Anisotropy: The use of spring elements to represent elastic resistance is a key innovation for handling the complex, non-uniform behavior of layered soft rock, which is often overlooked by simpler models.
  • Stage-by-Stage Modeling: The D-S method accounts for the evolving geometry and constraints during tunnel construction, providing a more realistic load assessment at each stage.
  • Practical Parameter Acquisition: The method relies on parameters that are generally easier to obtain (e.g., material properties, measured deformations) compared to some traditional methods that require complex geotechnical investigations.

Key Results

The D-S load calculation method was applied to the Muzhailing Tunnel, demonstrating its ability to capture the uneven and asymmetric load distribution characteristic of deep-buried layered soft rock tunnels. The results showed that the load distribution was significantly influenced by the strata inclination and construction progress, with load values increasing as excavation progressed. The method's calculated loads were found to be within a reasonable range when compared to a large dataset of field measurements, with a relative error of less than 10% for typical tunnel projects. Furthermore, the D-S method's results differed significantly from traditional methods like Promojiyfakonov, Terzaghi, and Fenner, highlighting its improved accuracy for this specific geological condition.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the D-S method requires reconstructing the geometric form of the model and adjusting units for each specific construction process, which can be time-consuming for complex projects. They suggest that the method is particularly suitable for long and large tunnel projects. Future work could focus on developing user-friendly tunnel simulation platforms that integrate the D-S method for real-time monitoring and timely adjustment of support designs, thereby enhancing the efficiency, economy, and safety of tunnel construction.

Summary updated

Abstract

After the excavation and unloading of deep-buried soft rock tunnels, support structures often experience deformation-related disasters such as concrete cracking, steel frame bending and twisting, and primary support instability under different forms of load. Accurately calculating the load borne by the primary support structure is the key to ensuring design rationality and construction safety. Especially in layered soft surrounding rock formations, the magnitude and distribution of the loads are different from those of conventional rock and soil masses, resulting in limited applicability of existing load calculation methods to similar formations. Therefore, based on the measured deformation of the tunnel structure, while considering the different geometric forms of the primary support structure during partial excavation, this paper proposes a deformation-structure (D-S) load calculation method. By comparing the calculation results of this method and a large number of sample data for typical deep-buried layered soft rock tunnels, the reliability of the D-S load calculation method is verified. In addition, the variation law of the loads during the tunnel construction period is enunciated, and the magnitude and distribution of the loads acting on the primary support are clarified. The D-S load calculation method provides a theoretical basis for load calculation in deep-buried layered soft rock tunnels.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024load,
  author = {Lixin Zhang and Lijun Chen and Jianxun Chen and Yanbin Luo and Huijie Guo and Yang Zhai and Pengkun Wang},
  title = {{Load Calculation Method for Deep-Buried Layered Soft Rock Tunnel Based on Back-Analysis of Structural Deformation}},
  booktitle = {Symmetry},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/sym16040383},
}
Figure