Lithium Niobate MEMS Antisymmetric Lamb Wave Resonators with Support Structures

Yi Zhang, Yang Jiang, Chuying Tang, Chenkai Deng, Fangzhou Du, Jiaqi He, Qiaoyu Hu, Qing Wang, Hongyu Yu, Zhongrui WangMicromachines 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel design for Lithium Niobate (LiNbO₃) MEMS resonators that significantly suppresses unwanted spurious modes and enhances mechanical stability and power handling. By incorporating support pillars, these resonators can better dissipate spurious wave energy, paving the way for more robust and efficient RF filters.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid growth of wireless communication, particularly in the sub-6 GHz range for 5G, demands RF filters with higher operating frequencies and broader bandwidths. While Lithium Niobate (LiNbO₃) is a promising material for acoustic resonators due to its high electromechanical coupling coefficient, existing first-order antisymmetric (A1) Lamb mode resonators face critical challenges. These include:

  • Spurious Modes: Unwanted resonant frequencies that interfere with the desired signal, degrading filter performance.
  • Mechanical Instability: The suspended nature of these resonators makes them susceptible to mechanical stress and damage.
  • Limited Power Capacity: Inadequate heat dissipation leads to self-heating, which can warp the device, shift resonant frequencies, and cause irreversible damage, limiting their use in high-power applications.

This paper aims to address these limitations by proposing a new resonator architecture.

Methods

The researchers propose and analyze a novel A1 Lamb mode resonator design that incorporates support pillars beneath the LiNbO₃ thin film and electrodes.

  • Finite Element Analysis (FEA): The study extensively uses FEA to simulate the propagation characteristics of A1 modes and spurious modes in resonators with varying geometries (e.g., electrode pitch 'P').
  • Support Pillar Integration: The core innovation is the addition of support pillars. These pillars are designed to anchor the piezoelectric film to the substrate, providing mechanical support and a pathway for spurious wave energy to dissipate into the substrate.
  • Fabrication Process: A feasible fabrication process is outlined, involving photolithography, thermal oxidation, He ion implantation for creating a defect layer, bonding, annealing, chemical mechanical polishing (CMP), e-beam lithography for IDTs, and etching to create release holes and cavities.
  • Thermal Simulation: FEA is also employed to simulate the thermal behavior of resonators with different support structures (Si pillars, SiO₂ pillars, and suspended structures) under a heat source.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spurious Mode Dissipation: The support pillars act as a crucial element for dissipating spurious wave energy into the substrate, effectively mitigating unwanted modes that plague conventional suspended resonators. This is a direct consequence of creating a more connected structure rather than a purely suspended one.
  • Mechanical Robustness: Anchoring the LiNbO₃ film with pillars significantly enhances the mechanical stability of the resonator, making it less prone to damage.
  • Improved Heat Dissipation: The pillars provide a thermal pathway to the substrate, dramatically reducing the self-heating effect and increasing the resonator's power handling capacity. This is a critical advantage for high-power RF applications.
  • Trade-offs and Optimization: While pillars can slightly reduce the primary mode's Q factor (especially at smaller electrode pitches), this can be effectively compensated by increasing the electrode pitch (P) or gap (G). This highlights the importance of design optimization.
  • Material Synergy: The use of Si or SiO₂ pillars offers additional benefits. Si provides excellent thermal conductivity, while SiO₂ can act as a temperature compensation component, further stabilizing the resonator's frequency.

Key Results

  • Spurious Mode Reduction: Simulations show that resonators with support pillars exhibit significantly fewer spurious modes compared to suspended-plate structures across various electrode pitches.
  • Enhanced Q Factor (with optimization): While initial Q values might be lower, increasing electrode pitch (P) allows the Q values of pillar-supported resonators to converge with or even surpass those of suspended resonators. For example, with 20 electrodes and a pitch of 20 µm, Qs increased from 108 to 287 and Qp from 397 to 460 compared to a suspended structure.
  • Reduced Temperature Rise: Thermal simulations demonstrated a drastic reduction in self-heating. The temperature increment for Si pillar-supported structures was only about 2°C, compared to 423 K for suspended structures. SiO₂ pillars also showed significant improvement over suspended designs.
  • Frequency Stability: The combination of Si/SiO₂ pillars and the LiNbO₃ material offers potential for temperature compensation, with SiO₂ providing a positive TCF to counteract LiNbO₃'s negative TCF.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fabrication Complexity: The authors acknowledge that the fabrication process for resonators with support pillars is more challenging than for conventional suspended structures, particularly concerning the bonding step.
  • Q Factor Trade-off: At smaller electrode pitches, the Q factor of the primary mode can be slightly reduced due to energy leakage. However, this is presented as an optimization challenge rather than a fundamental flaw.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that these advantages highlight the considerable potential of the proposed structures, paving the way for further advancements and optimizations in resonator design. This implies continued research into optimizing pillar dimensions, materials, and electrode configurations for even better performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

The piezoelectric thin film composed of single-crystal lithium niobate (LiNbO<sub>3</sub>) exhibits a remarkably high electromechanical coupling coefficient and minimal intrinsic losses, making it an optimal material for fabricating bulk acoustic wave resonators. However, contemporary first-order antisymmetric (A1) Lamb mode resonators based on LiNbO<sub>3</sub> thin films face specific challenges, such as inadequate mechanical stability, limited power capacity, and the presence of multiple spurious modes, which restrict their applicability in a broader context. In this paper, we present an innovative design for A1 Lamb mode resonators that incorporates a support-pillar structure. Integration of support pillars enables the dissipation of spurious wave energy to the substrate, effectively mitigating unwanted spurious modes. Additionally, this novel approach involves anchoring the piezoelectric thin film to a supportive framework, consequently enhancing mechanical stability while simultaneously improving the heat dissipation capabilities of the core.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024lithium,
  author = {Yi Zhang and Yang Jiang and Chuying Tang and Chenkai Deng and Fangzhou Du and Jiaqi He and Qiaoyu Hu and Qing Wang and Hongyu Yu and Zhongrui Wang},
  title = {{Lithium Niobate MEMS Antisymmetric Lamb Wave Resonators with Support Structures}},
  booktitle = {Micromachines},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/mi15020195},
}
Figure