Liquid phase blending of metal-organic frameworks

Louis Longley, Sean M. Collins, Chao Zhou, Glen J. Smales, Sarah E. Norman, Nick J. Brownbill, Christopher W. Ashling, Philip A. Chater, Robert Tovey, Carola‐Bibiane Schönlieb, Thomas F. Headen, Nicholas J. Terrill, Yuanzheng Yue, Andrew J. Smith, Frédéric Blanc, David A. Keen, Paul A. Midgley, Thomas D. BennettNature Communications 2018 · DOI

Abstract

The liquid and glass states of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have recently become of interest due to the potential for liquid-phase separations and ion transport, alongside the fundamental nature of the latter as a new, fourth category of melt-quenched glass. Here we show that the MOF liquid state can be blended with another MOF component, resulting in a domain structured MOF glass with a single, tailorable glass transition. Intra-domain connectivity and short range order is confirmed by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and pair distribution function measurements. The interfacial binding between MOF domains in the glass state is evidenced by electron tomography, and the relationship between domain size and $T_g$ investigated. Nanoindentation experiments are also performed to place this new class of MOF materials into context with organic blends and inorganic alloys.

Introduction

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are typically celebrated for their crystalline porosity, making them ideal for gas storage and catalysis. However, their crystalline nature often results in fragile powders that are difficult to process into useful industrial shapes like membranes or fibers.

Recently, a subset of MOFs was discovered to melt into liquids and quench into glasses—creating a "fourth category" of melt-quenched glass alongside inorganic, organic, and metallic glasses. Until now, these MOF glasses were limited to single-component systems. This research addresses the challenge of miscibility: can we mix different MOFs together in the liquid phase to create hybrid "alloys" with customized thermal and mechanical properties?

Methods and Materials

The study focused on the Zeolitic Imidazolate Framework (ZIF) family, specifically mixing ZIF-4 (containing Zn or Co) and ZIF-62.

Structural and thermal characterization of MOF blends. (a) Crystal structures of ZIF-4-Co and ZIF-62. (b) DSC and TGA curves for the Zn-based mixture and blend. (c) Linear tunability of the glass transition temperature ($T_g$) with composition. (d) Thermal analysis of the Co-based mixture showing the quench point.
  • Synthesis: Researchers used ball-milling to create a homogeneous physical mixture of crystalline MOF powders. These were then heated above their melting temperatures ($T_m \approx 400–600^\circ\text{C}$) in an inert argon atmosphere and quenched to form a solid glass.
  • Thermal Characterization: Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) was employed to identify the glass transition temperature ($T_g$).
  • Structural Analysis: Synchrotron X-ray and neutron total scattering were used to generate Pair Distribution Functions (PDFs), revealing short-range atomic ordering.
  • Chemical Mapping: To visualize metal distribution, Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy (EELS) and EDS Tomography were used to reconstruct the 3D distribution of Cobalt and Zinc within glass shards at the nanoscale.
  • Mechanical Testing: Nanoindentation measured the Young’s modulus ($E$) to compare the blend's stiffness to traditional materials.

Key Insights: The "Single $T_g$" Phenomenon

A major finding was that the MOF blends exhibited a single, sharp glass transition. In polymer science, a single $T_g$ is the "gold standard" proof of miscibility. This suggests that even though the MOFs don't mix perfectly at the atomic level, they are functionally integrated.

The authors propose that at the interface between two MOF liquids, the metal-ligand bonds break and reform, "swapping" imidazolate linkers. This ligand swapping creates chemical connectivity between different domains, effectively "gluing" the blend together. Electron tomography revealed that the blend is not a perfectly homogeneous "alloy" but a collection of interlocked domains (200 nm to 1 µm), a structure reminiscent of certain high-performance inorganic glasses.

Results and Discussion

Thermal and Mechanical Properties

For the (ZIF-4-Zn)$_{0.5}$(ZIF-62)$_{0.5}$ blend, the $T_g$ was measured at 306°C, distinct from the $T_g$ of the individual components (292°C and 318°C). Crucially, the $T_g$ of the blend follows a linear relationship based on the ratio of the two components, allowing for precise "tuning" of thermal properties.

Mechanically, the Young’s modulus ($E$) of the MOF blends was approximately 7.1–7.5 GPa. This places them in a unique niche: stiffer than almost all organic polymers but more compliant than traditional inorganic oxide glasses like silica.

Structural Integrity

PDF analysis confirmed that the short-range order—specifically the tetrahedral coordination of the metal nodes—remains intact after melting and blending, despite the loss of long-range crystalline order.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While the high viscosity of MOF liquids currently prevents true atomic-level homogeneity, the resulting interlocked domain structure offers a new way to engineer hybrid materials. Future work may focus on expanding this liquid-phase blending to other MOF families (e.g., carboxylates) and exploring ways to maintain porosity in the glass state for applications in gas separation or ion transport.

Summary updated

Abstract

The liquid and glass states of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have recently become of interest due to the potential for liquid-phase separations and ion transport, alongside the fundamental nature of the latter as a new, fourth category of melt-quenched glass. Here we show that the MOF liquid state can be blended with another MOF component, resulting in a domain structured MOF glass with a single, tailorable glass transition. Intra-domain connectivity and short range order is confirmed by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and pair distribution function measurements. The interfacial binding between MOF domains in the glass state is evidenced by electron tomography, and the relationship between domain size and T<sub>g</sub> investigated. Nanoindentation experiments are also performed to place this new class of MOF materials into context with organic blends and inorganic alloys.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{longley2018liquid,
  author = {Louis Longley and Sean M. Collins and Chao Zhou and Glen J. Smales and Sarah E. Norman and Nick J. Brownbill and Christopher W. Ashling and Philip A. Chater and Robert Tovey and Carola‐Bibiane Schönlieb and Thomas F. Headen and Nicholas J. Terrill and Yuanzheng Yue and Andrew J. Smith and Frédéric Blanc and David A. Keen and Paul A. Midgley and Thomas D. Bennett},
  title = {{Liquid phase blending of metal-organic frameworks}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-018-04553-6},
}

Loading related content...

Figure