Liquid-Ordered Phase Formation by Mammalian and Yeast Sterols: A Common Feature With Organizational Differences

Alena Khmelinskaia, Joaquim T. Marquês, André E.p. Bastos, Catarina A.c. Antunes, Andreia Bento‐Oliveira, Silvia Scolari, Gerson M. da S. Lobo, Rui Malhó, Andreas Herrmann, H. Susana Marinho, Rodrigo F.m. de AlmeidaFrontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the biophysical properties of membranes enriched in three metabolically related sterols: cholesterol, ergosterol, and their precursor, zymosterol. While cholesterol and ergosterol are known to induce liquid-ordered ($l_o$) phases essential for membrane organization, zymosterol fails to do so, instead accommodating easily into gel phases. Using fluorescence-lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) of an aminostyryl dye in both model membranes and living cells, researchers established a parallel between in vitro and in vivo sterol behavior. The findings reveal fundamental differences in eukaryotic membrane organization: cholesterol interacts preferentially with saturated lipids, whereas ergosterol favors monounsaturated phosphatidylcholines. This suggests that different kingdoms have evolved unique molecular strategies to achieve the common goal of a stable, ordered plasma membrane.

Introduction: The Evolutionary "Why" of Sterol Diversity

The eukaryotic plasma membrane is a complex mosaic, not a passive barrier. Central to its function are "liquid-ordered" ($l_o$) domains—often termed lipid rafts—which are critical for signal transduction and protein trafficking. While cholesterol (animals) and ergosterol (fungi) are the primary drivers of these domains, their common metabolic precursor, zymosterol (Zym), remains a biosynthetic intermediate. This research explores why zymosterol was bypassed by evolution as a structural component and how well simplified model membranes reflect the complexity of living cells.

Methods and Materials

The researchers utilized a dual-track experimental design comparing model systems with living cells. Model membranes (GUVs and LUVs) were constructed using various lipid scaffolds, including saturated DPPC and unsaturated POPC or DOPC. Fluorescence-Lifetime Imaging Microscopy (FLIM) was employed using the dye di-4-ANEPPS, whose lifetime is sensitive to membrane order and hydration.

Chemical structures of the lipid scaffolds (DPPC, POPC, DOPC) and the fluorescent probe (di-4-ANEPPS) used to characterize membrane phases.

Key Findings

Zymosterol: A Structural Failure

Unlike its evolutionary descendants, zymosterol is unable to induce the $l_o$ phase. Instead of organizing the membrane, it "hides" within existing lipid structures. This lack of organizational capacity makes Zym-rich membranes significantly more permeable than those containing cholesterol or ergosterol, explaining its exclusion from mature plasma membranes.

Kingdom-Specific Lipid Preferences

A major insight of this study is the divergence in lipid pairing between animals and fungi. Cholesterol shows a strong affinity for saturated lipids (like sphingolipids), forming highly ordered domains. In contrast, ergosterol appears to prefer monounsaturated lipids (like POPC). This suggests that fungi have optimized their primary sterol to work with the specific fatty acid profiles they produce, which differ from those in mammalian cells.

Bridging the In Vitro - In Vivo Gap

The study found a remarkable correlation between model membranes and living cells. The FLIM signatures of di-4-ANEPPS in CHO cells closely matched cholesterol-rich model vesicles, while yeast signatures aligned with ergosterol-rich models. Interestingly, mammalian plasma membranes were found to be generally more ordered (average lifetime $\sim$4.27 ns) than fungal ones ($\sim$2.58 ns).

Conclusion and Future Directions

The research demonstrates that while the formation of ordered membrane domains is a conserved evolutionary trait across eukaryotes, the specific molecular "recipes" used to achieve this order have diverged. Cholesterol and ergosterol have evolved to interact with different lipid environments. Future research is needed to address membrane asymmetry and how high protein densities further modulate these biophysical properties in a native environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Here, biophysical properties of membranes enriched in three metabolically related sterols are analyzed both <i>in vitro</i> and <i>in vivo</i>. Unlike cholesterol and ergosterol, the common metabolic precursor zymosterol is unable to induce the formation of a liquid ordered (<i>l</i> <sub>o</sub>) phase in model lipid membranes and can easily accommodate in a gel phase. As a result, Zym has a marginal ability to modulate the passive membrane permeability of lipid vesicles with different compositions, contrary to cholesterol and ergosterol. Using fluorescence-lifetime imaging microscopy of an aminostyryl dye in living mammalian and yeast cells we established a close parallel between sterol-dependent membrane biophysical properties <i>in vivo</i> and <i>in vitro</i>. This approach unraveled fundamental differences in yeast and mammalian plasma membrane organization. It is often suggested that, in eukaryotes, areas that are sterol-enriched are also rich in sphingolipids, constituting highly ordered membrane regions. Our results support that while cholesterol is able to interact with saturated lipids, ergosterol seems to interact preferentially with monounsaturated phosphatidylcholines. Taken together, we show that different eukaryotic kingdoms developed unique solutions for the formation of a sterol-rich plasma membrane, a common evolutionary trait that accounts for sterol structural diversity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{khmelinskaia2020liquid,
  author = {Alena Khmelinskaia and Joaquim T. Marquês and André E.P. Bastos and Catarina A.C. Antunes and Andreia Bento‐Oliveira and Silvia Scolari and Gerson M. da S. Lobo and Rui Malhó and Andreas Herrmann and H. Susana Marinho and Rodrigo F.M. de Almeida},
  title = {{Liquid-Ordered Phase Formation by Mammalian and Yeast Sterols: A Common Feature With Organizational Differences}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fcell.2020.00337},
}
Figure