Lipid modification to improve cryotolerance of gametes, embryos and larvae and its potential application in aquaculture species: a review

Xiaochen Zhu, Penny Miller-Ezzy, Yingying Zhao, Jian G. Qin, Youhong Tang, Yibing Liu, Xiaoxu LiFrontiers in Marine Science 2023 · DOI

Cryopreservation is a cornerstone of modern aquaculture, enabling the long-term storage of genetic material and facilitating efficient breeding programs. By maintaining biological materials at ultralow temperatures, researchers can overcome challenges like asynchronous maturation and unbalanced sex ratios. However, the process is fraught with physical and chemical stresses that often lead to poor survival rates. Recent research highlights lipid sensitivity as a primary cause of cryoinjury, particularly in the complex oocytes and embryos of aquatic species.

The Challenge of Cryoinjury and Lipid Phase Transition

The transition of cell membranes from a flexible liquid state to a rigid, crystalline gel—known as Lipid Phase Transition (LPT)—is a major hurdle. As temperatures drop, this hardening can lead to membrane rupture and metabolic failure. Aquatic oocytes and embryos are especially vulnerable due to their large size and high intracellular lipid content (yolk), which increases chilling sensitivity compared to smaller, simpler cells like sperm.

Strategies for Lipid Modification

To combat these issues, researchers have developed several strategies to manipulate lipid profiles and enhance membrane stability. These methods, largely adapted from successful mammalian studies, include:

  1. Nutritional Management: Adjusting the diet of broodstock to increase levels of Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids (PUFAs), which naturally improves the cryoresistance of the resulting gametes.
  2. Exogenous Supplementation: Adding stabilizing agents like cholesterol or Low-Density Lipoproteins (LDL) directly to the freezing medium (extender).
  3. Delipidation: This involves reducing the cell's fat content either mechanically (via centrifugation) or chemically (using lipolysis stimulators like Forskolin or L-carnitine).
  4. Cholesterol Loading: Utilizing methyl-β-cyclodextrin (MBC) to insert cholesterol into membranes, broadening the temperature range of the liquid-to-gel transition and preventing premature hardening.
Summary of lipid modification strategies and their impact on post-thaw parameters in various animal models.

Insights from Mammalian and Aquatic Models

While much of the foundational work has been performed on mammalian models such as bovine and porcine embryos, these insights are now being applied to aquatic species. For instance, high levels of DHA (a type of PUFA) increase membrane fluidity because their molecular structure prevents tight packing at low temperatures.

Interestingly, while lipids provide essential energy, an excess of intracellular lipids can be detrimental during freezing. This "lipid paradox" makes delipidation a highly effective, if counterintuitive, strategy. Chemical delipidation using Forskolin has been shown to significantly increase survival rates in bovine embryos, a success that researchers hope to replicate in fish and shellfish.

Advanced lipid modification methods, including carnitine treatments and cholesterol-loaded cyclodextrin, used to improve cryopreservation outcomes.

Key Results in Aquaculture

Recent studies have shown promising results across various aquatic species:

  • Salmonids: In Atlantic salmon, adding exogenous lipids to the freezing medium improved membrane integrity and fertility.
  • Carp: Cholesterol-loaded cyclodextrin enhanced sperm motility and fertilization rates in common carp.
  • Shellfish: For Pacific oysters, supplementing larvae with specific phospholipids and Vitamin E significantly improved "spat yield," the number of larvae that successfully settle and grow.
  • Coral: Vitrified coral larvae treated with erucic acid liposomes achieved higher post-thaw settlement rates, offering a vital tool for reef restoration.

Future Directions

Despite these advancements, aquatic cryopreservation faces unique challenges. The "oocyte wall"—the large size and low surface-area-to-volume ratio of fish eggs—makes uniform lipid modification and cryoprotectant penetration difficult. Furthermore, optimal lipid "cocktails" are often species-specific.

Future research is shifting toward in vitro lipid modulation, where oocytes are grown in specialized media to "tune" their lipid content before cryopreservation. Integrating nanotechnology, such as using gold nanoparticles to improve the delivery of protective lipids, also holds significant potential for the future of aquaculture and genetic conservation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cryopreservation is a technique to maintain biological materials’ physiological and genetic stability at an ultralow temperature. For commercially important livestock or aquatic species, gamete and embryo cryopreservation could play a significant role in breeding programs and commercial production. For example, it could help overcome key problems such as asynchronous maturation and an unbalanced sex ratio. However, the physiochemical stresses imposed by cryopreservation can negatively affect gametes and embryos, leading to a poor survival rate. Recent studies on cryoinjury have demonstrated that the cryosensitivity of lipids is one of the key causes of cryodamage in mammalians, as lipid compositions in membranes of gametes and embryos are closely related to their cryoresistance. In addition, the cryotolerance of gametes and embryos in some mammalian species has been improved by lipid modification. However, studies on the role of lipids in the cryopreservation of gametes, embryos, and larvae are rare in fish and shellfish. Therefore, this review focuses on recent methodological advances to improve cryotolerance by lipid modification, including lipid application or manipulation in human and livestock sperm, oocytes, and embryos, and how these novel approaches could improve cryopreservation techniques in aquatic species, especially for oocytes and embryos.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2023lipid,
  author = {Xiaochen Zhu and Penny Miller-Ezzy and Yingying Zhao and Jian G. Qin and Youhong Tang and Yibing Liu and Xiaoxu Li},
  title = {{Lipid modification to improve cryotolerance of gametes, embryos and larvae and its potential application in aquaculture species: a review}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2023.1235958},
}
Figure