Lipid membranes from naked mole-rat brain lipids are cholesterol-rich, highly phase-separated, and sensitive to amyloid-induced damage

Daniel Frankel, Matthew Davies, Bharat Bhushan, Yavuz Kulaberoglu, Paulina Urriola‐Muñoz, Justine Bertrand‐Michel, Melissa R. Pergande, Andrew A. Smith, Swapan Preet, Thomas J. Park, Michele Vendruscolo, Kenneth S. Rankin, Stephanie M. Cologna, Janet R. Kumita, Nicolas Cénac, Ewan St John SmithbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Naked mole-rats, known for their exceptional longevity and resistance to neurodegenerative diseases, possess unique brain lipid membranes that are unusually rich in cholesterol and highly phase-separated. Despite high levels of amyloid-beta peptide in their brains, these membranes are surprisingly susceptible to amyloid-beta-induced disruption, suggesting their neuroprotection relies on oxidative resistance rather than mechanical resilience.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Alzheimer's disease (AD) is a devastating neurodegenerative condition characterized by the accumulation of amyloid-beta (Aβ) plaques in the brain. While Aβ is a known neurotoxic agent, naked mole-rats (NMRs), a species with an extraordinary lifespan and remarkable resistance to age-related diseases, paradoxically have high levels of Aβ in their brains but do not develop AD-like pathology. This presents a significant puzzle: how do NMRs achieve this protection? This paper investigates whether the unique composition and properties of NMR brain lipid membranes play a role in this resistance, particularly in how they interact with Aβ.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Lipidomics (Mass Spectrometry): They used liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) to comprehensively analyze the lipid profiles of brain tissue from NMRs and mice. This allowed for the quantification of various lipid classes, including cholesterol, sphingomyelin, phospholipids, and ceramides.
  • Proteomics (LC-MS/MS): Differential proteomic analysis was used to compare protein abundance between mouse and NMR brain lysates, focusing on enzymes involved in lipid metabolism.
  • Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): AFM was a crucial tool for visualizing the physical properties of lipid membranes. They used it to:
  • Examine the phase separation and two-dimensional ordering of lipid bilayers formed from brain extracts.
  • Measure membrane thickness and breakthrough force (a proxy for stiffness/fluidity).
  • Observe the real-time interactions of synthetic human amyloid-beta peptides with these lipid bilayers.
  • Model Systems: They used a simplified model system of two lipids (DOPC and DPPC) to understand basic phase separation behavior and amyloid-beta interaction before moving to more complex brain-derived lipid extracts.

Datasets

The study utilized brain tissue from:

  • Naked mole-rats (NMRs)
  • C57BL6/J mice

No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on comparative analysis of existing biological samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cholesterol-Rich, Phase-Separated Membranes: NMR brain lipids are significantly richer in cholesterol and exhibit a much higher degree of phase separation compared to mouse brain lipids. This means their membranes are not uniform but rather form distinct domains, with the liquid-ordered phase occupying up to 80% of the membrane.
  • Unexpected Amyloid-Beta Susceptibility: Despite their unique membrane properties, NMR brain lipid bilayers are surprisingly disrupted by amyloid-beta, breaking into fragments. In contrast, mouse brain lipid bilayers, while showing some interaction, maintain their integrity and form small, well-defined footprints.
  • "Membrane Pacemaker" Hypothesis Connection: The highly phase-separated and cholesterol-rich nature of NMR membranes aligns with the "membrane pacemaker" theory of aging, which suggests that long-lived species have membranes resistant to oxidative damage. However, this study suggests this resistance might not translate to mechanical protection against amyloid-beta.
  • Altered Lipid Metabolism Proteins: The proteomic analysis revealed decreased levels of key enzymes involved in ceramide and sphingomyelin metabolism in NMR brains, providing a molecular link to the observed lipid composition differences.
  • Amyloid-Beta Avoids Ordered Domains (in model): In a simplified model system, amyloid-beta was observed to preferentially interact with the disordered lipid phase, avoiding the more ordered DPPC gel domains.

Key Results

  • NMR brain lipids contain significantly more cholesterol and less sphingomyelin (with shorter chain lengths) than mouse brain lipids.
  • NMR brain lipid bilayers exhibit a high degree of phase separation, with liquid-ordered domains occupying up to 80% of the membrane. Mouse brain lipid bilayers show little to no phase separation.
  • NMR brain lipid bilayers are stiffer than mouse brain lipid bilayers, likely due to higher cholesterol content.
  • Exposure to human amyloid-beta (8 µM for 2 hours) causes significant disruption and fragmentation of NMR brain lipid bilayers.
  • Mouse brain lipid bilayers, under the same conditions, show pores but maintain overall integrity, with amyloid-beta appearing to penetrate deeply.
  • Proteomic analysis showed decreased levels of acid ceramidase and ceramide synthase 2 in NMR cerebellar tissue, and decreased sphingomyelinase and S1P receptor 1 in NMR hippocampus.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In Vitro vs. In Vivo: The study uses extracted lipids to form artificial bilayers. While informative, this is an in vitro model and doesn't fully replicate the complex cellular environment, including the presence of proteins and cytoskeleton, which also contribute to membrane stability. The authors acknowledge this by stating that cell membranes consist of more than just phospholipids.
  • Amyloid-Beta Source: The study used synthetic human amyloid-beta. While NMRs have high levels of endogenous Aβ, the interaction with synthetic human Aβ might not perfectly reflect the in vivo situation, although they did note similar behaviors when using NMR-derived Aβ.
  • Mechanism of Disruption: While the study shows NMR membranes are disrupted, the precise molecular mechanism of this disruption by amyloid-beta requires further investigation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that NMR neuroprotection might be more reliant on resistance to oxidative processes rather than mechanical resistance. Future work could explore the specific oxidative defense mechanisms within NMR brain membranes and how they interact with amyloid-beta. Further investigation into the role of other membrane components (proteins, etc.) in NMRs' resistance to Aβ toxicity is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Naked mole-rats are extraordinarily long-lived rodents that do not develop age-related neurodegenerative diseases. Remarkably, they do not accumulate amyloid plaques, even though their brains contain high concentrations of amyloid beta peptide, even from a young age Therefore, these animals offer an opportunity to investigate mechanisms of resistance against the neurotoxicity of amyloid beta aggregation. Working in this direction, here we examine the composition, phase behaviour, and amyloid beta interactions of naked mole-rat brain lipids. Relative to mouse, naked mole-rat brain lipids are rich in cholesterol and contain sphingomyelin in lower amounts and of shorter chain lengths. Proteins associated with metabolism of ceramides, sphingomyelin and ceramide receptor activity were also found to be decreased in naked mole-rat brain lysates. Correspondingly, we find that naked mole-rat brain lipid membranes exhibit a high degree of phase separation, with the liquid ordered phase occupying up to 80% of the supported lipid bilayer. These observations are consistent with the ‘membrane pacemaker’ hypothesis of ageing, according to which long-living species have lipid membranes particularly resistant to oxidative damage. However, we found that exposure to amyloid beta disrupts the naked mole-rat brain lipid membranes while those formed from mouse brain lipids exhibit small, well-defined footprints, whereby the amyloid beta penetrates deeply into the lipid membranes. These results suggest that in naked mole-rats the lipid composition of cell membranes may offer neuroprotection through resistance to oxidative processes rather than through mechanical effects.
BibTeX
@misc{frankel2020lipid,
  author = {Daniel Frankel and Matthew Davies and Bharat Bhushan and Yavuz Kulaberoglu and Paulina Urriola‐Muñoz and Justine Bertrand‐Michel and Melissa R. Pergande and Andrew A. Smith and Swapan Preet and Thomas J. Park and Michele Vendruscolo and Kenneth S. Rankin and Stephanie M. Cologna and Janet R. Kumita and Nicolas Cénac and Ewan St John Smith},
  title = {{Lipid membranes from naked mole-rat brain lipids are cholesterol-rich, highly phase-separated, and sensitive to amyloid-induced damage}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.06.05.134973},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure