Linking suicide and social determinants of health in South Korea: An investigation of structural determinants

Yongjun Zhu, Seojin Nam, Lihong Quan, Jihyun Baek, Hong Jin Jeon, Buzhou TangFrontiers in Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how structural social determinants of health (gender, social class, occupation) are linked to various suicide outcomes in South Korea, using a national-level suicide registry. It highlights significant differences in suicide methods, places of death, and warning signs across these demographic groups, underscoring the complex interplay between societal structures and suicide.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Suicide is a significant global public health issue, and while its connection to social factors is recognized, a comprehensive understanding of these "social determinants of health" (SDOH) in relation to suicide remains limited. This is partly due to data limitations and the lack of a unified framework to analyze these complex relationships. Previous studies have often relied on self-reported data or smaller sample sizes, potentially leading to incomplete or less generalizable findings. This paper aims to bridge this gap by applying the World Health Organization's Commission on Social Determinants of Health (CSDH) conceptual framework to a large, national dataset of completed suicides in South Korea, providing a more robust analysis of how structural factors influence suicide outcomes.

Methods

The study employed a quantitative, cross-sectional design. The core methodology involved linking a national-level suicide registry from the Korea Psychological Autopsy Center with the CSDH conceptual framework. This framework categorizes determinants of health into social-economic and political context, structural determinants, and intermediary determinants. For this study, the researchers focused on three key structural determinants: gender, social class (operationalized by employment status), and occupation. These were then analyzed in relation to four suicide outcomes: type of suicide (individual, joint, murder-suicide), place of death, suicide method, and warning signs. Statistical analysis was performed to identify associations between these variables.

Datasets

The primary dataset used was the national suicide registry from the Korea Psychological Autopsy Center. This registry contains data on 67,331 completed suicides in South Korea between 2013 and 2017, compiled in collaboration with police stations and trained investigators. The data includes over 30 individual-level variables grouped into four categories, as detailed in Table 1 of the paper. This dataset is noted as the most recent, detailed, and complete available for this type of analysis in South Korea.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structural Determinants Matter: The study strongly reinforces the idea that societal structures, not just individual psychology, play a crucial role in suicide. Gender, social class, and occupation are not merely background factors but actively shape how and why individuals die by suicide.
  • Gendered Patterns: There are clear gendered differences in suicide. Men are more prevalent in murder-suicides and tend to use more lethal methods like fire and transportation, while women show higher rates in joint suicides and prefer less lethal methods like drug overdose and jumping from heights.
  • Social Class as a Proxy for Vulnerability: Employment status (social class) reveals distinct patterns. For instance, "other economically inactive" individuals (often elderly or with disabilities) are overrepresented in individual suicides, while employees are more common in murder-suicides. This highlights how different socioeconomic positions are associated with different suicide typologies.
  • Occupation Shapes Method: The type of occupation appears to influence the chosen suicide method. Blue-collar workers in physically demanding jobs (e.g., mechanics, laborers) are more likely to use methods involving tools or physical force, while professionals with higher education may opt for less immediately violent methods like drug overdose.
  • Warning Signs are Not Universal: While verbal and mood-related signs are common across the board, their prevalence and specific nature can vary by social class and occupation, suggesting that tailored approaches to recognizing warning signs might be necessary.

Key Results

  • Gender: Male victims outnumbered female victims across all suicide types, places of death, and methods. Men were disproportionately represented in murder-suicides, while women were more represented in joint suicides.
  • Social Class (Employment Status): "Other economically inactive" and unemployed individuals constituted the largest proportion of individual suicides. Employees and housemakers were more prevalent in murder-suicides. Students and unemployed individuals showed higher percentages in joint suicides.
  • Occupation: Laborers and salespeople were the most common individual suicide victims. Service industry workers and those in illegal businesses were more represented in joint suicides. Mechanics and laborers were more represented in murder-suicides.
  • Suicide Methods: Hanging was the most frequent method overall, except for students and soldiers. Men were more likely to use violent methods like fire and transportation, while women preferred drug overdose and jumping from heights. Pesticides were more frequently used by primary industries workers, while drug overdoses and jumping from heights were more common among professionals and laborers.
  • Warning Signs: Male victims frequently showed verbal, mood, and behavioral signs, with verbal signs being most common. Female victims most often exhibited mood-related signs, particularly depression. Unemployed individuals, students, and housemakers showed mood-related signs more frequently, while other social classes leaned towards verbal signs.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study is descriptive and cannot establish causal relationships between structural determinants and suicide outcomes. The study also had limitations in the variables available from the national suicide data, meaning only partial social determinants were explored. Due to the lack of comparable large-scale national suicide data from other countries, direct comparisons to test generalizability were not possible.

Future work should investigate the intermediary determinants (material, psychosocial, and behavioral circumstances) to more thoroughly understand the mechanisms through which structural determinants impact suicide. Further research could also explore how these findings might generalize to other populations and contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

A clear connection exists between the investigated structural factors and various suicide outcomes, with gender, social class, and occupation all impacting suicide.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2022linking,
  author = {Yongjun Zhu and Seojin Nam and Lihong Quan and Jihyun Baek and Hong Jin Jeon and Buzhou Tang},
  title = {{Linking suicide and social determinants of health in South Korea: An investigation of structural determinants}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2022.1022790},
}
Figure