Linking Multiscalar Fisheries Using Metacoupling Models

Andrew K. Carlson, Daniel I. Rubenstein, Simon A. LevinFrontiers in Marine Science 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces and applies the "metacoupling framework" to quantitatively model the complex, multiscalar interactions within and between different types of fisheries (local, adjacent, and distant). By analyzing 65 years of catch data for mahi-mahi, tuna, and cod, the study reveals how these interactions differentially impact fish stocks and human livelihoods, highlighting the need for integrated management strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Marine fisheries are critical for global food security, livelihoods, and economies, but they are embedded within intricate social-ecological systems. Traditional research often focuses on single fisheries or limited spatial scales, failing to capture the complex web of interactions that span local, adjacent, and distant fishing activities. These "metacouplings" – human-nature interactions occurring at multiple scales – are crucial because demand in one region can drive fishing pressure in another, impacting local communities and ecosystems in ways that are not immediately apparent. The challenge is to understand and quantify these multiscalar linkages to inform effective, sustainable fisheries management.

Methods

The authors developed and applied the metacoupling framework, which extends the concept of telecoupling by explicitly accounting for interactions within local systems (Type 1), between adjacent systems (Type 2), and between distant systems (Type 3). They used time series analysis, specifically Autoregressive Integrated Moving Average (ARIMA) models, to:

  • Characterize metacouplings: Quantify historical catch data (1950-2014) for different fishing types (artisanal, subsistence, industrial, recreational) across these three spatial scales.
  • Model cross-scalar interactions: Assess how catches of one fishing type influence catches of others, considering both positive and negative relationships.
  • Predict future catches: Project catch trends for each fishing type and taxon up to 2030.

A key methodological innovation is the use of ARIMA models with external regressors to explicitly model the influence of one fishing type on another, allowing for a quantitative understanding of these multiscalar dependencies. Model performance was validated using MASE and NRMSE metrics.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is from the Sea Around Us project (Pauly et al., 2020). This database is crucial because it reconstructs fisheries catch data for the world's 280 Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZs) from 1950 to 2014, aiming to overcome the underestimation issues common in official FAO data by incorporating artisanal, subsistence, recreational, and discarded catches. The data were organized by nation, EEZ, and fishing sector.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Local: The Pervasive Influence of Distant Fishing: While most catches (75%) occur within a nation's own EEZ (Type 1), catches in adjacent (Type 2) and distant (Type 3) EEZs and the high seas are substantial (25% combined) and have become increasingly important, especially for tuna and cod since 1980. This highlights that local fisheries are deeply intertwined with global fishing activities.
  • Differential Impacts Across Species and Sectors: The study reveals that metacouplings don't affect all fisheries equally. For mahi-mahi, interactions are largely positive, leading to increased catches across sectors. In contrast, tuna and cod fisheries experience more inhibitory interactions, where industrial fishing can negatively impact artisanal and subsistence catches.
  • Metacoupling Structure and Conservation: The study found a correlation between the structure of metacoupling interactions and extinction risk. Fisheries with more positive and fewer negative interactions tend to have lower extinction risks, suggesting that synergistic fishing practices can contribute to stock resilience.
  • Predictive Power of Metacoupling Models: The ARIMA models successfully predicted future catch trends, offering valuable insights for proactive management, even though these predictions often mirrored historical trends with some important nuances (e.g., projected declines in cod subsistence catches).

Key Results

  • Catch Distribution: Over 65 years (1950-2014), 75% of catches were Type 1 (within own EEZ), while Type 2 (adjacent EEZ) accounted for 1.0 MMT and Type 3 (distant EEZ/high seas) for 1.9 MMT.
  • Tuna and Cod Shift: Catches in adjacent and distant EEZs became consistently important for tuna and cod after 1980.
  • Negative Interactions:
    • Tuna artisanal/subsistence catches decreased with increasing Type 2/3 industrial fishing.
  • Cod subsistence catches declined with increasing Type 2/3 industrial fishing and Type 1 artisanal fishing.
  • Positive Interactions: Mahi-mahi fishing types generally showed positive interactions, leading to increased catches across sectors.
  • Extinction Risk Correlation: Extinction risk decreased as fishing-type interactions became more positive and less negative.
  • Catch Trends: Total catches in 1950-2014 increased with stronger, more positive fishing-type interactions and declined with more negative interactions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that data availability and quality vary significantly across EEZs and fishing sectors. Recreational and subsistence catch data are often the least available and most prone to bias, necessitating robust catch reconstruction methods like those used by the Sea Around Us.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Expanding to other species: Applying the metacoupling framework to a wider range of commercially and ecologically important species.
  • Incorporating end-use: Analyzing how different end uses of fish (direct consumption, fishmeal, etc.) influence metacouplings.
  • Trade analysis: Investigating the role of international trade as a critical metacoupling research area.
  • Advanced modeling: Utilizing network analysis and agent-based modeling to deepen understanding and management of fisheries metacouplings.
  • Policy and Governance: Developing decision-support tools and governance frameworks that explicitly incorporate metacoupling insights to optimize fisheries' contributions to food supply, employment, and biodiversity.
  • Public Outreach: Using metacoupling as a concept to connect people to the origins of their food and promote sustainable choices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Marine fisheries are social-ecological systems important for human health and livelihoods. However, research approaches that consider human–nature interactions within as well as between adjacent and distant fisheries are scarce. As such, we measured and modeled marine fisheries catches at local and regional scales over 65 years (1950–2014), assessed cross-scalar interactions among fishing types (artisanal, subsistence, industrial, recreational), and predicted future catches using the metacoupling framework, a new approach for evaluating human-nature interactions within and across adjacent and distant fisheries (metacouplings). Across taxa examined (mahi-mahi [Coryphaena hippurus], Atlantic bluefin tuna [Thunnus thynnus], cods [Gadidae]), 75% of catches (8.5 million metric tons [MMT]) were made by nations in their own exclusive economic zones (EEZs; Type 1 fishing). However, catches in adjacent EEZs (Type 2 fishing, 1.0 MMT) and distant EEZs and the high seas (Type 3 fishing, 1.9 MMT) increased substantially for all taxa at certain times, becoming consistently important for tuna and cods after 1980. Moreover, Types 1–3 fishing interacted in ways that affect humans differentially across fisheries. For instance, tuna artisanal and subsistence catches (Type 1) decreased with increasing Type 2 and Type 3 industrial fishing, respectively. Cod subsistence catches declined with increasing Type 2/3 industrial fishing and Type 1 artisanal fishing, whereas fishing-type interactions were largely positive for mahi-mahi, causing catches to increase across sectors. Overall, metacouplings affect humans in positive and negative ways that vary across scales and fisheries systems, galvanizing the need for metacoupling-informed fisheries research, policy, and management programs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{carlson2020linking,
  author = {Andrew K. Carlson and Daniel I. Rubenstein and Simon A. Levin},
  title = {{Linking Multiscalar Fisheries Using Metacoupling Models}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2020.00614},
}

Loading related content...

Figure