Linkage Mapping and Comparative Transcriptome Analysis of Firmness in Watermelon (Citrullus lanatus)

Lei Sun, Yushu Zhang, Haonan Cui, Lupeng Zhang, Tongyun Sha, Chaonan Wang, Chao Fan, Feishi Luan, Xuezheng WangFrontiers in Plant Science 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies key genetic regions and candidate genes associated with watermelon flesh firmness by combining linkage mapping and comparative transcriptomics. The findings pinpoint specific chromosomal locations and potential regulatory genes that influence cell wall structure and hormone levels, offering valuable insights for breeding firmer watermelon varieties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Watermelon flesh firmness is a crucial trait for consumer appeal, impacting texture, shelf-life, and overall quality. However, this trait is complex, controlled by multiple genes, making it challenging to improve through traditional breeding. Understanding the genetic underpinnings of flesh firmness, particularly the key regulatory factors, is essential for developing new watermelon varieties with desirable textures. This paper aims to bridge this gap by identifying the genomic regions and candidate genes responsible for variations in watermelon flesh firmness.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Bulked Segregant Analysis (BSA)-Seq: This technique was used to identify genomic regions associated with flesh firmness. DNA from individual watermelon plants with extreme firmness phenotypes (very hard vs. very soft) was pooled (bulked) and then sequenced. By comparing the DNA sequences of these bulks, researchers could pinpoint chromosomal regions that differed significantly between the hard and soft lines, suggesting the presence of genes controlling firmness.
  • Linkage Mapping: Using molecular markers (specifically CAPS markers derived from SNP data), the study constructed a genetic linkage map of the watermelon genome. This map helps to visualize the relative positions of genes and markers on chromosomes, allowing for the precise localization of quantitative trait loci (QTLs) associated with flesh firmness.
  • Comparative Transcriptome Analysis (RNA-Seq): This method involved sequencing the RNA from watermelon flesh at different developmental stages in both the hard and soft parent lines. By comparing gene expression profiles, the researchers identified genes that were differentially expressed between the two varieties, providing clues about their roles in firmness.
  • Physicochemical and Cellular Analysis: The study also measured cell wall components (cellulose, protopectin, hemicellulose) and key hormones (IAA, ABA) in the fruit flesh. Additionally, paraffin sections were used to examine the cellular structure of the flesh, providing a visual understanding of differences in cell size, arrangement, and wall thickness.

Datasets

The study utilized an F2 population derived from a cross between a hard-flesh egusi seed watermelon (PI186490) and a soft-flesh cultivated watermelon (W1-1). This population served as the basis for phenotypic data collection and genetic analysis. RNA-Seq data was generated from 18 cDNA libraries (three biological replicates for each parent at three developmental stages). The raw sequencing reads were deposited in the NCBI Short Read Archive (SRA) under accession number PRJNA477364.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Firmness is a complex trait with major gene influence: The continuous distribution of flesh hardness in the F2 population, coupled with the identification of specific chromosomal regions, indicates that while multiple genes are involved, some major genes play a significant role in determining watermelon flesh firmness.
  • Cell wall components are key players: The study found strong correlations between flesh firmness and the content of cellulose, protopectin, and hemicellulose. The hard-flesh variety (PI186490) consistently had higher levels of these cell wall components, suggesting their direct impact on structural integrity and firmness.
  • Hormonal influence is nuanced: While IAA and ABA are known to be involved in fruit ripening and texture, their role in the observed firmness differences between the two varieties was less clear-cut. IAA levels decreased with ripening in both, and ABA levels, while higher in the soft-flesh variety, didn't show a direct correlation with the firmness trend.
  • Cellular structure dictates firmness: Microscopic examination revealed that the hard-flesh variety had more numerous, tightly packed cells with thicker cell walls and clearer edges, directly contributing to its firmer texture.
  • Candidate genes identified: The study pinpointed specific candidate genes within the mapped chromosomal intervals. Notably, Cla016033 (a DUF579 family member) and Cla012507 (a MADS-box transcription factor) are highlighted as potentially crucial regulators of flesh firmness, influencing cell wall integrity and fruit ripening, respectively.

Key Results

  • QTL Localization: Major genes controlling center flesh firmness were delimited to physical intervals on chromosome 2 (6,210,787–7,742,559 bp) and chromosome 8 (207,553–403,137 bp).
  • Cell Wall Component Correlation: Flesh firmness showed a significant positive correlation with cellulose (0.763), protopectin (0.787), and hemicellulose (0.598).
  • Hormone Correlation: Flesh firmness was negatively correlated with IAA (-0.444) and ABA (-0.459).
  • Transcriptome Analysis: Comparative transcriptome analysis identified 11,405 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between W1-1 and PI186490. Of these, 160 genes were significantly differentially expressed across three developmental stages and are considered potential key regulators of flesh hardness.
  • Candidate Gene Expression: Cla016033 showed differential expression patterns related to fruit maturation and firmness, with an insertion in its promoter region in the hard-flesh variety. Cla012507 (MADS-box) also showed differential expression, with higher expression in the hard-flesh variety.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Candidate Gene Validation: While candidate genes were identified, further functional validation is needed to definitively confirm their roles in flesh firmness. This could involve gene editing or overexpression studies.
  • Complex Interaction: The study acknowledges that flesh firmness is a complex trait influenced by multiple genes and environmental factors. Future work could explore the interactions between identified genes and other regulatory pathways.
  • Breeding Applications: The identified QTLs and candidate genes provide a strong foundation for marker-assisted selection in watermelon breeding programs aimed at improving flesh firmness.
  • Broader Genetic Diversity: The study focused on two specific watermelon lines. Investigating a wider range of genetic diversity could reveal additional genes and pathways involved in firmness.

Summary updated

Abstract

Watermelon fruit texture and quality are determined by flesh firmness. As a quality trait, flesh firmness is controlled by multigenes. Defining the key regulatory factors of watermelon flesh firmness is of great significance for watermelon genetic breeding. In this study, the hard-flesh egusi seed watermelon PI186490 was used as the male parent, the soft-flesh cultivated watermelon W1-1 was used as the female parent, and 175 F<sub>2</sub> generations were obtained from selfing F<sub>1</sub>. Primary mapping of the major genes controlling center flesh firmness was achieved by bulked-segregant analysis (BSA)-Seq analysis and molecular marker technology. Finally, major genes were delimited in the physical interval between 6,210,787 and 7,742,559 bp on chromosome 2 and between 207,553 and 403,137 bp on chromosome 8. The content of each cell wall component and hormone was measured, and comparative transcriptome analysis was performed during fruit development in watermelon. The protopectin, cellulose, hemicellulose, indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and abscisic acid (ABA) contents were measured, and paraffin sections were made during the three fruit developmental stages. The results revealed that protopectin, celluloses, and hemicelluloses exhibited similar trends for flesh firmness, while the IAA and ABA concentrations continued to decrease with fruit ripening. Paraffin sections showed that PI186490 cells were more numerous, were more tightly packed, had clearer cell wall edges and had thicker cell walls than W1-1 cells at every developmental stage. Comparative transcriptome analysis was conducted on RNA samples of flesh during fruit development and ripening in W1-1 and PI186490. The results from the localization interval transcriptome analysis showed that Cla016033 (DUF579 family member), which may influence the cell wall component contents to adjust the flesh firmness in watermelon fruit, was different in W1-1 and PI186490 and that Cla012507 (MADS-box transcription factor) may be involved in the regulation of fruit ripening and affect the hardness of watermelon fruit.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2020linkage,
  author = {Lei Sun and Yushu Zhang and Haonan Cui and Lupeng Zhang and Tongyun Sha and Chaonan Wang and Chao Fan and Feishi Luan and Xuezheng Wang},
  title = {{Linkage Mapping and Comparative Transcriptome Analysis of Firmness in Watermelon (Citrullus lanatus)}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2020.00831},
}
Figure