Lingering effects of contraception management on feral mare (Equus caballus) fertility and social behavior

Cassandra M.v. Nuñez, James S. Adelman, Haley A Carr, Colleen M Alvarez, Daniel I. RubensteinConservation 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the long-term impacts of PZP contraception on feral horse fertility and social behavior after the program was suspended. It reveals that while PZP can cause lingering subfertility and behavioral changes, the intensity of treatment matters: mares receiving fewer PZP applications recover fertility and social stability more effectively than those receiving many.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Feral horse populations in the US have grown due to the absence of natural predators, leading to management challenges. One common management tool is immunocontraception using Porcine Zona Pellucida (PZP) to prevent pregnancy. While PZP is effective at reducing fertility, there's a concern about its potential long-term physiological and behavioral side effects on the treated animals, especially after the contraception program ends. Previous research hinted at issues like extended estrous cycling and decreased fidelity to social groups, but the lasting impact and how treatment intensity influences recovery remained largely unexplored. This paper aims to fill that gap by examining how feral mares on Shackleford Banks, NC, recover their fertility and social behavior after PZP treatment is suspended, specifically looking at the influence of the number of PZP applications received.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of field observations and statistical modeling. They monitored foaling rates and dates from 2009 to 2014, a period when the contraception program was largely suspended. Fecal samples were used for pregnancy testing, and foaling records were tracked. Behavioral observations, including group changes and reproductive interactions, were conducted in 2013 and 2015.

Key statistical methods included:

  • Linear Mixed-Effects Models (LMMs): Used to analyze birth rates and foaling dates, accounting for individual mare variation and temporal effects.
  • Generalized Linear Mixed Models (GLMMs): Applied to analyze foaling probability, considering factors like mare age and contraception history.
  • Poisson Regression: Used for analyzing behavioral data like group changes, which are count-based.

The study also incorporated time since last treatment as a crucial variable, particularly for mares that had received PZP. They analyzed data using both raw and arcsine-square root transformed formats to address potential issues with normality and variance.

Datasets

The study utilized long-term data collected on the feral horse population of Shackleford Banks, North Carolina. This included:

  • Foaling records: Data on foaling dates and pregnancy status from 2000 onwards, with specific focus on 2009-2014 for this study.
  • Contraception histories: Records of individual mares' PZP treatment status, including the number of applications received.
  • Behavioral observations: Data on group transfers and reproductive behaviors collected during the summers of 2013 and 2015.

No new datasets were introduced; the study relied on existing long-term monitoring data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Treatment Intensity Matters: The most significant takeaway is that the number of PZP applications directly influences a mare's ability to recover fertility and social stability. Less intensive treatment (1-3 applications) leads to a much better recovery than more intensive treatment (4+ applications).
  • Lingering Subfertility is Real: Even after the contraception program stopped, mares that had received PZP were less likely to foal than untreated mares. This isn't a quick fix; the effects can persist.
  • Behavioral Echoes: Mares that received many PZP treatments continued to change groups more frequently, indicating a lasting impact on their social fidelity, even when fertility recovery was slow.
  • Foaling Dates Shift: Treated mares consistently foaled later in the year, suggesting a potential link to changes in body condition often associated with PZP.
  • Adaptive Management Compromised: The prolonged subfertility, especially from intensive treatment, can hinder adaptive population management, making it harder for populations to rebound if needed.

Key Results

  • Foaling Probability: Mares receiving any level of PZP treatment were less likely to foal than untreated mares.
  • Mares with 1-3 PZP applications showed an initial increase in foaling probability with time since last treatment, peaking around 6 years post-treatment, before declining.
  • Mares with 4+ PZP applications did not show a significant increase in foaling probability, even years after treatment.
  • Foaling Dates: Mares previously treated with PZP (both 1-3 and 4+ applications) gave birth later in the year compared to untreated mares.
  • Group Changes: Mares that received 4+ PZP treatments changed groups more often than untreated mares. Mares with 1-3 treatments did not differ significantly from untreated mares in this regard.
  • Reproductive Behavior: No significant difference in reproductive behavior was observed between treated and untreated mares.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Foal Survival: The study acknowledges that assessing foal survival was complicated by the removal of horses from the island for adoption, making it difficult to draw firm conclusions on this aspect.
  • Harassment Definition: The authors note that comparing "harassment" data from previous studies to their definition of reproductive behavior is limited, making direct comparisons challenging.
  • Future Work: The paper strongly suggests the need for careful consideration of treatment frequency to maintain more natural physiological and social dynamics. They advocate for monitoring individual treatment histories or modeling the probability of multiple treatments to enable more flexible and effective population management. The findings also highlight the importance of understanding the link between physiological changes and behavioral outcomes in management programs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to the extirpation of their natural predators, feral horse populations have expanded across the United States, necessitating their management. Contraception of females (mares) with porcine zona pellucida (PZP) is a popular option; however, effects to physiology and behavior can be substantial. On Shackleford Banks, North Carolina, USA, treated mares have exhibited cycling during the non-breeding season and demonstrated decreased fidelity to the band stallion, but PZP's long-term effects on mare physiology and behavior remain largely unexplored. After the contraception program was suspended in this population, we examined how prior exposure to varying levels of PZP treatment impacted (1) foaling probability and foaling dates (a proxy for ovulatory cycling) from 2009 to 2014 and (2) mare fidelity to the band stallion and reproductive behavior during 2013 and 2015. Additionally, we evaluated the effects of time since the mares' last treatment on these factors. Mares receiving any level of prior PZP treatment were less likely to foal than were untreated mares. Among mares that received 1-3 PZP applications, foaling probability increased with time since last treatment before declining, at ~6 years post-treatment. Mares that received 4+ applications did not exhibit a significant increase in foaling probability with time since last treatment. Moreover, previously treated mares continued to conceive later than did untreated mares. Finally, mares previously receiving 4+ treatments changed groups more often than did untreated mares, though reproductive behavior did not differ with contraception history. Our results suggest that although PZP-induced subfertility and its associated behavioral effects can persist after the cessation of treatment, these effects can be ameliorated for some factors with less intense treatment. Careful consideration to the frequency of PZP treatment is important to maintaining more naturally functioning populations; the ability to manage populations adaptively may be compromised if females are kept subfertile for extended periods of time.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nunez2017lingering,
  author = {Cassandra M.V. Nuñez and James S. Adelman and Haley A Carr and Colleen M Alvarez and Daniel I. Rubenstein},
  title = {{Lingering effects of contraception management on feral mare (Equus caballus) fertility and social behavior}},
  booktitle = {Conservation},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1093/conphys/cox018},
}
Figure