Linear Predictive Approaches Separate Field Potentials in Animal Model of Parkinson's Disease

Md Fahim Anjum, Joshua Haug, Stephanie L. Alberico, Soura Dasgupta, Raghuraman Mudumbai, Morgan Kennedy, Nandakumar S. NarayananFrontiers in Neuroscience 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Linear Predictive Coding (LPC) as a computationally efficient method to analyze brain activity in an animal model of Parkinson's Disease (PD). A single LPC parameter, derived from just one minute of local field potential (LFP) data, can reliably distinguish between PD mice treated with levodopa (a PD medication) and those treated with a placebo, paving the way for real-time adaptive deep brain stimulation (aDBS).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Parkinson's Disease (PD) is a neurodegenerative disorder characterized by impaired movement and cognitive function, largely due to the loss of dopamine-producing neurons. This loss leads to abnormal electrical activity in the brain, particularly in areas like the cerebral cortex and basal ganglia, which can be measured using electroencephalography (EEG) or local field potentials (LFPs). Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) is a common treatment for PD, but current methods often involve manually adjusting stimulation parameters infrequently.

The next generation of DBS, known as adaptive DBS (aDBS), aims to dynamically adjust stimulation in real-time based on the patient's brain activity. However, a major challenge for aDBS is the need for algorithms that can quickly and efficiently identify specific brain signals that indicate the patient's state (e.g., response to medication) in real-time. Existing methods, while effective, can be computationally intensive, require significant processing power, and may not always provide the necessary speed or simplicity for real-time application. This paper addresses this gap by proposing a novel, computationally efficient approach using Linear Predictive Coding (LPC) to identify PD-related neural signals for potential use in aDBS.

Methods

The core of this paper's methodology lies in the application of Linear Predictive Coding (LPC). LPC is a signal processing technique that models a time-series signal as an autoregressive (AR) process. Essentially, it tries to predict the next sample of a signal based on a linear combination of previous samples. The coefficients of this AR model (the LPC coefficients) capture important characteristics of the signal's dynamics.

The authors specifically focus on:

  • First-order LPC: This involves a single LPC parameter (a¹), which is computationally very simple and fast to calculate.
  • Second-order LPC: This uses two parameters (a¹ and a²) or, more interpretably, the poles (p1, p2) of the AR model's transfer function. The phase of these poles can indicate dominant frequencies in the signal.

The process involved:

  1. Implantation and Lesioning: A rodent model of PD was created by unilaterally depleting dopamine in the striatum using 6-OHDA. Control animals received a sham injection.
  2. LFP Recording: Local Field Potentials (LFPs) were recorded from the dorsal striatum of both PD and control mice using a multi-electrode array. Recordings were taken after saline injection (control) and after levodopa injection (treatment).
  3. Signal Processing: Raw LFP signals were filtered (2.5-50 Hz bandpass) and normalized to unit power. For each mouse, LFP recordings from four channels were averaged into a single time-series.
  4. Feature Extraction: LPC coefficients (primarily first-order) were calculated from these time-series. The authors explored different window lengths for LPC calculation, including full-length sessions (40 minutes), segmented epochs (1, 3, 10, 40 minutes), and an expanding time-window to simulate real-time processing.
  5. Comparison: The performance of their LPC-based approach was compared against established methods like Power Spectral Density (PSD) analysis (specifically beta-power) and Phase-Amplitude Coupling (PAC) analysis.

Datasets

The study utilized LFP data collected from a total of eight male C57/B6 wild-type mice.

  • Four mice were subjected to unilateral 6-OHDA injection to create a dopamine-depleted model of Parkinson's Disease.
  • Four control mice received a sham injection (ascorbic acid).

For each mouse, LFP recordings were obtained under two conditions:

  • Saline injection: Serving as a baseline or control condition for the PD model.
  • Levodopa injection: Representing the treatment condition for the PD model.

The data was collected at a sampling rate of 1 kHz. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses data from their experimental setup for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Simplicity is Powerful: The most striking insight is that a single, first-order LPC coefficient, derived from just a minute of LFP data, is sufficient to distinguish between levodopa-treated and saline-treated PD mice. This highlights that complex neural signals can sometimes be characterized by surprisingly simple metrics.
  • Real-time Potential: The ability to update LPC coefficients with an expanding time window, requiring only a short duration (e.g., 1 minute) of data, strongly suggests the feasibility of real-time application for adaptive DBS.
  • Levodopa's Specific Effect: The LPC method effectively differentiates between levodopa treatment and placebo only in dopamine-depleted mice. In healthy control mice, levodopa treatment did not significantly alter the LPC coefficients, indicating that the method is detecting the benefit of levodopa in restoring dopaminergic function, rather than just the presence of the drug.
  • Second-order LPC Offers Little Advantage: While second-order LPC (using poles) can provide information about dominant frequencies, it did not offer significantly better separation between conditions compared to the simpler first-order LPC. This reinforces the value of the first-order approach due to its computational efficiency.
  • Computational Efficiency: The LPC approach demonstrated significantly faster computation times compared to established methods like PAC and beta-power analysis, making it a strong candidate for resource-constrained applications like implanted DBS devices.

Key Results

  • High Discrimination Accuracy: A single first-order LPC parameter, calculated from just 1 minute of LFP data, could distinguish between levodopa-treated and saline-treated dopamine-depleted mice.
  • Outperforms Existing Methods: The LPC-based approach showed statistically significant separation (p < 0.05) for both 40-minute and 3-minute epochs, outperforming PAC and beta-power methods in some cases, especially for longer epochs.
  • Rapid Convergence: For the expanding time-window analysis, LPC coefficients converged within 1 minute for most mice, indicating that a short recording period is sufficient for reliable estimation.
  • Computational Speed: The LPC-based approach was approximately 5 times faster than the next fastest established method (de Hemptinne et al., 2013) for 3-minute epochs, with a total computation time of 1.1 seconds.
  • No Effect in Healthy Controls: In healthy mice without dopamine depletion, first-order LPC coefficients did not show significant differences between saline and levodopa treatments.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Animal Model Limitations: The authors acknowledge that human PD is more complex than the animal model used. Features like resting tremor and freezing-of-gait are not perfectly replicated in rodents, and future work may need to extend to primate or human models.
  • Levodopa-Induced Dyskinesias (LIDs): The study notes that levodopa can induce dyskinesias in PD models, and their LPC metrics might be affected by these LIDs. Future work could develop LPC metrics to specifically differentiate LIDs or other aspects of striatal LFPs.
  • Cause vs. Consequence: It's unclear whether the LFP differences captured by LPC are a cause or a consequence of motor changes induced by levodopa. However, the authors argue that LPC-based analyses can still be useful for reflecting the dopaminergic state and triggering aDBS.
  • Future Work:
    • Human Application: Extending LPC analysis to human EEG data for PD detection.
  • Primate/Human Models: Investigating LPC in more complex models to capture a wider range of PD symptoms.
  • Differentiating Brain States: Exploring if LPC values can reflect distinct brain states between dopamine-depleted mice (saline/levodopa) and healthy controls.
  • Real-time aDBS Integration: Developing aDBS systems that use LPC parameters as control signals to adjust stimulation, aiming to bring LPC parameters closer to those observed in levodopa-treated or healthy states.
  • Higher Sampling Rates: Investigating if higher LFP sampling rates (beyond 1 kHz) could lead to faster convergence, though the biological phenomenon might not manifest faster.
  • Single Unit Recordings: Exploring if single-unit recordings could provide additional detail beyond LFPs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Parkinson's disease (PD) causes impaired movement and cognition. PD can involve profound changes in cortical and subcortical brain activity as measured by electroencephalography or intracranial recordings of local field potentials (LFP). Such signals can adaptively guide deep-brain stimulation (DBS) as part of PD therapy. However, adaptive DBS requires the identification of triggers of neuronal activity dependent on real time monitoring and analysis. Current methods do not always identify PD-related signals and can entail delays. We test an alternative approach based on linear predictive coding (LPC), which fits autoregressive (AR) models to time-series data. Parameters of these AR models can be calculated by fast algorithms in real time. We compare LFPs from the striatum in an animal model of PD with dopamine depletion in the absence and presence of the dopamine precursor levodopa, which is used to treat motor symptoms of PD. We show that in dopamine-depleted mice a first order AR model characterized by a single LPC parameter obtained by LFP sampling at 1 kHz for just 1 min can distinguish between levodopa-treated and saline-treated mice and outperform current methods. This suggests that LPC may be useful in online analysis of neuronal signals to guide DBS in real time and could contribute to DBS-based treatment of PD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{anjum2020linear,
  author = {Md Fahim Anjum and Joshua Haug and Stephanie L. Alberico and Soura Dasgupta and Raghuraman Mudumbai and Morgan Kennedy and Nandakumar S. Narayanan},
  title = {{Linear Predictive Approaches Separate Field Potentials in Animal Model of Parkinson's Disease}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2020.00394},
}
Figure