Limiting motor skill knowledge via incidental training protects against choking under pressure

Taraz G. Lee, Daniel E. Acuña, Konrad P. Körding, Scott T. GraftonPsychonomic 2018 · DOI

Introduction

"Choking under pressure" is a well-documented phenomenon where performance declines despite high motivation and stakes. Researchers have proposed several theories to explain this paradox: the Distraction theory (worries exhaust working memory), the Explicit Monitoring theory (conscious attention disrupts automaticity), and the Overmotivation theory (arousal triggers competing Pavlovian responses). This study investigates whether the method of learning a motor skill—specifically, the amount of explicit knowledge acquired—determines a performer's susceptibility to choking.

Methods

The researchers employed a Discrete Sequence Production (DSP) task across two experiments. Participants were required to type 8-item sequences on a keyboard under different training conditions.

  • Training Groups: Participants were divided into an Instructed group, who received color-coded preparatory cues to plan sequences, and an Incidental group, who reacted to stimuli without preparatory cues.
  • Training Depth: Sequences were trained at three levels of intensity: Deep (192 trials), Moderate (96 trials), and Shallow (32 trials).
  • Pressure Testing: Following training, participants performed the task with varying monetary incentives ($5, $10, or $20) for success. Strict time limits were enforced to ensure accuracy was the primary variable of interest.
Experimental design for Instructed and Incidental training conditions.

To analyze the underlying motor structure, the authors utilized a Bayesian algorithm to estimate "chunking" (the grouping of keypresses into fluid units), providing a measure of movement stability and proceduralization.

Results and Key Insights

Learning Curves and Speed

As shown in the training data, both groups improved their movement times (MTs) over eight blocks of training. Instructed participants generally achieved faster movement times than Incidental participants, demonstrating that explicit planning and preparatory cues provide a significant speed advantage during acquisition. Furthermore, the depth of training significantly impacted speed, with "Deeply" trained sequences being performed faster than "Shallowly" trained ones.

Movement times across training blocks for different levels of training depth in both Instructed and Incidental groups.

The Vulnerability of Explicit Knowledge

The most critical finding was the interaction between training type and incentive level ($p = .013$). The Instructed group followed a classic inverted-U performance curve: accuracy improved as incentives rose from $5 to $10 but collapsed significantly at the $20 level ($p = .046$). In contrast, the **Incidental group** remained "immune" to pressure, showing stable accuracy across all incentive levels ($p = .850$).

Memory tests confirmed that Instructed participants possessed significantly higher explicit awareness of the sequences ($p < .001$). Interestingly, expertise did not offer protection; deeply trained sequences in the Instructed group were just as prone to choking as shallowly trained ones. Bayesian analysis suggested that pressure disrupts the stable "motor chunks" developed by Instructed learners, leading to increased movement variability.

Discussion and Future Directions

This research suggests that the explicit knowledge used to speed up performance during training becomes a liability under high-pressure conditions. By limiting a performer's explicit awareness through incidental training, the motor skill becomes more robust against the interference caused by high incentives.

While the study is limited by its laboratory setting and short-term training duration, the implications for high-stakes environments are profound. Future work should explore whether training strategies that minimize conscious awareness—such as errorless or analogy-based learning—can be effectively implemented for athletes, surgeons, and other professionals who must perform reliably under extreme pressure.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2018limiting,
  author = {Taraz G. Lee and Daniel E. Acuña and Konrad P. Körding and Scott T. Grafton},
  title = {{Limiting motor skill knowledge via incidental training protects against choking under pressure}},
  booktitle = {Psychonomic},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3758/s13423-018-1486-x},
}
Figure