Limited specificity of molecular interactions incurs an environment-dependent fitness cost in bacteria

Claudia Igler, Claire Fourcade, Torsten Waldminghaus, Florian M. Pauler, Balaji Santhanam, Gašper Tkačik, Călin C. GuetbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that transcription factors (TFs) binding to DNA with low specificity, even at non-target sites, can impose significant fitness costs on bacteria. This "molecular crosstalk" is a fundamental constraint on gene regulation, influencing bacterial evolution and the design of synthetic biological systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cells rely on highly specific molecular interactions to function correctly. In gene regulation, transcription factors (TFs) are crucial for controlling gene expression by binding to specific DNA sequences. However, genomes are vast, and TFs can encounter numerous DNA sequences that resemble their target sites but are not their intended targets. These "non-cognate" interactions, whether due to weak binding to similar motifs or non-specific DNA binding, have been poorly understood in terms of their impact on cellular fitness. This paper investigates whether and how this low-specificity binding of TFs to non-cognate DNA sites affects bacterial growth and survival, and what mechanisms contribute to this effect.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Bacterial Growth Assays: They expressed various phage repressors (λ CI, 434 CI, HK022 CI, P22 C2) and a bacterial repressor (Lacl) in E. coli and S. enterica under different environmental conditions (media types, inducer concentrations, induction timing) to measure their impact on growth rates.
  • Competition Assays: To quantify fitness effects more precisely, they performed direct competition experiments between cells expressing repressors and control cells, using fluorescence as a proxy for relative abundance.
  • Mutagenesis and Chimeric Proteins: They created mutants of λ CI defective in DNA binding, dimerization, or cooperativity, as well as chimeric proteins combining the DNA-binding domain of one repressor with the cooperative binding domain of another. This helped dissect the roles of different TF properties.
  • ChIP-sequencing (ChIP-seq): This technique was used to map the genomic locations where λ CI binds in E. coli and S. enterica, revealing the extent and distribution of non-cognate binding.
  • Thermodynamic Modeling: They used a simple thermodynamic model to predict TF binding across the genome and compared these predictions with ChIP-seq data to understand the biophysical basis of binding.
  • Fluorescence Microscopy: Cells were imaged to observe the effects of repressor expression on DNA replication and cell division.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-cognate binding is a significant fitness cost: The study provides strong evidence that even low-specificity binding of TFs to non-target DNA sites can severely inhibit bacterial growth. This isn't just theoretical; it has tangible consequences for survival.
  • Cooperativity amplifies low-specificity binding: TF cooperativity, where multiple TF molecules bind together, plays a crucial role in enhancing the impact of low-specificity binding. This suggests that the ability of TFs to oligomerize is a key factor in their promiscuity.
  • The TF-to-DNA ratio matters: The balance between the amount of TF and the total amount of genomic DNA influences the severity of growth inhibition. More DNA can "titrate away" TFs, reducing their non-cognate binding.
  • Prokaryotic TFs may be under selection to avoid promiscuity: Unlike eukaryotes, where some level of non-specific binding might be tolerated or even beneficial for gene regulation, prokaryotes might have evolved mechanisms to minimize it due to its detrimental fitness effects.
  • Cell division, not DNA replication, is the primary target: For λ CI, the observed growth inhibition is linked to an interference with cell division, leading to filamentation, rather than a direct impact on DNA replication.

Key Results

  • Expression of several phage repressors (λ CI, 434 CI, P22 C2) led to significant growth reductions in E. coli and/or S. enterica, with λ CI causing the most severe inhibition.
  • P22 C2, a more specific binder, showed effects primarily in non-native hosts, while Lacl, a single-target regulator, had minimal impact unless coupled with λ CI's cooperativity.
  • ChIP-seq data revealed that λ CI binds to numerous sites across the genome, not just its cognate operators, indicating widespread low-specificity binding.
  • Mutants of λ CI defective in DNA binding, dimerization, or cooperativity showed restored growth, highlighting the importance of these properties for the observed fitness cost.
  • Microscopy showed that λ CI expression leads to cell filamentation, suggesting an inhibition of cell division.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability to all TFs: While the study focused on repressors, the findings might not directly translate to all types of TFs (e.g., activators) without further investigation.
  • Environmental Specificity: The impact of non-cognate binding varied with environmental conditions, suggesting that the selective pressures on TF specificity might be context-dependent.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that understanding the interplay of costs and benefits of low-specificity interactions is crucial for synthetic biology. Further research could explore how these interactions drive evolution and how to engineer TFs for specific applications while mitigating toxicity. The study also opens questions about the evolutionary strategies prokaryotes employ to manage non-cognate binding.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Reliable operation of cellular programs depends crucially on the specificity of biomolecular interactions. In gene regulatory networks, the appropriate expression of genes is determined through the specific binding of transcription factors (TFs) to their cognate DNA sequences. However, the large genomic background likely contains many DNA sequences showing similarity to TF target motifs, potentially allowing for substantial non-cognate TF binding with low specificity. Whether and how non-cognate TF binding impacts cellular function and fitness remains unclear. We show that increased expression of different transcriptional regulators in Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica can significantly inhibit population growth across multiple environments. This effect depends upon (i) TF binding to a large number of DNA sequences with low specificity, (ii) TF cooperativity, and (iii) the ratio of TF to DNA. DNA binding due to the limited specificity of promiscuous or non-native TFs can thus severely impact fitness, giving rise to a fundamental biophysical constraint on gene regulatory design and evolution.
BibTeX
@misc{igler2021limited,
  author = {Claudia Igler and Claire Fourcade and Torsten Waldminghaus and Florian M. Pauler and Balaji Santhanam and Gašper Tkačik and Călin C. Guet},
  title = {{Limited specificity of molecular interactions incurs an environment-dependent fitness cost in bacteria}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.10.20.465141},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure