Limited Sampling Modeling for Estimation of Phenotypic Metrics for CYP Enzymes and the ABCB1 Transporter Using a Cocktail Approach

Eduardo Barbosa Coelho, Diego Alberto Ciscato Cusinato, João Paulo Bianchi Ximenez, Vera Lúcia Lanchote, Claúdio J. Struchiner, Guilherme Suarez‐KurtzFrontiers in Pharmacology 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops and validates "limited sampling strategies" (LSS) to accurately estimate how well key drug-metabolizing enzymes (CYPs) and transporters (like ABCB1) are working in the body, using just a few blood samples instead of many. This approach simplifies drug interaction studies and could lead to more efficient drug development and personalized medicine.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how an individual's body processes drugs is crucial for predicting drug efficacy and potential side effects. This processing is largely handled by a group of enzymes, primarily the Cytochrome P450 (CYP) family, and transporter proteins like ABCB1. Traditionally, assessing the activity of these "phenotypic metrics" involves administering specific "probe" drugs and then meticulously tracking their concentrations and those of their metabolites in the blood over an extended period. This often requires numerous blood draws, which can be inconvenient for participants and costly. The challenge, therefore, is to find ways to accurately measure these phenotypic metrics using fewer blood samples, making the process more practical and cost-effective. This paper aims to address this by developing and validating "limited sampling strategies" (LSS) for a cocktail of common drug probes.

Methods

The core of this study lies in developing and validating Limited Sampling Strategies (LSS). The researchers used plasma concentration data from 16 healthy adults who received a "cocktail" of sub-therapeutic doses of six selective probe drugs: caffeine (for CYP1A2), metoprolol (for CYP2D6), midazolam (for CYP3A), losartan (for CYP2C9), omeprazole (for CYP2C19), and fexofenadine (for ABCB1).

They employed all-subsets linear regression modeling to create LSS equations. This statistical technique explores all possible combinations of predictor variables (in this case, plasma concentrations at different time points) to find the best linear model for predicting the desired outcome (e.g., the area under the concentration-time curve, AUC, or ratios of parent drug to metabolite AUCs).

The models were developed using a "training set" of data and then validated using a separate "validation set." To assess the accuracy of the LSS models, they calculated the correlation coefficient (R²), which indicates how well the LSS-predicted values matched the "best estimates" derived from analyzing all available plasma data. Additionally, a jack-knife resampling technique was used as a further validation step, providing a robust assessment of the models' reliability. Bias and precision were also quantified using mean percentage difference (MD%) and mean absolute percentage difference (MAD%).

Datasets

The study utilized plasma concentration data from a previous trial involving 16 healthy volunteers. This dataset comprised 2,640 plasma concentration points collected over 12 hours after the administration of a cocktail of probe drugs. The data was split into a "training set" for developing the LSS models and a "validation set" for testing their accuracy. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the existing comprehensive dataset was leveraged for model development and validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Parsimony in Sampling: The study strongly supports the principle of parsimony in scientific measurement. By demonstrating that accurate phenotypic metrics can be derived from just one or two blood samples for certain probes, it highlights the potential to significantly reduce the burden on participants and researchers.
  • Probe-Specific Sampling Needs: A key finding is that different drug probes require different sampling strategies. While single time-point models were highly accurate for metoprolol and omeprazole (CYP2D6 and CYP2C19), probes for CYP1A2, CYP3A, and ABCB1 required two time points for comparable accuracy. This suggests that a "one-size-fits-all" approach to limited sampling is not optimal.
  • Ratio-Based Metrics are Efficient: The study found that using the ratio of parent drug to metabolite AUCs (e.g., metoprolol:α-OH metoprolol) allowed for highly accurate estimation even with a single sampling point. This is an important insight for designing future phenotyping cocktails.
  • Sub-Therapeutic Doses are Viable: The use of sub-therapeutic doses of probe drugs, combined with LSS, proved effective. This is advantageous as it minimizes the risk of drug-drug interactions between the probes themselves and reduces the potential for adverse effects in participants.

Key Results

  • Single-point LSS models achieved high accuracy (R² > 0.95) for estimating the AUC<sub>0-12h</sub> ratios of metoprolol:α-OH metoprolol and omeprazole:5-OH omeprazole.
  • Two-point LSS models were required to achieve R² > 0.95 for the AUC<sub>0-12h</sub> of caffeine, fexofenadine, and midazolam.
  • The developed LSS models demonstrated robustness across a wide range of phenotypic metric values during validation.
  • Increasing the number of sampling points beyond two led to minor improvements in accuracy, suggesting that two points often strike a good balance between accuracy and convenience.
  • The LSS models provided accurate predictions of phenotypic indices for CYP1A2, CYP2C19, CYP2D6, CYP3A, and ABCB1.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Exclusion of Poor Metabolizers: CYP2D6 poor metabolizers were excluded from the LSS modeling for metoprolol. This means the developed single- and two-point models for metoprolol may not be directly applicable to individuals with this specific genetic profile.
  • Small Cohort Size: The study involved a relatively small cohort of 16 healthy subjects. While this is comparable to other phenotyping cocktail studies, larger and more diverse populations would strengthen the generalizability of the findings.
  • Healthy Subjects Only: The study was conducted solely in healthy subjects. Future research should investigate the applicability of these LSS models in patient populations, where drug metabolism and transporter activity can be altered.
  • Sub-Therapeutic Doses: The modeling is based on sub-therapeutic doses of probe drugs. The relationship between phenotypic metrics and enzyme/transporter activity might not remain linear at higher probe doses, which could affect the applicability of these LSS models in certain drug interaction scenarios.

Future work could focus on extending these LSS models to include CYP2D6 poor metabolizers, validating them in diverse patient populations, and exploring their utility with different probe drug cocktails or higher doses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Plasma concentration data points (n = 2,640) from 16 healthy adults were used to develop and validate limited sampling strategies (LSS) for estimation of phenotypic metrics for CYP enzymes and the ABCB1 transporter, using a cocktail of subtherapeutic doses of the selective probes caffeine (CYP1A2), metoprolol (CYP2D6), midazolam (CYP3A), losartan (CYP2C9), omeprazole (CYP2C19), and fexofenadine (ABCB1). All-subsets linear regression modelling was applied to estimate the AUC<sub>0-12h</sub> for caffeine, fexofenadine, and midazolam, and the AUC<sub>0-12h</sub> ratio of metoprolol: α-OH metoprolol and omeprazole:5-OH omeprazole. LSS-derived metrics were compared with the parameters' 'best estimates' obtained by non-compartmental analysis using all plasma concentration data points. The correlation coefficient (<i>R</i> <sup>2</sup>) was used to identify the LSS equations that provided the best fit for <i>n</i> timed plasma samples, and the jack-knife statistics was used as an additional validation procedure for the LSS models. Single time-point LSS models provided <i>R</i> <sup>2</sup> values greater than 0.95 (<i>R</i> <sup>2</sup> > 0.95) for the AUC<sub>0-12h</sub> ratio of metoprolol:α-OH metoprolol and omeprazole:5-OH omeprazole, whereas 2 time-point models were required for <i>R</i> <sup>2</sup> > 0.95 for the AUC<sub>0-12h</sub> of caffeine, fexofenadine, and midazolam. Increasing the number of sampling points to three led to minor increases in <i>R</i> <sup>2</sup> and/or the bias or prediction of the estimates. In conclusion, the LSS models provided accurate prediction of phenotypic indices for CYP1A2, CYP2C19, CYP2D6, CYP3A, and ABCB1, when using subtherapeutic doses of selective probes for these enzymes and transporter.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{coelho2020limited,
  author = {Eduardo Barbosa Coelho and Diego Alberto Ciscato Cusinato and João Paulo Bianchi Ximenez and Vera Lúcia Lanchote and Claúdio J. Struchiner and Guilherme Suarez‐Kurtz},
  title = {{Limited Sampling Modeling for Estimation of Phenotypic Metrics for CYP Enzymes and the ABCB1 Transporter Using a Cocktail Approach}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pharmacology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fphar.2020.00022},
}
Figure