Limited nucleotide changes of HIV-1 subtype B Rev response element in China affect overall Rev-RRE activity and viral replication

Yuting Shi, Jingwan Han, Bo Zhu, Zhi Liu, Qingmiao Liang, Chunlin Lan, Zhengyang Li, Hanping Li, Yongjian Liu, Lei Jia, Tianyi Li, Xiaolin Wang, Jingyun Li, Bohan Zhang, Junjun Jiang, Lin LiFrontiers in Microbiology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

The HIV-1 Rev response element (RRE) is a cis-acting RNA element that facilitates the nuclear export of mRNA-containing introns by binding specifically to the Rev protein, enabling a critical step in the viral replication cycle. This study aims to determine the subtype-specific loci of HIV-1 subtype B RRE circulating in China and to analyze their effects on Rev-RRE function and HIV-1 replication. We amplified 71 HIV-1 subtype B RRE full-length sequences from the HIV patients' blood samples collected in China, analyzed the subtype-specific loci on them by comparing them with subtype B in the United States, and predicted their RNA secondary structures. Rev-RRE activity assay was used to test the binding activity of Rev and different RREs. Infectious clones were mutated to test the effect of the subtype-specific loci on replication capacity. In this study, two sites were determined to be the subtype-specific loci of HIV-1 subtype B RRE circulating in China. Both site 186 and site 56-57insAAC can significantly increase the viral mRNA transcription and Rev-RRE activity, but only the site 186 can significantly improve viral replication ability. Collectively, the subtype-specific loci of subtype B RRE circulating in China have a significant effect on the Rev-RRE activity and viral replication. This study investigates the subtype-specific loci of RRE, which are unique to retroviruses and essential for viral replication, and will help to explore the reasons why subtype B circulating in China is more widespread and persistent than American subtype B in China at the genetic level, and will provide theoretical support for the development of more inclusive detection and treatment methods for subtype B circulating in China. At the same time, it will also provide insight into the impact of different subtype HIV-1 genetic characteristics on viral replication.

Introduction: The Molecular Gatekeeper of HIV-1

HIV-1 is characterized by extreme genetic diversity. While Subtype B is a global variant, the strains circulating in China have diverged significantly from those found in the United States. This study investigates whether this divergence is merely genetic drift or if it provides a functional advantage to the virus.

The researchers focused on the Rev Response Element (RRE), a complex RNA structure that acts as a molecular gatekeeper. The RRE binds to the viral Rev protein to facilitate the export of large, intron-containing viral genetic material from the cell's nucleus to the cytoplasm for packaging into new virions. If this Rev-RRE interaction is inefficient, viral replication is severely hindered.

Functional requirement of the HIV-1 RRE in the viral replication cycle.

Methods and Datasets

The research team employed a multi-disciplinary approach to analyze 71 full-length RRE sequences from patients in Guangdong, Henan, and Hebei provinces, China. These were compared against 629 US-based subtype B sequences from the Los Alamos HIV Sequence Database.

  • Structural Modeling: Computational tools (RNAfold) predicted how mutations change the RNA’s physical shape, using Shannon entropy to measure structural flexibility.
  • Functional Assays: A reporter system measured p24 protein production (a proxy for viral output) in HeLa cells to evaluate different RRE/Rev combinations.
  • Replication Kinetics: Identified mutations were introduced into the standard NL4-3 HIV-1 infectious clone to observe growth rates in human T-cell lines (MT2 cells).

Key Insights: Shape-Shifting for Success

The study revealed that the sequence of the RRE RNA itself has a more profound impact on activity than the sequence of the Rev protein. A Chinese RRE paired with a US Rev protein still outperformed a US RRE.

A critical finding was the mutation at site 186 (G to A), which appears to shift the RRE from a 4-stem-loop (4-SL) structure to a more active 5-stem-loop (5-SL) structure. Furthermore, these mutations increased the "Shannon entropy" of the RNA, suggesting a more dynamic and flexible structure that likely facilitates the binding of multiple Rev proteins to initiate export.

Results and Implications

The researchers identified two primary genetic signatures unique to the Chinese RRE: a mutation at site 186 and an insertion at site 56-57 (insAAC).

While both modifications significantly boosted Rev-RRE functional activity and increased intracellular viral mRNA levels, only the G186A mutation significantly improved the actual replication rate of the virus (p < 0.0001). This mutation effectively increases viral "fitness," providing a genetic explanation for why this specific subcluster has become so dominant and persistent in China compared to imported American variants.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the structural findings are supported by computational models, physical mapping (such as SHAPE-MaP) is required to definitively confirm the 4-SL to 5-SL transition. Additionally, while the 56-57insAAC mutation increased mRNA levels, it did not boost overall replication, suggesting a potential bottleneck after the export phase that requires further study. Future research will also focus on correlating these specific mutations with clinical outcomes and disease progression in patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

The HIV-1 Rev response element (RRE) is a cis-acting RNA element that facilitates the nuclear export of mRNA-containing introns by binding specifically to the Rev protein, enabling a critical step in the viral replication cycle. This study aims to determine the subtype-specific loci of HIV-1 subtype B RRE circulating in China and to analyze their effects on Rev-RRE function and HIV-1 replication. We amplified 71 HIV-1 subtype B RRE full-length sequences from the HIV patients' blood samples collected in China, analyzed the subtype-specific loci on them by comparing them with subtype B in the United States, and predicted their RNA secondary structures. Rev-RRE activity assay was used to test the binding activity of Rev and different RREs. Infectious clones were mutated to test the effect of the subtype-specific loci on replication capacity. In this study, two sites were determined to be the subtype-specific loci of HIV-1 subtype B RRE circulating in China. Both site 186 and site 56-57insAAC can significantly increase the viral mRNA transcription and Rev-RRE activity, but only the site 186 can significantly improve viral replication ability. Collectively, the subtype-specific loci of subtype B RRE circulating in China have a significant effect on the Rev-RRE activity and viral replication. This study investigates the subtype-specific loci of RRE, which are unique to retroviruses and essential for viral replication, and will help to explore the reasons why subtype B circulating in China is more widespread and persistent than American subtype B in China at the genetic level, and will provide theoretical support for the development of more inclusive detection and treatment methods for subtype B circulating in China. At the same time, it will also provide insight into the impact of different subtype HIV-1 genetic characteristics on viral replication.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shi2022limited,
  author = {Yuting Shi and Jingwan Han and Bo Zhu and Zhi Liu and Qingmiao Liang and Chunlin Lan and Zhengyang Li and Hanping Li and Yongjian Liu and Lei Jia and Tianyi Li and Xiaolin Wang and Jingyun Li and Bohan Zhang and Junjun Jiang and Lin Li},
  title = {{Limited nucleotide changes of HIV-1 subtype B Rev response element in China affect overall Rev-RRE activity and viral replication}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2022.1044676},
}
Figure